[Okaros]

So Iparth has come on thread, and quoted a few posts and replied to them. He hasn't cast a vote. Trake has come on and has analysed the thread from his point of view. Alkend has followed my reasoning although he thinks Iparth is more likely recruiter. Kaschan has not been around. At this stage it looks like we won't lynch and we will lose. RL sucks sometimes. Come on Kaschan, come back to the thread. I am waiting to see what Iparth adds, and then I am going to vote Mockra.

Mockra what is your role name? Iparth what is yours? Most others have been free with this information, and seem as this is d day it is the right time to let us know.

[Okaros]

Feels like cult are being hush hush, thinking timeout will win them the game.

[Okaros]

4 hours left in the day roughly I think.

[Trake]

I'll be on properly in about 30 minutes when I get to work, and then should be around till timeout.

[Alkend]

Lack of any movement in that direction makes me believe Mockra might have been the right call

[Okaros]

I have not voted yet, I want to see what Iparth and Trake are going to do. I believe the cultist only has 1 member, but I do have what you have said in the back of my mind Alkend. Other than that dodgy post which could disprove your reveal I am willing to overlook that at the moment. I do have a good thought but do not want to share it until others have said what they need to.

[Alkend]

When you say 1 member, do you mean leader + recruit, or just the leader? Because if the latter, that seems rather unlikely.

[Trake]

I'm continuing my reread now. I'm hesitant to believe that Mockra is the recruiter pretty much just because of their day 1 play. However, I'm reading trying to read through their posts now with the idea that they were recruited at some point in the game, and seeing if anything stands out as changing in their behaviour towards other players, and see if that then points to someone.

I'll be doing that for Iparth and Alkend too. If there's time I'll do Okaros too just in case, but I suspect I won't get around to them in time.

[Okaros]

Alkend, on 15 March 2017 - 11:05 AM, said:

When you say 1 member, do you mean leader + recruit, or just the leader? Because if the latter, that seems rather unlikely.

Leader plus recruit.

[Okaros]

Trake, on 15 March 2017 - 11:20 AM, said:

I'm continuing my reread now. I'm hesitant to believe that Mockra is the recruiter pretty much just because of their day 1 play. However, I'm reading trying to read through their posts now with the idea that they were recruited at some point in the game, and seeing if anything stands out as changing in their behaviour towards other players, and see if that then points to someone.

I'll be doing that for Iparth and Alkend too. If there's time I'll do Okaros too just in case, but I suspect I won't get around to them in time.

I think behaviour of players from the reveal and where they voted is more telling than how you play day one. I am listening though, see what you dig up.

[Okaros]

Can we get a time update please?

[Alkend]

2:20 to go, based on the last update.

[Trake]

Huh, an interesting thing I've just come across while reading through Mockra's posts:

Okaros actually mentioned recruiters knowing who they recruit well before Alkend speculated on that, so now it looks a bit strange of Okaros to raise it as a point against Alkend.

[Trake]

Alkend and Mockra have disagreements throughout.

Mockra gets into a disagreement with Hanas pre-reveal, calls their post, to paraphrase, copied bullshit, quite close to calling someone scummy, but is all about Gamelon post-reveal. I think that they could be recruited. And if a Hanas cultist, then that really doesn't get us anywhere.

[Okaros]

Trake, on 15 March 2017 - 12:11 PM, said:

Huh, an interesting thing I've just come across while reading through Mockra's posts:

Okaros actually mentioned recruiters knowing who they recruit well before Alkend speculated on that, so now it looks a bit strange of Okaros to raise it as a point against Alkend.

Bring up relevant post please. If I thought it a huge deal I may have voted towards Alkend.

[Trake]

This is the post I came across:

Mockra, on 08 March 2017 - 12:32 AM, said:

Iparth Erule, on 08 March 2017 - 12:28 AM, said:

Mockra, on 08 March 2017 - 12:13 AM, said:

Iparth Erule, on 07 March 2017 - 09:09 PM, said:

Okaros, on 07 March 2017 - 09:00 PM, said:

You would think the recruiters might want a juicier role than mine anyway as they will know who they recruit.

That seems a very specific bit of knowledge of the recruitment process

Uhm... Since they start out with no one on their teams, I assume the recruiters would be the ones doing the recruiting...

"They know who they recruit" sounds rather like knowing their character name. The only people who would know if a recruiter learns the character name is the recruiters.

Vote Okaros

Ok, I see your point.

Or, hold on, was your post there about yourself specifically?

[Trake]

Shit, I've totally forgotten about Kaschan. Though I doubt I'll find much in their posts either way.

[Okaros]

Trake, on 15 March 2017 - 12:25 PM, said:

This is the post I came across:

Mockra, on 08 March 2017 - 12:32 AM, said:

Iparth Erule, on 08 March 2017 - 12:28 AM, said:

Mockra, on 08 March 2017 - 12:13 AM, said:

Iparth Erule, on 07 March 2017 - 09:09 PM, said:

Okaros, on 07 March 2017 - 09:00 PM, said:

You would think the recruiters might want a juicier role than mine anyway as they will know who they recruit.

That seems a very specific bit of knowledge of the recruitment process

Uhm... Since they start out with no one on their teams, I assume the recruiters would be the ones doing the recruiting...

"They know who they recruit" sounds rather like knowing their character name. The only people who would know if a recruiter learns the character name is the recruiters.

Vote Okaros

Ok, I see your point.

Or, hold on, was your post there about yourself specifically?

No, maybe I did not explain myself properly there but I am sure I did later. What I was referring to was my ability when recruited versus other potential roles.

So when I am recruited the recruiter gets a CF and no one else does but why does he care anyway because he already will know who he has recruited.

For example, a recruiter recruits Kaschan, he knows Kaschan is recruited. That is what I meant.

I never meant, he knows he has recruited Father whatever his name was, who has this ability etc, I wouldn't think so anyway.

[Okaros]

All this pussy footing around makes me believe you want to vote elsewhere away from Mockra. So as time is running out I am going to throw in what I think.

First of all without Kaschan arriving I think we lose cause we need his vote.

Trake is swaying away from Mockra with his thoughts on day one.

Iparth has not come out and accused anyone, or even put forth a case on someone.

Mockra voting Iparth makes me think Iparth cannot be a recruit of Mockra if Mockra is the recruiter.

Now in the same leap of logic, Iparth cannot be Mockra's recruiter because Mockra wouldn't vote Iparth when many people are speculating on only them as cult.

Iparth has revealed he cannot be re-recruited. That is extra information about his role. Kind of believable, I put him as Johannes or Walter.

Right now I am thinking that Trake is Mockra's recruit, which is bad because this means we are going to need Kaschan to vote and he is absent. (If not Mockra's recruit, then maybe reverse the role)

I am certain we need Kaschan and Iparth to vote Mockra. Iparth may appear but Kaschan is the risk.

Vote Mockra

[Trake]

Iparth is all about Okaros, hardly replies or talks about anyone else throughout. But there is that interesting bit of activity where they initially vote for Hanas, only to remove asking what's the rush and then go for Gamelon instead. After that, back to talking about how Okaros is probably recruited. That initial vote for Hanas is still interesting though, I don't think a Hanas recruit would do that so early.