Karatallid, on 10 May 2014 - 01:49 AM, said:
My concerns are that, given potential scum numbers vs deaths today/tonight, we're edging very close to what is D-day.
While it makes sense to take out the potential scum with two NKs, WCS says that Dem is inno and scum can then STILL take out two people tonight. We lose three with a lynch. Because that scenario would require scum to have the remaining kill powers, scum reach parity and, barring a SK, win the game.
If we don't lynch Demelain, and he's scum, then WCS we lose four tonight, scum win the game, barring the presence of an SK.
So...in other words, Town are fucked tonight almost regardless of what happens, under WCS. We can hope for a good guard action, or something, but it's pretty marginal.
Seeing as I won't be around, I'm going to vote now. The only real hope Town has at this point is if Dem is Town and not lynched. But...fuck. That's got so many inherent problems with it. As Town, I'd never go for that power purely because going for it is going to get you jumped as scum trying to win the game - logically, only scum would go for it hoping to use it to win by pretending to be inno, because "no scum would take this power as it lights them up too much as a target" - i.e. WIFOM. If your only defence is WIFOM logic, you shouldn't have done something in the first place.
Vote Demelain