[Gust Hubb]

Any questions for me HO, or am I pariah yet?

[Gnaw]

Vengeance, on 07 October 2014 - 09:36 PM, said:

It is now Day 4

7 players alive: A Demon Llama, Gnaw, Gust Hubb, HiddenOne, Messremb, Obdigore, The unfound

4 votes to lynch 4 votes for night

22 hours and 23 minutes left in the day.


2 votes for the unfound (Messremb,Gust Hubb,

17+ hours. That's great. (No sarcasm)

I just got back from a 4 hour friends and family tech support call. "Oh it'll take just a minute." Bah. The supper would have made it ok except the grill hadn't been cleaned in I don't really want to know how long.

[Gnaw]

Gust Hubb, on 08 October 2014 - 12:49 AM, said:

Any questions for me HO, or am I pariah yet?

Still.

Care to do one of those colonoscopy analyses on ADL and/or Unfound?

[A Demon Llama!]

Yeah just someone fucken do an analysis on me instead of everyone saying that there should be one. You guys will get to a point where you will be convinced that I must be taken out because shit will stay the same and the timer will go off. And you know what you will find? That you were wrong. And I somehow think that the others (Gnaw and Unfound) might also not be where we should be looking. And at that point were fucked. The weird ass "finds" are not helping us either, just creating a perfect environment for more confusion.

[A Demon Llama!]

Also if i sound angry I am. Seems like something is up with my fucken car again. fuck.

[A Demon Llama!]

Why is my shit changing to being highlighted in black when I copy and past anything?

[HiddenOne]

Because you are pure evil?

[HiddenOne]

Gust Hubb, on 08 October 2014 - 12:49 AM, said:

Any questions for me HO, or am I pariah yet?

No way, I always have a word for the necro

[A Demon Llama!]

WTF go damnit

yeah i dont know how to fix this shit w.e is happening with my attemps to post

This post has been edited by A Demon Llama!: 08 October 2014 - 02:55 AM

[HiddenOne]

I'm out, be back in about 9 hrs
Just in case

vote ADL

[A Demon Llama!]

Fnd--------Mess---------Obdi---------HO---------CF

Khel-------Inno---------Scum--------Inno-------Inno
Mess------xxxx---------Scum--------Inno-------xxxx
GH---------Inno---------Scum -------Inno-------xxxx
Gnaw------Inno---------xxxx---------xxxx-------xxxx

If Mess is faking a true finder he is only symp and from his finds is protecting either GH or Gnaw.

If HO is faking true finder he is either protecting GH or Mess ( cant be Mess)

If Obdi is faking reverese finder then hes protecting GH and Mess (cant be Mess)


Answer: GH is poopular?

Dont really know how else to try and look at these finds to try and spot a fake finder.

[A Demon Llama!]

HiddenOne, on 08 October 2014 - 03:07 AM, said:

I'm out, be back in about 9 hrs
Just in case

vote ADL

I am shocked.

[A Demon Llama!]

Well, looks like it will be either me, Gnaw, or The Unfound.

Vote The Unfound

[Gnaw]

Sleep circles and hovers but refuses to actually land.


5 town and 2 scum, wcs. So tomorrow is d-day.

All of the finders are telling the truth. Statistically unlikely.
One of them is lying, two are telling the truth. One of those dies tonight. One real, one liar.

I propose that the best use of our lynch is getting rid of one of the uncertainties, but one of the finder targets. Khell is dead. Mess is one of the finders.

Of the two remaining, I'm the one causing the most uncertainty.

Remove Vote

Vote Gnaw

[Gnaw]

A Demon Llama!, on 08 October 2014 - 03:36 AM, said:

Well, looks like it will be either me, Gnaw, or The Unfound.

Vote The Unfound

Switch to me or remove. Don't leave him at L-1 please.

[Messremb]

[/quote]

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

I, unshockingly, got a scum find on Khell.

Which makes me, I'm pretty fucking sure, the reverse finder.

It is about as sure as I or HO are the normal finder. One of us could be symp/killer and the reverse one could be dead leaving you as insane.

Or, you know, you could by symp/killer and reverse is dead.

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

Which, in turn leads me to disbelieve either Mess or HO's reveals. Or a startling statistical improbability has reared its head in this game. Or mini-me is fucking with us.

I think Mess' reveal was a bad bad time for town to reveal. I think HO's reveal, using people either already found or dead, is the 'correct' play for either a killer or a symp to counter-reveal finder. HO's reveal would be more believable, had he gotten some wonky results, like an Inno on Mess, and a Guilty on Gust, and whatever on whoever. It would have let him slide right into that 'insane finder' role.

This looks awfully rich coming from the person who revealed before me and prompted my reveal.

However agreed on HO. Although your own claimed finds are as wonky - finding a claimed role rather than a new, previously un-found player when there's 2 of us revealed on thread? That's bullshit play.

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

Symps/Killers don't generally reveal what could/should be contrary to other stuff posted on thread so long as they can help it. This lends, in my mind, credence to HO's reveal.

Contradictory a bit here Obdi; you don't believe HO so much because he could have claimed more believable results by being contrary but then say because he is going along with what we've said he is more believable?

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

Of course, tomorrow is the final day if we haven't reduced the scums numbers to 1. A toss of the dice with a semi-counter/semi-unbelievable reveal to try to get through a day and then some. HO possibly as the killer, thinking either Mess or I are his symp, trying to clear us through and making a gamble at it.

Yes, so get off the fucking fence and put a vote down. We can clear out one of ADL or Unfound because they're the ones no-one has claimed a find on. We can all find the other and go with majority opinion (weighted for believability of the claimant)

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

I believe that would be why Khell was killed last night and not Mess or I. Either the killer is afraid of the Healer, or he isn't sure who his symp is yet (protip: It is gust hubb, unless you think gust is _that_ bad at mafia (double protip: he just might be!)).

You missed Khells little hint about the healer then? Not as obvious as Gusts but still there.

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

This leads me to suggest that we have to lynch ADL, The Unfound, or Gnaw. Now Gusymp has run a train OFF The Unfound onto Gnaw, and now he hops all aboard a train on The Unfound before even hearing what a revealed finder says his find was last night? Stinky cheese, yo.

Is this protective coloring(that's right, no extraneous 'u' in that one, poms.)? Or possibly gust realizing that some of us wont be led around by our noses by a symp, so he is just voting for whoever he thinks he can get that isn't his master?

Protective colouring (that's right, spelt with a 'u' like in the mother-fucking-language) is a maybe. However you were so retardedly slow with your information I'd not have been surprised by a lynch before you deigned to grace us with your presence.

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

As I go through my list of suspects, there is one that, after going back and checking Gust' initial shit-slinging on day 2, never got seriously looked at, that I can recall. ADL.

How very very interesting. Gust tried to paint 'scum' on numerous people we know know were town, such as Shinrei and Khell and, well, most everyone on thread, but he never took a run at ADL.

I find that remarkably odd.

Why didn't you find him last night then?

This game went form being a Mafia game to being a "lets have everyone concentrate on the claimed finders results only" far too soon.

[Messremb]

A Demon Llama!, on 08 October 2014 - 03:12 AM, said:

Fnd--------Mess---------Obdi---------HO---------CF

Khel-------Inno---------Scum--------Inno-------Inno
Mess------xxxx---------Scum--------Inno-------xxxx
GH---------Inno---------Scum -------Inno-------xxxx
Gnaw------Inno---------xxxx---------xxxx-------xxxx

If Mess is faking a true finder he is only symp and from his finds is protecting either GH or Gnaw.

If HO is faking true finder he is either protecting GH or Mess ( cant be Mess)

If Obdi is faking reverese finder then hes protecting GH and Mess (cant be Mess)


Answer: GH is poopular?

Dont really know how else to try and look at these finds to try and spot a fake finder.

Oh FFS ADL. Put your boner for Gust away, I'm sick of it.

Unless 2 finders are fake then Gust isn't the killer.

Deal with it and move on.

[Messremb]

Gnaw, on 08 October 2014 - 03:41 AM, said:

A Demon Llama!, on 08 October 2014 - 03:36 AM, said:

Well, looks like it will be either me, Gnaw, or The Unfound.

Vote The Unfound

Switch to me or remove. Don't leave him at L-1 please.

Oh just lynch. We're playing off claimed finder results it is clear.

[Messremb]

And I'm off for up to 7 hours - sat outside a warehouse in my car reading a book most likely waiting for our Christmas site to have some services installed and then hanging around for white goods delivery. So no internet. Deal with it.

[Obdigore]

Messremb, on 08 October 2014 - 08:44 AM, said:

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

I, unshockingly, got a scum find on Khell.

Which makes me, I'm pretty fucking sure, the reverse finder.

It is about as sure as I or HO are the normal finder. One of us could be symp/killer and the reverse one could be dead leaving you as insane.

Or, you know, you could by symp/killer and reverse is dead.

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

Which, in turn leads me to disbelieve either Mess or HO's reveals. Or a startling statistical improbability has reared its head in this game. Or mini-me is fucking with us.

I think Mess' reveal was a bad bad time for town to reveal. I think HO's reveal, using people either already found or dead, is the 'correct' play for either a killer or a symp to counter-reveal finder. HO's reveal would be more believable, had he gotten some wonky results, like an Inno on Mess, and a Guilty on Gust, and whatever on whoever. It would have let him slide right into that 'insane finder' role.

This looks awfully rich coming from the person who revealed before me and prompted my reveal.

However agreed on HO. Although your own claimed finds are as wonky - finding a claimed role rather than a new, previously un-found player when there's 2 of us revealed on thread? That's bullshit play.

Really? Testing a further find against someone already found, from someone I'm not sure I can trust? Yea right. Oh, by the way, when I revealed, it should have been just 1 person revealing, giving info to the thread and other finders. Then, assuming the healer wasn't dead at that point, perhaps a kill is blocked and maybe we figure some stuff out. A second reveal at that time was bad play, as I already noted.

Quote

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

Symps/Killers don't generally reveal what could/should be contrary to other stuff posted on thread so long as they can help it. This lends, in my mind, credence to HO's reveal.

Contradictory a bit here Obdi; you don't believe HO so much because he could have claimed more believable results by being contrary but then say because he is going along with what we've said he is more believable?

I said HO's reveal time and using players already found or CFed was scummy. I said him not trying to easily slide into the role of 'insane' finder is not. I mean maybe that is hard for you to get, I thought I put it out pretty clearly the first time but hey, maybe you'll understand now?

Quote

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

Of course, tomorrow is the final day if we haven't reduced the scums numbers to 1. A toss of the dice with a semi-counter/semi-unbelievable reveal to try to get through a day and then some. HO possibly as the killer, thinking either Mess or I are his symp, trying to clear us through and making a gamble at it.

Yes, so get off the fucking fence and put a vote down. We can clear out one of ADL or Unfound because they're the ones no-one has claimed a find on. We can all find the other and go with majority opinion (weighted for believability of the claimant)

There is like 20 hours left in the day. Why are you (and gust) voting before I had even had a chance to get on thread after being given night resolution, since I have revealed as a finder? Why are you so very antsy to have this day over and done with?

Quote

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

I believe that would be why Khell was killed last night and not Mess or I. Either the killer is afraid of the Healer, or he isn't sure who his symp is yet (protip: It is gust hubb, unless you think gust is _that_ bad at mafia (double protip: he just might be!)).

You missed Khells little hint about the healer then? Not as obvious as Gusts but still there.

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

This leads me to suggest that we have to lynch ADL, The Unfound, or Gnaw. Now Gusymp has run a train OFF The Unfound onto Gnaw, and now he hops all aboard a train on The Unfound before even hearing what a revealed finder says his find was last night? Stinky cheese, yo.

Is this protective coloring(that's right, no extraneous 'u' in that one, poms.)? Or possibly gust realizing that some of us wont be led around by our noses by a symp, so he is just voting for whoever he thinks he can get that isn't his master?

Protective colouring (that's right, spelt with a 'u' like in the mother-fucking-language) is a maybe. However you were so retardedly slow with your information I'd not have been surprised by a lynch before you deigned to grace us with your presence.

Poor widdle baby doesn't wike my playtime? I guess you idiots should lynch me just like Shinrei then? I mean we are on almost the same timezones...fucking case enough for Gust, amirite? Oh sorry, forgot about his massive 'player profiles'.

Quote

Obdigore, on 07 October 2014 - 11:32 PM, said:

As I go through my list of suspects, there is one that, after going back and checking Gust' initial shit-slinging on day 2, never got seriously looked at, that I can recall. ADL.

How very very interesting. Gust tried to paint 'scum' on numerous people we know know were town, such as Shinrei and Khell and, well, most everyone on thread, but he never took a run at ADL.

I find that remarkably odd.

Why didn't you find him last night then?

This game went form being a Mafia game to being a "lets have everyone concentrate on the claimed finders results only" far too soon.

Because I did, in fact, miss it if Khell hinted he was a healer, and I was expecting the killer to keep him around longer to throw the 'khellfusion' on some of the players playing this game. OHMAIGAWDITSKHELLHESGOTTOBEEEEEEEEEEEVIL.

I will happily vote, today, for ADL.

Vote for A Demon Llama