Posted 28 August 2011 - 11:05 PM
ah fuck. well, i assume it's dday, right? fuck. you know i really don't like the choices of who is left. all you blokes are scummy in one way or another and fener (and thyr by proxy) was the last person to really stand out to me above all the rest of you.
apparently osseric's guard didn't work last night, so either he isn't the guard, he guarded the wrong person, or there are two killers and the healer managed to stop the other one on every previous night. osseric, which person did you guard last night? just to be sure. so here are my thoughts on each person:
barghast: fairly reasonable and helpful all game long, though often in the background until pressure is applied as in last friday, guarded on the night there was no NK
osseric: faithful guard, never confirmed, with only one night NK-less (guarding barghast for that matter) potentially under his belt. if he guarded barghast last night, then this is all just more confusing and makes me strongly suspect his reveal
anthras: one of the game's major spit fire, somewhat unreliable in his thinking, with several instances of getting "sidetracked" by things not necessarily relevant or helpful
karatalid: very vocal early on, especially when fighting off a day 1 lynch. moderate player, interjecting here and there, and very wishy-washy (right before the TS vote, Kara said I was pushing the fener/thyr thing awfully hard, and yet went along with the fener lynch fairly complacently)
silanah: hardest one for me to read (especially after korlat left the queue), quiet early on, helpful nearer to the end of the game, also a little more fiesty in posting style. not sure who the hell he is
thyr: probably the most controversial figure aside from fener for the whole game. does fener disavowing a connection to thyr mean thyr is the killer and fener was townie? does it mean fener was a symp and thyr was a killer? or does it mean thyr was town and the townie fener saw no reason to bind himself to thyr. i know there are other pairings, but i was waiting to see if fener's lynch could give me something else to go off of. sadly, fener's lynch was disappointing (inno could be symp or town, and we will never know) and now i just don't know.
d'riss: fener's early pick, a very cantankerous persona that like anthras has a lot of bluster and anger issues. his thought processes are likewise a little confused, and from earlier posts it seems like korlat was his top pick until i convinced people to move in on fener.
telas: confused all game long with unconfirmed gut reactions to several players now dead and inno, with no confirmation of those players' orientation. definitely not the best poster of the game, but fairly straightforward if not naive in play style. probably going to be today's top lynch catch of the day
so i guess, for what it's worth, i will put my guesses in order of scumminess. guys, i am just flat out lost this game and am not sure where to go on this supposed D-day. i may, if i have a chance, go back and look at people's last argument for lynching someone (maybe reveal something manipulative, scummy?), though by all means, somebody can beat me to that analysis.
d'riss>kara>silanah>barghast>anthras>thyr>osseric
this order will change dramatically if osseric guarded barghast last night, btw
sorry guys, i'll try to post later, but this cold and confusion is definitely getting me down