Trull, on 28 March 2012 - 07:48 PM, said:
Has anyone managed to get a hold of Shogun 2 Fall of the samurai (TW stand-alone expansion)? I loved Shogun 2 (my second favorite in the series, after Rome of course). I'm not sure if I should dish out cash right away for this, as there seems to be a lot of change in terms of tech and political management. Less politics and more guns by the looks of it. To the players of TWEmpire, you understand how guns can fundamentally change the feel of the game. Looks good overall I guess, but I was hoping to get an opinion from the malazans if possible.
I bought it and have so far spent 15 minutes on it.
It seems both Imperialists and Shogun-supporters are going to tech up to guns, which was a bit of a pity. I also thought the amount of different units at your disposal is rather slim (1 each of sword, spear, bow foot units, several tiers of gun units including skirmishers, and each side a mounted gun men and a lancer unit, plus 3 or 4 foreign units which are basically all the same apart from a few point spreads (French foreign legion, British marines, US Marines). Fleets are likewise the same for each faction - Imperial factions have 1 "unique" elite gun unit each - I guess the same is true for the Shogunate factions, or maybe they have sword units to reflect a more traditional approach).
In vanilla Shogun 2, the lack of clan-unique units was fine because there was such an intricate balance between different type of units, but it seems in the add-on guns > other units. Which just calls for gun-toting units-spamming for your front line with maybe a unit or 3 of swordsmen to give you the edge if it comes to melee.
Imho, after the very little bit I've seen of it € 9.99 like the Napoleon add-on Spanish campaign would have been a decent price, certainly not € 29.99.
But, like I said, I played 2 turns and checked the tech tree and the upgrade tree for generals and the available agents. Once I sink some decent time into it, I may know more. Gotta finish Napoleon first to unlock several achievements, though - and maybe try and see if Empire looks better after Napoleon than it did before.
Everyone is entitled to his own wrong opinion. - Lizrad