Toll the Hounds Discussion Thread
#501
Posted 12 February 2008 - 08:26 PM
For the main plotline--we've discussed it. There are at least 3 "main plotlines" in MBOTF
1) the Crippled God
2) KE, its shattering and possible rebirth/healing
3) Malazan Empire itself (although by now it might become an ICE-mostly topic...
1) the Crippled God
2) KE, its shattering and possible rebirth/healing
3) Malazan Empire itself (although by now it might become an ICE-mostly topic...
#502
Posted 12 February 2008 - 09:21 PM
Exactly how old is Karsa, anyway? In DG Leoman says he's seen 17 summers. In HOC's he's about 80... young for Toblakai though. Just a slip?
#503
Posted 12 February 2008 - 09:25 PM
I think the accepted explanation was that mentally, attitude and experience wise, Karsa was a teenager. Actually he was far older than a normal humans lifespan. Think of the changes that had happened with the seaport since Karsa's grandfather attacked it.
#504
Posted 12 February 2008 - 10:49 PM
Traveller;258007 said:
Exactly how old is Karsa, anyway? In DG Leoman says he's seen 17 summers. In HOC's he's about 80... young for Toblakai though. Just a slip?
This is kind of random, but I don't recall Leoman and Karsa ever having real conversations. My point is that this might not be another GotM-ism; Leoman might be guessing at Karsa's age in DG.
I survived the Permian and all I got was this t-shirt.
#505
Posted 13 February 2008 - 12:42 AM
Well, for my money, the US cover art for Toll the Hounds is second only to the UK cover for Deadhouse Gates. I really like it and can't wait to pimp it on the blog tomorrow night!
Patrick
Patrick
For book reviews, author interviews, giveaways, related articles and news, and much more, check out www.fantasyhotlist.blogspot.com
#506
Posted 13 February 2008 - 01:35 AM
Pat you suck....I mean that in the nicest way possible...
How many fucking people do I have to hammer in order to get that across.
Hinter - Vengy - DIE. I trusted you you bastard!!!!!!!
Steven Erikson made drowning in alien cum possible - Obdigore
Hinter - Vengy - DIE. I trusted you you bastard!!!!!!!
Steven Erikson made drowning in alien cum possible - Obdigore
#507
Posted 13 February 2008 - 02:22 AM
Karsa was supposedly 80, which would be an equivalent of 17 years for a human, since TTT aren't human, and thus have diff. development and lifespans.
#508
Posted 13 February 2008 - 06:52 AM
So where is this cover?!?!?! its Wednesday. now....
wait I guess that depends on what part of the world your in
its almost 10 in the morning here in hell...
and I will go ahead and 13th the Karsa being 80ish thing... anything that suggest different is because the other character was
Guessing, drawing Parallels between human and teblor years (kinda of like we have dog years) or jut making shiz up
wait I guess that depends on what part of the world your in
its almost 10 in the morning here in hell...
and I will go ahead and 13th the Karsa being 80ish thing... anything that suggest different is because the other character was
Guessing, drawing Parallels between human and teblor years (kinda of like we have dog years) or jut making shiz up
You can't find me because I'm lost in the music
#509
Posted 13 February 2008 - 02:29 PM
kud13;258097 said:
Karsa was supposedly 80, which would be an equivalent of 17 years for a human, since TTT aren't human, and thus have diff. development and lifespans.
Here is that quote from DG... Leoman talking:
Quote
You are wrong. My companion is Toblakai, an escaped slave from the Laederon Plateau of Genabackis. He's seen seventeen summers and has personally killed forty-one enemies. Those are their ears on his belt.
EDIT: Did the Teblor have any initiation ceremonies like the Awl's Death Night? I don't have HoC on me... maybe 17 is the number of years since Karsa's first kill or something.
Forum Member from the Old Days. Alive, but mostly inactive/ occasionally lurking
#510
Posted 13 February 2008 - 02:31 PM
Leoman is of course also a great pillar of truth and reliability.
#511
Posted 13 February 2008 - 04:58 PM
I think somewhere in HoC it's mentioned that Teblor years and Human years aren't the same. Plus, by the time Kalam meets Karsa/Toblakai, he's already lost his clothes and killed way more than 41 enemies - that's probably a ref just to what he's done in Leoman's company since they met.
- Abyss, wonders why no one ever keeps their enemies' noses....
- Abyss, wonders why no one ever keeps their enemies' noses....
THIS IS YOUR REMINDER THAT THERE IS A
'VIEW NEW CONTENT' BUTTON THAT
ALLOWS YOU TO VIEW NEW CONTENT
'VIEW NEW CONTENT' BUTTON THAT
ALLOWS YOU TO VIEW NEW CONTENT
#512
Posted 13 February 2008 - 05:46 PM
Skywalker;258266 said:
Here is that quote from DG... Leoman talking:
EDIT: Did the Teblor have any initiation ceremonies like the Awl's Death Night? I don't have HoC on me... maybe 17 is the number of years since Karsa's first kill or something.
EDIT: Did the Teblor have any initiation ceremonies like the Awl's Death Night? I don't have HoC on me... maybe 17 is the number of years since Karsa's first kill or something.
Id say inconsistency or possible how long hes been with Karsa. Hes already by the time we see him in HOC.
#513
Posted 13 February 2008 - 05:55 PM
Agreed as im sure it was said early on in that book that he was in fact 80 odd?
"I think i was a bad person before. Before this time. I do not try to be good now but i am not bad. Perhaps if i try harder i may get a better hand dealt next time? But surely that makes it pointless? Perhaps i am good. Just good at being pointless. But that would make me bad. Bad at having a point. Ah…. I see now. I was nothing before, I am nothing now. I am bad purely because im pointless. "
EQ 10
EQ 10
#514
Posted 14 February 2008 - 06:12 AM
Yeah it says that early in House of Chains. 80 for a Teblor is like being 20-25 human age I guess.
#515
Posted 16 February 2008 - 05:57 PM
In a totally different direction, and from viewing the Toll the Hounds cover picture, got me thinking about the axe and the light.
In GotM, when Rake confronts the demon Galayn Lord:
The demon says "...I smell the reek of Tiama in you Lord..."
And as they fight, "The demon's ax flared bright white, cascading light like liquid. Rake's sword was swallowed in darkness, devouring the lashing waves of light that struck it."
And finally, "Rake began to launch attacks, savage swings of his black weapon. At first the demon held its ground, delivering fierce ripostes, then staggered back a step, then another. Relentless, Rake pressed his attack. 'To the Mother's regret,' he grated between blows, 'was Light granted birth. To her dismay...she saw too late...its corruption. Galayn...you are the unintended victim...to punishment...long overdue.' "
If the demon's weapon gives off light and Rake's weapon gives off dark, to simplify it, perhaps this is a subtle clue that the Light is the from the demon's plane of existence. If so, then Father Light was a demon probably corrupted by the power of Mother Dark and the creation of the new Tiste races, and that is why Rake said what he did, and why they all felt so betrayed.
Further, demons have the power to be soletaken dragons without Tiama, which they may have gotten from Father Light's corruption?
I'm probably not explaining this well, but as SE said he has given all the clues needed to figure it all out, maybe this idea has some merit. All the Tiste are certainly aware of the demon plane, which seems quite advanced as we see thru the use of many demons throughout the books so far.
Anyway, something to think about....
In GotM, when Rake confronts the demon Galayn Lord:
The demon says "...I smell the reek of Tiama in you Lord..."
And as they fight, "The demon's ax flared bright white, cascading light like liquid. Rake's sword was swallowed in darkness, devouring the lashing waves of light that struck it."
And finally, "Rake began to launch attacks, savage swings of his black weapon. At first the demon held its ground, delivering fierce ripostes, then staggered back a step, then another. Relentless, Rake pressed his attack. 'To the Mother's regret,' he grated between blows, 'was Light granted birth. To her dismay...she saw too late...its corruption. Galayn...you are the unintended victim...to punishment...long overdue.' "
If the demon's weapon gives off light and Rake's weapon gives off dark, to simplify it, perhaps this is a subtle clue that the Light is the from the demon's plane of existence. If so, then Father Light was a demon probably corrupted by the power of Mother Dark and the creation of the new Tiste races, and that is why Rake said what he did, and why they all felt so betrayed.
Further, demons have the power to be soletaken dragons without Tiama, which they may have gotten from Father Light's corruption?
I'm probably not explaining this well, but as SE said he has given all the clues needed to figure it all out, maybe this idea has some merit. All the Tiste are certainly aware of the demon plane, which seems quite advanced as we see thru the use of many demons throughout the books so far.
Anyway, something to think about....
"Yes, the owl was deliberate in each and every instance, and yes, it was intended to work on multiple levels." (from SE's Dec 09 Q&A)
#516
Posted 16 February 2008 - 08:13 PM
Abyss;258337 said:
I think somewhere in HoC it's mentioned that Teblor years and Human years aren't the same.
I'm assuming you mean that they age more slowly, not that they count time differently.
A quick, added note: Karsa's grandfather is old at close to five hundred years, giving us a rough estimate of their lifespans (Karsa thinks to himself that Silver Lake has been untouched for four-hundred years, since his grandfather's raid, and figure that Pahlk was at maturity when he left, or nearly a century old).
On top of which, the Imass discussing among themselves that the new child would require a century of waiting, so figure a few human years just for the pregnancy.
#517
Posted 17 February 2008 - 04:16 AM
ShadowOwl;259663 said:
In a totally different direction, and from viewing the Toll the Hounds cover picture, got me thinking about the axe and the light.
In GotM, when Rake confronts the demon Galayn Lord:
The demon says "...I smell the reek of Tiama in you Lord..."
And as they fight, "The demon's ax flared bright white, cascading light like liquid. Rake's sword was swallowed in darkness, devouring the lashing waves of light that struck it."
And finally, "Rake began to launch attacks, savage swings of his black weapon. At first the demon held its ground, delivering fierce ripostes, then staggered back a step, then another. Relentless, Rake pressed his attack. 'To the Mother's regret,' he grated between blows, 'was Light granted birth. To her dismay...she saw too late...its corruption. Galayn...you are the unintended victim...to punishment...long overdue.' "
If the demon's weapon gives off light and Rake's weapon gives off dark, to simplify it, perhaps this is a subtle clue that the Light is the from the demon's plane of existence. If so, then Father Light was a demon probably corrupted by the power of Mother Dark and the creation of the new Tiste races, and that is why Rake said what he did, and why they all felt so betrayed.
Further, demons have the power to be soletaken dragons without Tiama, which they may have gotten from Father Light's corruption?
I'm probably not explaining this well, but as SE said he has given all the clues needed to figure it all out, maybe this idea has some merit. All the Tiste are certainly aware of the demon plane, which seems quite advanced as we see thru the use of many demons throughout the books so far.
Anyway, something to think about....
In GotM, when Rake confronts the demon Galayn Lord:
The demon says "...I smell the reek of Tiama in you Lord..."
And as they fight, "The demon's ax flared bright white, cascading light like liquid. Rake's sword was swallowed in darkness, devouring the lashing waves of light that struck it."
And finally, "Rake began to launch attacks, savage swings of his black weapon. At first the demon held its ground, delivering fierce ripostes, then staggered back a step, then another. Relentless, Rake pressed his attack. 'To the Mother's regret,' he grated between blows, 'was Light granted birth. To her dismay...she saw too late...its corruption. Galayn...you are the unintended victim...to punishment...long overdue.' "
If the demon's weapon gives off light and Rake's weapon gives off dark, to simplify it, perhaps this is a subtle clue that the Light is the from the demon's plane of existence. If so, then Father Light was a demon probably corrupted by the power of Mother Dark and the creation of the new Tiste races, and that is why Rake said what he did, and why they all felt so betrayed.
Further, demons have the power to be soletaken dragons without Tiama, which they may have gotten from Father Light's corruption?
I'm probably not explaining this well, but as SE said he has given all the clues needed to figure it all out, maybe this idea has some merit. All the Tiste are certainly aware of the demon plane, which seems quite advanced as we see thru the use of many demons throughout the books so far.
Anyway, something to think about....
I like this idea, but Dragnipur was made by Draconus - not Anomander Rake.
I survived the Permian and all I got was this t-shirt.
#518
Posted 17 February 2008 - 06:38 AM
Hmmm
I always drew the connection Between Galayn Lord and Kurald Galain...
That's just me though...
EDIT: the US cover is actually well-done for once.... but why the wolves? and who's the dude witht he axe?
let us speculate!
I always drew the connection Between Galayn Lord and Kurald Galain...
That's just me though...
EDIT: the US cover is actually well-done for once.... but why the wolves? and who's the dude witht he axe?
let us speculate!
#519
Posted 17 February 2008 - 12:03 PM
There's already been a lot of speculation. No definite conclusions have been sought across.
I think it is the name alone which leads us to this connection.
I think it is the name alone which leads us to this connection.
#520
Posted 17 February 2008 - 12:09 PM
Slightly connected question... Anyone remember the meaning of Rake and Dragnipurs names?
Anomandaris Purake and Dragnipurake. I remember someone having a theory on the meaning of Purake.
Anomandaris Purake and Dragnipurake. I remember someone having a theory on the meaning of Purake.