[Tattersail_]

Khellendros, on 10 December 2012 - 05:33 PM, said:

Ah, forget my previous post - I thought you'd written "we CAN'T widdle [whittle?] it down assuming the symp is dead." Thought you were accusing me of being blase

I'm anything But vindictive. You know I'm such a nice guy and wouldn't mess with you like that.

[Khellendros]

Tattersail, on 10 December 2012 - 07:07 PM, said:

Khellendros, on 10 December 2012 - 05:33 PM, said:

Ah, forget my previous post - I thought you'd written "we CAN'T widdle [whittle?] it down assuming the symp is dead." Thought you were accusing me of being blase

I'm anything But vindictive. You know I'm such a nice guy and wouldn't mess with you like that.

I'm a sensitive soul.

[Tattersail_]

Khellendros, on 10 December 2012 - 07:08 PM, said:

Tattersail, on 10 December 2012 - 07:07 PM, said:

Khellendros, on 10 December 2012 - 05:33 PM, said:

Ah, forget my previous post - I thought you'd written "we CAN'T widdle [whittle?] it down assuming the symp is dead." Thought you were accusing me of being blase

I'm anything But vindictive. You know I'm such a nice guy and wouldn't mess with you like that.

I'm a sensitive soul.

You sound like Pumba.

Hakuna Matatta

[Tattersail_]

oh and I'm embarrassed about widdle over whittle, that's my accent coming into play

[HiddenOne]

keep coming on here to try and read a little & comment but it's not working

Khell you say that only Bubba and I can be suspect somewhere in the previous page. Explain that

[Khellendros]

HiddenOne, on 10 December 2012 - 09:20 PM, said:

keep coming on here to try and read a little & comment but it's not working

Khell you say that only Bubba and I can be suspect somewhere in the previous page. Explain that

I did.

[Khellendros]

Khellendros, on 10 December 2012 - 09:52 PM, said:

HiddenOne, on 10 December 2012 - 09:20 PM, said:

keep coming on here to try and read a little & comment but it's not working

Khell you say that only Bubba and I can be suspect somewhere in the previous page. Explain that

I did.

Sigh - I'm too kind.

In summary, because of interaction over the previous days - Tats had made cases on Blend, as had Shin (and no one has countered his assertion he vigged Blend - though I supposed it could have been Gnaw, it is pretty clear from the posts that Shin had been suspecting Blend for some time), Blend had attacked Tats, I'm not going to be accusing myself, and Starling has also made some attacks against Blend.

So that leaves you and Bubba - and the posts which myself and Tattersail have produced indicate there both of you are possibles as Blend's partner, though perhaphs Bubba more so.

[bubba]

Well that is game if you guys play it right.

First off let me say DO vote me off today. It is the only way you will see I'm telling the truth.

First off, I am the real finder. I have been getting a find in every other night. The Pics have been me.

I tried to show you all that Tatts was one of the killers, but their symp jumped to the rescue with his counter reveal.

So I played it safe, waiting for the other killer to make an appearance. Great job shin.

Now that all are revealed. I have no problem giving up this info.

Great game everyone.

[Tattersail_]

Well this is a little worrisome. If Bubba is a symp then who is the other killer. If Bubba is a killer why this reveal? If we do lynch him and he comes up innocent what then?

Bubba what did your last picture mean then?

[bubba]

Tattersail, on 11 December 2012 - 07:22 AM, said:

Well this is a little worrisome. If Bubba is a symp then who is the other killer. If Bubba is a killer why this reveal? If we do lynch him and he comes up innocent what then?

Bubba what did your last picture mean then?

I thought for sure Azath was the other killer. I sent it in when I seen him come up inno. I thought I had Fucked up getting Azanth lynched. so a big Face palm.

[Tattersail_]

Bubba, on 11 December 2012 - 07:29 AM, said:

Tattersail, on 11 December 2012 - 07:22 AM, said:

Well this is a little worrisome. If Bubba is a symp then who is the other killer. If Bubba is a killer why this reveal? If we do lynch him and he comes up innocent what then?

Bubba what did your last picture mean then?

I thought for sure Azath was the other killer. I sent it in when I seen him come up inno. I thought I had Fucked up getting Azanth lynched. so a big Face palm.

You could have said a 100 things here you liar. So you what? Tried to lynch Azath when you knew I was a killer? You held back your information from town? And you said some things about the pictures and finder reveal that fuck yourself in the arse earlier on.

Right. On to ignoring you. You can answer other peoples questions Liar.

[Shinrei]

Well now THAT's a kicker reveal.

I am actually tempted to believe it, because despite his protestations that he would have voted for him, Tatts insisted on going for Bubba rather than Blend yesterday. Also, Azath made no reference to the pictures being from him, and no one else has claimed to be doing the pictures either. Finally, the possibility certainly exists that Azath was the symp and a fake reveal bought time and confusion. Tatts connecting of Bubba and Blend is based a lot of how they didn't interact at all, which is tenuous merely from the fact that Bubba hasn't been connected with anyone, really. If he's telling the truth, low profile play fits a finder.

It's pretty clear that I'll die tonight if we don't lynch correctly today, but I think we actually do have 2 days to get this right. I'm comfortable with believe it is either Bubba or Tatts.

Tatts certaily fits the profile of a killer coming on and dominating the conversation as the game winds down.

The only darkhorse here is, if we don't lynch correctly today and I'm dead tomorrow, we have to rely on HO who is barely paying attention and Starling who is also barely here to get this right.

Also, now I want to wait to see if there is any counter-reveal on the picture thing.

[Tattersail_]

Quote

It is Day 4. 28 hours and 20 minutes remaining
6 Players still alive: Bubba, Hiddenone, Khellendros, Shinrei, Starling, Tattersail

Option A)
bubba is a symp, there is still a killer out there.

Lynch me first. See my CF so you can be sure Bubba is team scum.

Someone dies. It leaves 2 versus 2, does scum win then?

Option Bubba is killer trying to buy one more day. We lynch him we win.

Option C) Bubba is symp, we lynch him, we know scum team is down to one.

So he is lynched, one person dies.You are left with 4 people against one killer. Lynch me, one dies you are left with one and one.

Shit shit shit.

Bubba you fucking Genius.

Obviously Bubba is the first lynch and then I have to convince you I am not the killer and we have to find the correct one out of Khell, HO, Starling and Shin.

Shin in my mind cannot be the killer unless he somehow could vig his partner to PI himself.

Then it is a toss up. Some more than others and as the last few days went by it could be anyone of HO, Starling or Khell.

Khell's activity has shot up today compared to other days, Starling was around to lynch Azath and protect the fact that she could be a killer playing unettiquettly and HO rage if he is scum.

[Shinrei]

Tattersail, on 11 December 2012 - 08:08 AM, said:

Bubba, on 11 December 2012 - 07:29 AM, said:

Tattersail, on 11 December 2012 - 07:22 AM, said:

Well this is a little worrisome. If Bubba is a symp then who is the other killer. If Bubba is a killer why this reveal? If we do lynch him and he comes up innocent what then?

Bubba what did your last picture mean then?

I thought for sure Azath was the other killer. I sent it in when I seen him come up inno. I thought I had Fucked up getting Azanth lynched. so a big Face palm.

You could have said a 100 things here you liar. So you what? Tried to lynch Azath when you knew I was a killer? You held back your information from town? And you said some things about the pictures and finder reveal that fuck yourself in the arse earlier on.

Right. On to ignoring you. You can answer other peoples questions Liar.

He could have withheld to try and find the other killer. He was labeled by many as scummy, so he probably felt somewhat confident he wouldn't be NK'd. And if Bubba is finder, he'd know Azath fake revealed and of COURSE he would try to lynch Azath then.

What do you mean here, Tatts? Please show what you mean.

Quote

And you said some things about the pictures and finder reveal that fuck yourself in the arse earlier on.

[Shinrei]

Tattersail, on 11 December 2012 - 08:16 AM, said:

Quote

It is Day 4. 28 hours and 20 minutes remaining
6 Players still alive: Bubba, Hiddenone, Khellendros, Shinrei, Starling, Tattersail

Option A)
bubba is a symp, there is still a killer out there.

Lynch me first. See my CF so you can be sure Bubba is team scum.

Someone dies. It leaves 2 versus 2, does scum win then?

Option Bubba is killer trying to buy one more day. We lynch him we win.

Option C) Bubba is symp, we lynch him, we know scum team is down to one.

So he is lynched, one person dies.You are left with 4 people against one killer. Lynch me, one dies you are left with one and one.

Shit shit shit.

Bubba you fucking Genius.

Obviously Bubba is the first lynch and then I have to convince you I am not the killer and we have to find the correct one out of Khell, HO, Starling and Shin.

Shin in my mind cannot be the killer unless he somehow could vig his partner to PI himself.

Then it is a toss up. Some more than others and as the last few days went by it could be anyone of HO, Starling or Khell.

Khell's activity has shot up today compared to other days, Starling was around to lynch Azath and protect the fact that she could be a killer playing unettiquettly and HO rage if he is scum.

Of course, those scenarios change if you are the killer or symp.

[Tattersail_]

Shinrei, on 11 December 2012 - 08:15 AM, said:

Well now THAT's a kicker reveal.

I am actually tempted to believe it, because despite his protestations that he would have voted for him, Tatts insisted on going for Bubba rather than Blend yesterday. Also, Azath made no reference to the pictures being from him, and no one else has claimed to be doing the pictures either. Finally, the possibility certainly exists that Azath was the symp and a fake reveal bought time and confusion. Tatts connecting of Bubba and Blend is based a lot of how they didn't interact at all, which is tenuous merely from the fact that Bubba hasn't been connected with anyone, really. If he's telling the truth, low profile play fits a finder.

It's pretty clear that I'll die tonight if we don't lynch correctly today, but I think we actually do have 2 days to get this right. I'm comfortable with believe it is either Bubba or Tatts.

Tatts certaily fits the profile of a killer coming on and dominating the conversation as the game winds down.

The only darkhorse here is, if we don't lynch correctly today and I'm dead tomorrow, we have to rely on HO who is barely paying attention and Starling who is also barely here to get this right.

Also, now I want to wait to see if there is any counter-reveal on the picture thing.

I was thinking the same thing in the shower. About Starling and HO. I do think you'll die tonight because you are close to innocent as I said above.

I am town Shin, I no you have doubts but don't give up on me. I've fucking played for town the whole game and have no reason to give up on you now.

If you die tonight I want your thoughts on this situation.

We lynch Bubba, he turns out innocent, would you think the correct thing to do is lynch me? I KNOW he is lying. I have that information right here. He has already said that lynching him will bring him up innocent, this just sows confusion towards the end of the game, classic scum play.

Ask Bubba to describe his ability, (if it was him, why did he post two pictures of me night one and night two? Yet not night 3?)

When has the picture ability been played in any game so far? I've never seen it before. TMDi is mid way through the scale so the ability HAS to have been seen before.


I also want clarification from PS about this because if those pictures were just flavor then town could lose this game due to them.

[Tattersail_]

Tattersail, on 05 December 2012 - 08:59 AM, said:

Bubba, on 05 December 2012 - 08:47 AM, said:

I'm sorry Venge. I thought you we playing way to nice.

I have three of the clues from the expanded morning scene figured out.

But I cant for the life of me figure out what the drawing of Tatts by the well is supposed to mean. Anybody?

I think it was just flavor, I don't think the scenes will have much to do with the actual in play. I'm going to have a catch up for the next hour or so then post my thoughts

Okay first post by Bubba regarding picture. Look at my answer as well.

[Tattersail_]

Shinrei, on 05 December 2012 - 11:26 AM, said:

Bubba, you shifty veteran. What do YOU think about what has happened so far? You're cruising a bit.

You say this but he doesn't answer, he also doesn't follow up my picture answer.

[Tattersail_]

Bubba, on 06 December 2012 - 06:39 AM, said:

Good to see the forum is back up.

Having caught up, I'm not seeing anything jump out at me. HO seams to be off the hook from yesterdays train. I cant really say if this is good or bad, I'm not really getting a read on him, or anyone else at this point. I was instrumental in getting a townie lynched yesterday so I'm going to hold off on placing any vote.

I posted like a madman on day one, I had ample enough evidence against me for a case by Bubba yet after the night scene he doesn't find me remotely suspicious.

[Tattersail_]

Shinrei, on 06 December 2012 - 11:30 AM, said:

Here's what I wrote on Word, before refreshing and seeing Tatts vote:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Ok, upon re-read this is what I got.

Scum team is EM, Bubba with Tatts as symp.

EM and Bubba put their heads together and decided to play opposites. One is in your face angry, while the other is cruising low and reasonable. EM is obviously doing the angry stchtick. They haven't gone after each other in any way. Bubba didn't even bother to answer my direct question to him about what he thought about other people.
Tattersail had a big back and forth with EM on day one, and post #108 was the one that stuck out. Tattersail replies to EM saying:

Quote

"People will definitely seperate us by the way. You being a killer and all. That is the plan isn't it not buddy?"

That just screams "I know you are the killer, but you're also my buddy." It's easy for Tatts to explain it away if pressed, but I'm not sure I would buy it. It looks way too much like legit signals I've seen before. Couple that with the fact Tatts first joke vote was on EM….
EM is on the two likely trains – HO and then switches to Venge when Venge gets hot. Scum wants the good lynch, away from him and his partner.

What I've got on Bubba is less, but he's playing so low key and making some really standard mafia posts. Take #152 for example:

Quote

"I have to say that vote Gnaw is the first really scum like thing I have seen today.

Remove vote, Vote Gnaw


I will be the first to put some pressure on you to explain."

This, and his other posts, just seem too vanilla-mafia to be believed.