Tsundoku, on 08 October 2022 - 01:50 PM, said:
Do you think the rat fucker could wriggle out of it? Or is he too far gone?
https://www.news.com...38f9905168567f8
The "Kherson Counteroffensive" snippet video is a bit overly-optimistic, and I doubt Poland are going to go into Belarus or Kaliningrad.
I think it's difficult to see him doing that kind of climbdown now. Before the annexation, sure, consolidate the borders of Luhansk and Donetsk and admit mission accomplished. I suspect Italy and Hungary would immediately turn on the rest of the EU/NATO alliance and start campaigning hard for lifting energy sanctions etc (maybe Turkey, though Turkey's glee at the idea of Russia losing Crimea and thus a possible future gun to Turkey's head is a bit too enticing for Erdogan). It would create division and the conditions for a climbdown, and would leave Ukraine unable to join NATO (because of the frozen conflict clause) and, without further military support, unlikely to retake the Donbas or Crimea.
After the annexations I don't see how that's possible. Even the most Putin-leaning advocates in other countries have acknowledged that stripping Ukraine of almost a quarter of its territory (and Russian doesn't even occupy all of that territory) is overreaching and simply untenable to support. So I don't really see a way around that block. Even giving territory back to Ukraine would require a constitutional amendment that would be a huge amount of palaver, although it's possible in the extreme that this could be factored in to peace talks (i.e. "very tough talks" where Russia gains Luhansk and Donetsk but Putin magnanimously gives back Kherson and Zaporizhzhia in return for, I don't know, the Azov Battalion being disbanded or some symbolic BS).
I suspect Putin's plan is to hold the territory Russia has now, using his 300,000/700,000/1 million reservists to exhaust Ukraine's offensive momentum and basically agree to a peace by holding the four oblasts, with the negotiations maybe being about resetting the borders of the oblasts to match the front lines, with an end to the sanctions as part of the final deal. The problem is that absolutely nobody, not even his own generals and supporters, seems to think this is in any way a realistic outcome.
The various articles positing a power struggle beneath Putin between his underlings for whose policies will get more attention seems quite likely and is happening now. Some are arguing for ramping things up and some are arguing for trying to hold this line, but the ones arguing for some kind of climbdown either aren't saying that publicly or have been firmly overruled. The rumour is that Shoigu and Gerasimov are both unhappy with being forced to fight the war under-resourced and would look to find a way out of it by switching to smaller and more achievable aims, but both also have a lot of personal loyalty to Putin and he trusts them quite a bit (handy for them as they have, by far, the most resources for a coup), so I don't see them making a play counter to Putin's orders just yet.
This post has been edited by Werthead: 08 October 2022 - 03:42 PM