Cause, on 17 March 2026 - 05:38 PM, said:
Joe Kent, I seem to remember was controversial for being a far right nut.
The idea that Israel, AIPAC or American Jews can somehow get America to go to war against its own interests is absurd.
Anthony Blinken has already come out and said that Netanyahu tried this with both Obama and Biden and both of them told him no...Trump was just the idiot he needed to say yes.
And I'm sorry, you'll never convince me that Israel doesn't have an outsized influence on US politics in this day and age.
Also please remember we are discussing Israel the State, not Jewish people or Judaism, or any diaspora therein.
Cause, on 17 March 2026 - 05:38 PM, said:
The 6 million Jewish votes (typically vote democrat anyway) would be countered by the 4 million Arab votes.
The global Jewish influence of 18 million people would be countered I imagine by the 500 million Arab block and 1.5 billion additional Muslims.
The Jewish banking/hollywood/illuminati elite would be countered by the entirety of OPECs control over oil, Saudi’s Arabia, Qatar etc
Being Jewish (American or otherwise) is not the same as Israel the State (especially the state under the far right leaders its largely had since the 80's). Those are different things, and conflating them allows the narrative that Netanyahu and his crew like to push. No one is talking about American Jewish people or any other jewish people. We are talking about Israel the state.
Cause, on 17 March 2026 - 05:38 PM, said:
The US interest in Israel was to counter the soviets
Nah, it was to usurp Oil interests in a region they didn't have authority in post WWII.
Cause, on 17 March 2026 - 05:38 PM, said:
then to control oil interests
It was ALWAYS this. From the minute that Britain and France abandoned their full support for a more genial distant support, the US saw oil interest and snapped at it in the only country they felt they could at the time. The Petrodollar didn't arrive out of the ether, it was planned.
Cause, on 17 March 2026 - 05:38 PM, said:
then to counter terroism.
A non-legal pejorative that means whatever the accuser wants it to mean. That word gets tossed around a lot, the nuance of the region is far, far more buried under decades of foreign policy choices the US and Israel have made when they wing that word out.
Cause, on 17 March 2026 - 05:38 PM, said:
In fact America originally supported Israel as a way to not take in Jewish refugees.
This was the British more than anyone else going back to 1917...America supported them for oil interest/access in the region. It might have coincided with not taking in Jewish refugees...but the main goal was oil. I don't know how many times it bears repeating.
Cause, on 17 March 2026 - 05:38 PM, said:
It then ignored Israel and tried to court the Arab bloc during the Cold War but was rejected in favor of the soviets which forced them into aligning with Israel as the only alternative in the region.
For oil.
And then Citizens United happened and the US was lobbied into the sun with money. Is it normal to send a foreign nation the untold billions if they were just an ally and not lobbying the US govt for things it wants as a state?
"When the last tree has fallen, and the rivers are poisoned, you cannot eat money, oh no." ~Aurora
"Someone will always try to sell you despair, just so they don't feel alone." ~Ursula Vernon