[Vengeance]

Khellendros, on 31 August 2011 - 08:29 PM, said:

Really excellent game, I really enjoyed that one, couldn't pull myself away I am sorry about the RP, but once I went past day 1 there was no way I could go back without automatically getting lynched

Rep coming to a lot of people, dkt and Tapper were outstanding.

Me too. Exactly the same.

[Tapper]

There's still plenty of people to rep, but I'm out of it for today . You had me sweating a lot, folks

This post has been edited by Tapper: 31 August 2011 - 09:58 PM

[Morgoth]

All in all I greatly enjoyed modding this game. The killers got the moral victory in my opinion, especially as the game was stacked a little in the innos' favour.

[Khellendros]

The more I look back on it the more obvious Tapper as scum becomes: Karatallid's ignoring of Barghast as one of those who cast lengthy doubt on Osseric's reveal, and when Kalse-Grief was killed and I suggested we look carefully at why the killers might have gone for Kalse, there appeared Barghy-Tapper, to say, "now now, let's not not get fixated on Kalse's death..." Scummy scum scum!

And both Tapper and ansible made the consistently smoothest, slimiest posts of anyone - was it Tapper who also said we shouldn't equate smooth play with scummy play, rather look at it as an inno playing well? The sheer audacity!

[Tattersail_]

dktorode, on 31 August 2011 - 04:03 PM, said:

well anyways....had fun...thats what counts.


glad we got Osseric to vote Telas at the end there

If I was a good case builder then Barghy and Silanah would have went days ago, but i'm not as Barghy says in one of his PM's. Well played, back of my mind I was thinking you two were scum but I went for love rather than hate and look where that would have took us

[Tattersail_]

All in all, the finder reveal by Barghast was great play, we all thought there could have been a finder and by him saying kara was innocent it was 50/50 whether you believe him, maybe the golden rule at that stage would be to always ALWAYS test the finder. However if we did here we would have got an innocent CF

[Tapper]

Khellendros, on 01 September 2011 - 12:03 AM, said:

The more I look back on it the more obvious Tapper as scum becomes: Karatallid's ignoring of Barghast as one of those who cast lengthy doubt on Osseric's reveal, and when Kalse-Grief was killed and I suggested we look carefully at why the killers might have gone for Kalse, there appeared Barghy-Tapper, to say, "now now, let's not not get fixated on Kalse's death..." Scummy scum scum!

And both Tapper and ansible made the consistently smoothest, slimiest posts of anyone - was it Tapper who also said we shouldn't equate smooth play with scummy play, rather look at it as an inno playing well? The sheer audacity!

Well Khell, my disagreement with Osseric was not very lengthy and had more to do with outrage over the sheer "unconventionality" of it than with a genuine desire to lynch him/ cast doubt on his reveal.

And NKs are wifom. Everybody knows. initially, that was one post where I overextended myself, however. I should have rolled with it, shrugged accusations aside as wifom when they came instead of pre-emptively, and it is true: I made no waves but then, I did nothing stupid either and I was not questioned or pressured at all, so it was not made especially hard to coast through, either.