[The Unfound]

I dont like HO's late reveal. Assuming he is really a finder the best thing for him to have done would have been to reveal at the same time. That would have either given us enough info to figure out who was who a night earlier or it would really have helped in smoking out a finder that was lying.

[A Demon Llama!]

I dont necessarily have better advice. But knowing Im not scum would be a shame to waste towns lynch because of lack of ideas so far.

[Gnaw]

The Unfound, on 07 October 2014 - 06:10 PM, said:

Well lets see yesterday Khell points at me and screams "Get him!" and is immediately followed by Gnaw, yourself and Obdi in that order. This was done with basically no reason whatsoever, other than I did supposedly shifty things. However Khell, the one who started the train backs out. Now here we are again with you and GH. With no better reasoning than "Hey look over there!"

You are still new.

We're all a little ADD and have trouble sticking to one train of thought. It's a little annoying to be honest but just somethin


oooooo

[Gnaw]

Messremb, on 07 October 2014 - 05:57 PM, said:

Therefore either one is bullshitting and one is insane or I'm town.

HO or Obdi insane? Noooooooo....

Or you're bullshitting.

and insane.

[Messremb]

Gnaw, on 07 October 2014 - 06:19 PM, said:

The Unfound, on 07 October 2014 - 06:10 PM, said:

Well lets see yesterday Khell points at me and screams "Get him!" and is immediately followed by Gnaw, yourself and Obdi in that order. This was done with basically no reason whatsoever, other than I did supposedly shifty things. However Khell, the one who started the train backs out. Now here we are again with you and GH. With no better reasoning than "Hey look over there!"

You are still new.

We're all a little ADD and have trouble sticking to one train of thought. It's a little annoying to be honest but just somethin


oooooo

Dammit, I want to rep that. Can we all just suicide so that I can, please. Also, any more?

[Messremb]

Gnaw, on 07 October 2014 - 06:21 PM, said:

Messremb, on 07 October 2014 - 05:57 PM, said:

Therefore either one is bullshitting and one is insane or I'm town.

HO or Obdi insane? Noooooooo....

Or you're bullshitting.

and insane.

Well, I was too modest to suggest it myself...

[The Unfound]

Gnaw, on 07 October 2014 - 06:19 PM, said:

You are still new.

We're all a little ADD and have trouble sticking to one train of thought. It's a little annoying to be honest but just somethin


oooooo

And speaking of math. I have seen it referenced, Mess this game, before but cannot find it anywhere in the 101 guide. What is the odd even rule?

[Gnaw]

Messremb, on 07 October 2014 - 06:22 PM, said:

Gnaw, on 07 October 2014 - 06:19 PM, said:

The Unfound, on 07 October 2014 - 06:10 PM, said:

Well lets see yesterday Khell points at me and screams "Get him!" and is immediately followed by Gnaw, yourself and Obdi in that order. This was done with basically no reason whatsoever, other than I did supposedly shifty things. However Khell, the one who started the train backs out. Now here we are again with you and GH. With no better reasoning than "Hey look over there!"

You are still new.

We're all a little ADD and have trouble sticking to one train of thought. It's a little annoying to be honest but just somethin


oooooo

Dammit, I want to rep that. Can we all just suicide so that I can, please. Also, any more?

It's actually an Obdigore post.

http://forum.malazan...ost__p__1151937

[Gnaw]

Schmarbs523

Obdi, you don't need a new alt just to lurk.

[HiddenOne]

I revealed hoping it would prevent the mid game stall, but it didn't help

[Gust Hubb]

Gnaw, on 07 October 2014 - 07:53 PM, said:

Schmarbs523

Obdi, you don't need a new alt just to lurk.

Actually my fellow resident, just joined. Thinking of joining a game in the future.

[Messremb]

HiddenOne, on 07 October 2014 - 08:03 PM, said:

I revealed hoping it would prevent the mid game stall, but it didn't help

Obdi is managing that all by himself.

[Messremb]

Gust Hubb, on 07 October 2014 - 08:11 PM, said:

Gnaw, on 07 October 2014 - 07:53 PM, said:

Schmarbs523

Obdi, you don't need a new alt just to lurk.

Actually my fellow resident, just joined. Thinking of joining a game in the future.

Fresh meat!

(probably not the best thing to say given your line of work...)

[HiddenOne]

Hubb sez "Fresh is in the eye of the beholder"

[Vengeance]

It is now Day 4

7 players alive: A Demon Llama, Gnaw, Gust Hubb, HiddenOne, Messremb, Obdigore, The unfound

4 votes to lynch 4 votes for night

22 hours and 23 minutes left in the day.


2 votes for the unfound (Messremb,Gust Hubb,

[Obdigore]

I, unshockingly, got a scum find on Khell.

Which makes me, I'm pretty fucking sure, the reverse finder.

Which, in turn leads me to disbelieve either Mess or HO's reveals. Or a startling statistical improbability has reared its head in this game. Or mini-me is fucking with us.

I think Mess' reveal was a bad bad time for town to reveal. I think HO's reveal, using people either already found or dead, is the 'correct' play for either a killer or a symp to counter-reveal finder. HO's reveal would be more believable, had he gotten some wonky results, like an Inno on Mess, and a Guilty on Gust, and whatever on whoever. It would have let him slide right into that 'insane finder' role.

Symps/Killers don't generally reveal what could/should be contrary to other stuff posted on thread so long as they can help it. This lends, in my mind, credence to HO's reveal.

Of course, tomorrow is the final day if we haven't reduced the scums numbers to 1. A toss of the dice with a semi-counter/semi-unbelievable reveal to try to get through a day and then some. HO possibly as the killer, thinking either Mess or I are his symp, trying to clear us through and making a gamble at it.

I believe that would be why Khell was killed last night and not Mess or I. Either the killer is afraid of the Healer, or he isn't sure who his symp is yet (protip: It is gust hubb, unless you think gust is _that_ bad at mafia (double protip: he just might be!)).

This leads me to suggest that we have to lynch ADL, The Unfound, or Gnaw. Now Gusymp has run a train OFF The Unfound onto Gnaw, and now he hops all aboard a train on The Unfound before even hearing what a revealed finder says his find was last night? Stinky cheese, yo.

Is this protective coloring(that's right, no extraneous 'u' in that one, poms.)? Or possibly gust realizing that some of us wont be led around by our noses by a symp, so he is just voting for whoever he thinks he can get that isn't his master?

As I go through my list of suspects, there is one that, after going back and checking Gust' initial shit-slinging on day 2, never got seriously looked at, that I can recall. ADL.

How very very interesting. Gust tried to paint 'scum' on numerous people we know know were town, such as Shinrei and Khell and, well, most everyone on thread, but he never took a run at ADL.

I find that remarkably odd.

And now, you have just been subjected to the stream of consciousness that happens when Obdi (thats right, third person, bitches) is up for more than 24 hours (The Dark Defiles by Richard K Morgan. Read it.) and what I have to say at this time. Now I'm going to get ~ 2 hours of sleep then go to work.

Nite.

[HiddenOne]

That's what I like to see

[HiddenOne]

So if you distrust Mess, but you think GH is the symp, where does that put the balance?

[Gust Hubb]

I must be the killer!!!!! MUHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHA. /sarcasm

[Gust Hubb]

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

I, unshockingly, got a scum find on Khell.

Which makes me, I'm pretty fucking sure, the reverse finder.

Which, in turn leads me to disbelieve either Mess or HO's reveals. Or a startling statistical improbability has reared its head in this game. Or mini-me is fucking with us.

I think Mess' reveal was a bad bad time for town to reveal. I think HO's reveal, using people either already found or dead, is the 'correct' play for either a killer or a symp to counter-reveal finder. HO's reveal would be more believable, had he gotten some wonky results, like an Inno on Mess, and a Guilty on Gust, and whatever on whoever. It would have let him slide right into that 'insane finder' role.

Symps/Killers don't generally reveal what could/should be contrary to other stuff posted on thread so long as they can help it. This lends, in my mind, credence to HO's reveal.

Of course, tomorrow is the final day if we haven't reduced the scums numbers to 1. A toss of the dice with a semi-counter/semi-unbelievable reveal to try to get through a day and then some. HO possibly as the killer, thinking either Mess or I are his symp, trying to clear us through and making a gamble at it.

I believe that would be why Khell was killed last night and not Mess or I. Either the killer is afraid of the Healer, or he isn't sure who his symp is yet (protip: It is gust hubb, unless you think gust is _that_ bad at mafia (double protip: he just might be!)).

This leads me to suggest that we have to lynch ADL, The Unfound, or Gnaw. Now Gusymp has run a train OFF The Unfound onto Gnaw, and now he hops all aboard a train on The Unfound before even hearing what a revealed finder says his find was last night? Stinky cheese, yo.

Is this protective coloring(that's right, no extraneous 'u' in that one, poms.)? Or possibly gust realizing that some of us wont be led around by our noses by a symp, so he is just voting for whoever he thinks he can get that isn't his master?

As I go through my list of suspects, there is one that, after going back and checking Gust' initial shit-slinging on day 2, never got seriously looked at, that I can recall. ADL.

How very very interesting. Gust tried to paint 'scum' on numerous people we know know were town, such as Shinrei and Khell and, well, most everyone on thread, but he never took a run at ADL.

I find that remarkably odd.

And now, you have just been subjected to the stream of consciousness that happens when Obdi (thats right, third person, bitches) is up for more than 24 hours (The Dark Defiles by Richard K Morgan. Read it.) and what I have to say at this time. Now I'm going to get ~ 2 hours of sleep then go to work.

Nite.

I also skipped HO and Mess, btw, just to open things up for you. Because, I must be scum if I didn't include everyone in cases. Jeeze.