[Fener]

Osseric, on 26 August 2011 - 07:28 AM, said:

Well hi everyone, I wanted to gauge reaction from certain people but they have not been around to add any comments. I guarded Barghast last night and no kill came through, our healer (if we have one) is silent, our finder has had no luck even if he is still alive so I'd think about voting off Barghast, i'm sick of following other people, I personally think Fener and Thyr are innocent, I also think Telas is playing for the innocents. Anyway I won't be around for a good part of today, (my fiancé's brother and wife have had a baby so i'm travelling to see her)

Vote Barghast

Without wild speculation on Fener again no less, I think he is the best bet for scum today, and Silanah, after that post IGMEOY

Catch you later

Vote Barghast

[Fener]

Karatallid, on 26 August 2011 - 07:43 AM, said:

I think we should vote night and see if osseric can guard barghast again.


If it works then we keep guarding barghast and then we can find the other killer without worrying about night kill?

watcha think?

[Fener]

[Barghast]

Fener, on 27 August 2011 - 01:54 AM, said:

Osseric, on 26 August 2011 - 07:28 AM, said:

Well hi everyone, I wanted to gauge reaction from certain people but they have not been around to add any comments. I guarded Barghast last night and no kill came through, our healer (if we have one) is silent, our finder has had no luck even if he is still alive so I'd think about voting off Barghast, i'm sick of following other people, I personally think Fener and Thyr are innocent, I also think Telas is playing for the innocents. Anyway I won't be around for a good part of today, (my fiancé's brother and wife have had a baby so i'm travelling to see her)

Vote Barghast

Without wild speculation on Fener again no less, I think he is the best bet for scum today, and Silanah, after that post IGMEOY

Catch you later

Vote Barghast

So, you vote along, which is OK, I guess, but as your motivation, you quote a bit of text that has been rubbished by a lot of people, incluing Osseric himself? Either that is lazy (could have posted something you think I'm scum) or you simply just looked no further and jumped on my train to keep an alternative to your own open. If you are town, I am disappointed. Apart from showing you want to live to play the game, you also make no effort whatsoever to dispell the doubts we have on you.
If you're scum, well, as much as I hate to say it,

[Barghast]

Quote

If you're scum, well, as much as I hate to say it,

a minimum of effort got you really, really far. And I'll have to seriously rethink my theorycraft.

[Fener]

Barghast, on 27 August 2011 - 07:18 AM, said:

Fener, on 27 August 2011 - 01:54 AM, said:

Osseric, on 26 August 2011 - 07:28 AM, said:

Well hi everyone, I wanted to gauge reaction from certain people but they have not been around to add any comments. I guarded Barghast last night and no kill came through, our healer (if we have one) is silent, our finder has had no luck even if he is still alive so I'd think about voting off Barghast, i'm sick of following other people, I personally think Fener and Thyr are innocent, I also think Telas is playing for the innocents. Anyway I won't be around for a good part of today, (my fiancé's brother and wife have had a baby so i'm travelling to see her)

Vote Barghast

Without wild speculation on Fener again no less, I think he is the best bet for scum today, and Silanah, after that post IGMEOY

Catch you later

Vote Barghast

So, you vote along, which is OK, I guess, but as your motivation, you quote a bit of text that has been rubbished by a lot of people, incluing Osseric himself? Either that is lazy (could have posted something you think I'm scum) or you simply just looked no further and jumped on my train to keep an alternative to your own open. If you are town, I am disappointed. Apart from showing you want to live to play the game, you also make no effort whatsoever to dispell the doubts we have on you.
If you're scum, well, as much as I hate to say it,

[Fener]

Barghast, on 27 August 2011 - 09:08 AM, said:

Quote

If you're scum, well, as much as I hate to say it,

a minimum of effort got you really, really far. And I'll have to seriously rethink my theorycraft.

[Fener]

Barghast, on 27 August 2011 - 09:08 AM, said:

Quote

If you're scum, well, as much as I hate to say it,

a minimum of effort got you really, really far. And I'll have to seriously rethink my theorycraft.

[Path-Shaper]

Day 4

15 hours left of the day. The week end freeze is in effect.

10 players still alive: Barghast, Osseric, Anthras, Karatallid, Silanah, Korlat, Thyrllan, Fener, D'riss.

6 votes to lynch.
5 votes to go to night.

2 votes for Barghast (Osseric, Fener)
4 votes for Fener (Telas, Karatallid, Korlat, Thyrllan)

Players that have yet to vote: Barghast, Anthras, Silanah, D'riss.

[Fener]

Barghast, on 27 August 2011 - 07:18 AM, said:

Fener, on 27 August 2011 - 01:54 AM, said:

Osseric, on 26 August 2011 - 07:28 AM, said:

Well hi everyone, I wanted to gauge reaction from certain people but they have not been around to add any comments. I guarded Barghast last night and no kill came through, our healer (if we have one) is silent, our finder has had no luck even if he is still alive so I'd think about voting off Barghast, i'm sick of following other people, I personally think Fener and Thyr are innocent, I also think Telas is playing for the innocents. Anyway I won't be around for a good part of today, (my fiancé's brother and wife have had a baby so i'm travelling to see her)

Vote Barghast

Without wild speculation on Fener again no less, I think he is the best bet for scum today, and Silanah, after that post IGMEOY

Catch you later

Vote Barghast

So, you vote along, which is OK, I guess, but as your motivation, you quote a bit of text that has been rubbished by a lot of people, incluing Osseric himself? Either that is lazy (could have posted something you think I'm scum) or you simply just looked no further and jumped on my train to keep an alternative to your own open. If you are town, I am disappointed. Apart from showing you want to live to play the game, you also make no effort whatsoever to dispell the doubts we have on you.
If you're scum, well, as much as I hate to say it,

REmove vote

VOte Telas

[Osseric]

Remove Vote

Vote Fener

I see people do not want to be played big time if Fener turns out to be scum, but I highly doubt it, it is more likely that scum are riding his train, we have no new info regarding Fener yet we have info on the night last night, and scummy play by Kara. The posts where he is arguing with Thyr provide us with information, lynching Fener does not, if Fener comes out innocent where does that leave us? Telas with his "gut" feeling all game, Kara voting for him when we could have done this any day for the exact same reasoning as now, if Telas and Kara turn out to be symps protecting Barghast and Anthras then town will be royally fucked by lynching Fener.

In that scenario do we as town lose today? Cause that would mean they have a 4 team voting block.

Remove Vote

I'll be back on later to add a vote, it would be good to get a lynch this weekend so we have more time to discuss the aftermath.

[Karatallid]

I would rather have gone to night and tested if you can block barghast again. But everyone seems to be conveniently ignoring the odd/even rule scenario...so whatever ill just carry one with lynching who i feel is scum then.

I dont like that fener came straight on and followed your vote on barghast with nothing more than your reveal that you guarded him.
Its a knee jerk reactiion and a mistake that is as old as mafia itself. The classic guard revealing he "blocked" somebody when in fact the healer healed a nk and we end up lynching a random guard choice as a result. Its happened countless times and its stupid. I would rather not be mislead by faulty logic!
This is a M & P game.
We know that there is no way that a guard can be so powerful.
You are effectively a finder and you can stop ALL kills from day one?
Never...ever...sorry. Not a chance.

Fener thinks its good enough...Well i dont, Its misleading at best and i fear the scum know this.
And have had a change of heart with regards to him and thyr.
Simple as that.
If they are playing us for fools i would rather test it out now, while we still have a chance of getting it wrong.
who knows maybe your guard will work on barghast again, maybe the healer will stop another kill.

Imagine if we dont test one of them out today?...we sure as shit are not going to do it tomorrow. the longer we wait the more difficult it gets.
Yes we should have tried out on day one or two. But we didnt, then we thought it was a silencing and not a role, Fener in fact implied that someone did this too him...wich on of itself is contradictory to the whole concept if you look at it now.
When it didnt change to another person we spent another few days trying to figure it out but still giving them the benefit of the doubt...welll...shit...now we are at a crossroads

Im willing to chance it.
If anything they must be bloody symps or something....shit

[Karatallid]

I would rather have gone to night and tested if you can block barghast again. But everyone seems to be conveniently ignoring the odd/even rule scenario...so whatever ill just carry one with lynching who i feel is scum then.

I dont like that fener came straight on and followed your vote on barghast with nothing more than your reveal that you guarded him.
Its a knee jerk reactiion and a mistake that is as old as mafia itself. The classic guard revealing he "blocked" somebody when in fact the healer healed a nk and we end up lynching a random guard choice as a result. Its happened countless times and its stupid. I would rather not be mislead by faulty logic!
This is a M & P game.
We know that there is no way that a guard can be so powerful.
You are effectively a finder and you can stop ALL kills from day one?
Never...ever...sorry. Not a chance.

Fener thinks its good enough...Well i dont, Its misleading at best and i fear the scum know this.
And have had a change of heart with regards to him and thyr.
Simple as that.
If they are playing us for fools i would rather test it out now, while we still have a chance of getting it wrong.
who knows maybe your guard will work on barghast again, maybe the healer will stop another kill.

Imagine if we dont test one of them out today?...we sure as shit are not going to do it tomorrow. the longer we wait the more difficult it gets.
Yes we should have tried out on day one or two. But we didnt, then we thought it was a silencing and not a role, Fener in fact implied that someone did this too him...wich on of itself is contradictory to the whole concept if you look at it now.
When it didnt change to another person we spent another few days trying to figure it out but still giving them the benefit of the doubt...welll...shit...now we are at a crossroads

Im willing to chance it.
If anything they must be bloody symps or something....shit

[Osseric]

Vote Fener

I have my guard in place.

I agree this then would be the moment to test Fener, he hasn't been helpful, not at all, if he is town (which I think he may well be) he hasn't helped by pointing fingers and not giving reasons. Bye bye Fener.

[Path-Shaper]

15 hours left of the day. The week end freeze is in effect.

10 players still alive: Barghast, Osseric, Anthras, Karatallid, Silanah, Korlat, Thyrllan, Fener, D'riss.

6 votes to lynch.
5 votes to go to night.

1 vote for Telas (Fener)
5 votes for Fener (Telas, Karatallid, Korlat, Thyrllan, Osseric)

Players that have yet to vote: Barghast, Anthras, Silanah, D'riss.

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 28 August 2011 - 03:04 PM

[Karatallid]

I wonder where barghast is with his obligatory hammer?

[D'riss]

I have a few moments to check in. Looks like we have a Fener train going... Not sure how much I agree with it. It could be D day and people are being awefully cavalier about their votes. If Fener comes back inno and we don't end the game I am coming after Telas and Korlat hard tomorrow. Also, there are 2 inno's on the current Fener train, Me and Osseric. I don't really like how quick it built, and I don't like that Thyr is on the train. That effectively blows up the combo theory, If Fener comes back inno. That being said, this is an M&P and a silenced and 3rd person talker are rather weird...


vote Fener


*crosses fingers*

[Path-Shaper]

It is day 4. The day has ended.

10 players still alive: Barghast, Osseric, Anthras, Karatallid, Silanah, Korlat, Thyrllan, Fener, D'riss.

6 votes to lynch.
5 votes to go to night.

1 vote for Telas (Fener)
6 votes for Fener (Telas, Karatallid, Korlat, Thyrllan, Osseric, D'riss)

Players that have yet to vote: Barghast, Anthras, Silanah, D'riss.


End of day pending

[Path-Shaper]

Discussing back and forth you agree on little. Except a joint hatred for Fener and his picture drawing ways. A picture might say more than a 1000 words but it's clearly not the words you want to hear. Perhaps if he'd whisper that single phrase you always wanted to hear: "I love you and I want you. I want you now!". Alas for you, or perhaps more correctly, alas for Fener, he never did return that hot, festering love you felt ever since you first set eyes on his massive, manly physique.

You turn towards him as one. Anger, lust, and most of all hurt shine from your eyes. Together you beat him down, slowly reducing his hunkish shape into nothing more than bloody flesh. All the while you cry sweet sweet tears of release.

Fener (vengyboy) is dead. He was innocent.

[D'riss]

.....