worry, on 29 March 2022 - 04:07 AM, said:
Seemed reasonable to me (in terms of order of events). WS hears the joke and does a polite laugh for the camera, then it dawns on him that it's an alopecia joke and not a run of the mill razzing, then he gets up and gives CR a warning slap. It's not a "let's throw down" slap, it's a "watch what you say" slap.
I think the problem with this is that it crossed a line that's never really been crossed. Smith didn't just slap Rock. He was a rich and famous actor who got up in front of a room full of his peers, and on live TV in front of millions and slapped a comedian for telling a joke.
This means he slapped Don Rickles. He slapped Dave Chapelle. He slapped Ricky Gervais. He slapped Richard Pryor. And really every other risky comedian. This normalized attacking a person doing their job because you didn't like the words they said while doing that job.
Yes, in normal circumstances this would not be as big a deal a it is. But this isn't normal circumstances.
Just like every other instance of people getting away with this kind of thing, this will embolden some people that this is okay to do now.
And I'd also love to know where the proverbial "line" is? Because that line moves for every individual person.
So either we hold
all comedians accountable and no jokes that might offend a certain person are okay, or we accept that many jokes won't be to our personal taste. And you know what? If that's the way the pendulum wants to swing, fine, but let's
keep that energy for
everyone that tells jokes we don't like then.
worry, on 29 March 2022 - 04:07 AM, said:
Anyway, aside from the extraordinary setting, it's their private business and I'm sure will be settled (or not) privately with maybe a few press releases since they're all public figures.
Nah. This closing of ranks around this is not going to fly. These two men made this not only a public event, but as public as you can probably get. This is not and never was a private matter at that point.
If this was a private matter...it would have happened behind closed doors and we would have maybe heard about it later. Like Brad Pitt supposedly holding Weinstein accountable for his behaviour with Gwyneth Paltrow behind closed doors in the late 90's. THAT was a private matter, that we heard about later. If Pitt walked up in the Oscar stage and slapped Weinstein...we would not only be talking about it, it would be long remembered and discussed. This is no different.
If they air it in a public space, people get to weigh in. Not sorry. They made it everyones business by sucking the energy out of the night for a personal tiff.
I feel bad for people like Questlove, and the cast and producers of CODA whose big night is obliterated by this utter high school nonsense.
worry, on 29 March 2022 - 04:07 AM, said:
Hopefully it will escape the discourse machine sooner rather than later (I don't mean the board or other civilians, I mean the actual vultures who get paid by the take).
Oh I think it will. People are already sick of talking about it.
And no they won't take Will's Oscar...lots of people who have done WAY way shittier things have and kept Oscars.
As an aside: Watching people trip over themselves to try differentiate between a bald-head/Alopecia joke and the literal DECADES of male hair loss/bald jokes is amusing to me as if they are wildly different things instead of both being "making fun of genetic traits that can't be helped". Like Smith himself spent 4 damned seasons making bald and fat jokes at the expense of Uncle Phil (James Avery) with jokes not written by him (just like Rock reading jokes not written by him at the Oscars)...but that's apparently okay, while this is not?
"When the last tree has fallen, and the rivers are poisoned, you cannot eat money, oh no." ~Aurora
“Someone will always try to sell you despair, just so they don't feel alone.” ~Ursula Vernon