[Sheltatha Lore]

Gust Hubb, on 31 July 2012 - 04:10 PM, said:

Sheltatha Lore, on 31 July 2012 - 04:06 PM, said:

Ideally the killers can convince them Kalse was deflecting off Tellan.


God, i hate finders. and given I was playing this game to draw a find, i'm somewhat unhappy.

Understandable. But you have to admit that this unintentional twist in the game has made it very interesting.

it would've been far more interesting if Kalse revealed me last night, instead of whilst i was asleep.

When I come on thread to find myself @ L-1, with 20 mins to go and aa BS find, there's only so much I can do in terms of damage control.

Though I am very happy they went for me instead of Kas.

[Gust Hubb]

Indeed. Puts the Finder in a pickle

[Vengeance]

Path-Shaper, on 31 July 2012 - 03:32 PM, said:

Vengeance, on 31 July 2012 - 03:06 PM, said:

Mott, on 30 July 2012 - 11:31 PM, said:

It was, in all honesty, a mistake, I wasn't thinking and didn't even catch my mistake for a bit. I decided though to just inform the finder that the scum would all CF as scum to them but the symp would still come up on thread, which might balance out the whole guard thing when it came to endgame since the finder would have to be more cautious about revealing and building cases.

I have been very remiss with all this, one of my relatives passed away last week and a family member was in a spot of bother, so I've been very distracted and preoccupied and this has all ended up quite a mess and no doubt there will be some angry players, I am very sorry I know people put time and effort into playing.

Completely understandable. FYI if you had wished to have taken a bit off from modding you can always let this thread know and several of us would/can jump in. It has been done before.

Thank you Venge, I flail around trying to fix these things, digging deeper holes for myself. I think it would have been a good idea but I was just not thinking really.

Completely understandable. The next game that you mod, Put PathShaper's and the MM password with the others in the first couple of posts. Then if someone needs to jump into PS or do a game update they can.

[Roldom]

nobody believes me going to read through SH and see who was who

[Sheltatha Lore]

Roldom, on 31 July 2012 - 04:54 PM, said:

nobody believes me going to read through SH and see who was who

serves you right for attacking the symp!!!

[Gust Hubb]

I'm not all that sympathetic SL (hehe, see what I did there?)

[Path-Shaper]

Too late Telas had a thought that could have tested Kalse's claim in amongst theorising

Quote

Atrahal -- pushing for tellan/rashan lynch, I don't like this but it could just be rash/risky town play.
Eloth -- no content really, pretty noncomittal, comments without getting involved. Seems a bit scummy to me, but we'll see what he has to say later (claimed he would weigh in with his opinions, I should hold him to that)
Sorrit -- pushing for kalse lynch; since I agree with him I'd say he's the least likely scum among the 4, though I can't count out some aggressive, scrambling-like distancing
Liosan -- Relatively absent, has curiously fallen off the radar (though the case against her wasn't all that strong).

It's hard to really say until Eloth does something. Otherwise I'd guess Atrahal/Liosan as our pair.

I'm not sure how Tellan and Rashan fit into this since it is still possible that Kalse was trying to distance from them.

Quote

Fuck I should've guarded Kalse!!!

BALLS

sfgjklsdhffjshgkljsdfhgklsdjfghsdklfjghsdklfjh

Quote

Well. Fuck. If I had guarded him and he said so on thread then he would be the real finder, and we could lynch kaschan for gg.

balls.

Quote

Provisional: Guard Liosan

Quote

(not that it makes a difference right now)

Quote

Sorrit, agreeing with me?!?!?!

MUST BE SCUM

Quote

Also if Lio isn't scum he probably dies tonight (if not myself). Least risky kill.

Quote

Guard Eloth

In case he tries to claim finder.

[Sheltatha Lore]

hehehehheehhehehe.......

[Roldom]

you took one hell of a bullet there SL, if they had lynched kaschan instead of you town would have a chance but now i think we have lost

[Roldom]

Good game,

it definitly made it more interesting haveing the symp find as scum! lol

If the symp had rolled inno I probably wouldnt of found kaschan.

alot of my play was all over the place, but once I revealed and SL came out as inno I was doomed!

[Path-Shaper]

Kill orders:

Kasch

Quote

I'm sticking with the plan, KL

Kill Eloth

[Path-Shaper]

Kalse's thoughts:

Quote

I bet at least one among Kaschan, Liosan, and Rashan (maybe throw Eloth in too) are scum. Fucking lurking--each of the first 3 have fewer posts than P-S.

Quote

If we want to get meta, atrahal should be logging back on in a few hours (assuming he actually is an aussie and went to bed at 2am). If night resolves around then...

Quote

btw, for people in SH: Yes, I've forgotten about a lot of the shit that happened the first 2 days. It's hard to keep track of all the associations and I don't quite have the attention span to look it all up.

[Mentalist]

hmmm

now i'm scared they're gonna vote off Rash based purely on the meta-timing of the kill issues.

[Eloth]

Interesting post i made about kasch and Rashan. I should have tried to get that Rashan lynch. Its not fair that scum get by so well just low posting.

[EmperorMagus]

Why Tellan? Why?

[Path-Shaper]

Sorrit's views on the players remaning players (yesterday) and Finder's CFs. He also seems to think Tapper is playing.

Quote

Emur Drek
Driss GH
Osseric blissy bear
Ruse vengy lol
SL ment
Sorrit the greatest
Kalse roldom
Kaschan 60
Rashan Ho
Tellan Tatts
Eloth EoM
Tennes Tapper
Liosan JLv
Atrahal KL
Telas starling

Best guesses. JLV might be tellan, though. Which shifts Tats to Liosan.

For the record, I thought Finders always CFed finder in low TMDI games. I've studied all the ones on the website. I saw trends, and they always CFed finder in my short time. So that was my only fault, imo. If you look at my argument thinking finder CFs fucking finder, kill Kalse DEAD.

DAMN MAFIA.

Quote

Tell tellan I love them, and I don't really think they're whiny brats. JLV is left, who is beyond awesome, Tapper, one of my fav people, starling and KL are sweethearts, oh I didn't think tellan could be starling or KL. I thought JLV for sure, then Tapper, since Tats was tennes.

Tellan <3!!

Tellan on other players:

Quote

I just realized Tats and I conflict a lot in mafia. You're like my new Mentalist, buddy. How does that make you feel?

Although to be fair I conflict a lot with everyone...


Also! I love playing with Gusty when he plays in the way he did this game. So very reasonable and well thought out.


Now I'm getting Brujah's thought vomit disease. AURGHHH

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 01 August 2012 - 01:23 AM

[Path-Shaper]

Telas:

Quote

Atrahal -- argued with sorrit, wanted to lynch tellan and liosan
Rashan -- voiced suspicions of tellan, low posting
Liosan -- made a case against atrahal (somewhat self-defense / omgus), has been against atrahal most of the game, narrowly dodged the osseric-semi-derail
Kaschan -- does nothing. Utterly unhelpful if town and coasting by if scum
Tellan -- been under the spotlight all game since the end of day 1. I need to review that in detail, there's a lot on this guy.
Sorrit -- went nuts earlier, hard to really get a read on him. Either he's being a really helpful-seeming scum or is just an overzealous townie.

Right now I think the most informative lynches would be Atrahal, Liosan, or Tellan.

I really want to lynch Kaschan, though, but he would only be scum if my fake-symp thing was true. Or Kalse was telling the truth and he did get a scum find on the symp SL, which I think is the least likely scenario.

Quote

Although based on all the little bits where Sorrit just doesn't get it, I keep thinking that it just doesn't jive with his helpful town act.

Quote

I still stand by my belief the town roles are guard/healer. Healer is probably dead by now, so I can't use guard to verify anything, only to try and be clutch if we can lynch 1 scum and end up with a mexican stand-off or something.

Quote

If tellan is really scum and is just capitalizing on my fake symp theory I think in just lost town the game. If so, sorry.

Quote

I could be reading way too much into this, but you corrected me on the guard partners bit shortly after I set a provisional on atrahal. This convinces me of tellan's case.

Quote

Then again that could have also applied to Rashan or Liosan. Neither of whom are remotely PI in my book. Balls.

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 01 August 2012 - 01:29 AM

[Gust Hubb]

Tellan (JLV), I have something for everyone, whether it be reasonable or batshit crazy. But I'm happy you think I'm a good reasoner.

And for Pete's sake, kill that bloody owl!!

[Mentalist]

Gust Hubb, on 01 August 2012 - 10:27 AM, said:

Tellan (JLV), I have something for everyone, whether it be reasonable or batshit crazy. But I'm happy you think I'm a good reasoner.

And for Pete's sake, kill that bloody owl!!

But-but, that's Merlin!

you can't kill Merlin!

[Roldom]

Rashans came through with a post full of speculation which makes him look like hes absent town, rather than coasting scum, everyone is adament my reveal was fake so kaschans in the clear.

town are all other the place, Its going to take something special to get a town win