[D'riss]

Path-Shaper, on 05 July 2012 - 06:54 PM, said:

It is Day 2. 6 hours and 27 minutes remaining
12 Players still alive: Anomandaris, Barghast, D'riss, Kaschan, Liosan, Osseric, Rashan, Serc, Sheltatha Lore, Telas, Tellan, Thyrllan

8 votes to lynch.

1 Vote for Kaschan ( Rashan )
1 Vote for Osseric ( Anomandaris )
3 Votes for Thyrllan ( Eloth, Fener, Sheltatha Lore )

Kalse removed his vote. Well their goes the voting block idea out the window.

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 2. 6 hours and 25 minutes remaining
12 Players still alive: Anomandaris, Barghast, D'riss, Kaschan, Liosan, Osseric, Rashan, Serc, Sheltatha Lore, Telas, Tellan, Thyrllan

8 votes to lynch.

1 Vote for Kaschan ( Rashan )
1 Vote for Osseric ( Anomandaris )
4 Votes for Thyrllan ( Eloth, Fener, Sheltatha Lore, Kalse )

[Barghast]

Serc, on 05 July 2012 - 06:44 PM, said:

Barghast, on 05 July 2012 - 06:34 PM, said:

@Serc - I do find it odd, and most likely significant. I just don't know how. It is handy for adding to a train, and I can't help but feel it's scummy to use that to roll up a lynch - because we don't know what it means.


@D'riss - not accusations as much as speculation, it was just a thought that I had out of nowhere so I mentioned it. As long as it's not advertised as fact, I see no harm. And who said anything about setting up lynches for later?


@Ano - you're probably right, hadn't thought about it from that angle. If it were a one shot power or somehow limited it would be less unbalancing, but that is just speculation on top of speculation.

Fair enough, bro. But this is why we NEED everyone. Any of us can get blinded by what we think. We really need to bounce ideas off of each other,not turn at each other. In fact it's just as likely that we're all wrong, and scum are lying low, hoping we take each other out. Case in point, last game. DiBs and Tattersail didn't emerge much until later in the game, after townies had built gut suspicions about each other that lasted until almost the end, and blinded them to the real scum.

Maybe we should wait and hear from these silent players like Rashan, Liosan, etc. Who else has been silent today ?

Excellent point, it feels like the same several people have been here all day, and the others are not

[Barghast]

I'm still hung up on the idea of Tellan as the sandy haired cultist, which has fallen behind the whole Thyr/spectre convo

Anybody want to comment on it?


At this time we have little prospect for a different lynch, unless everybody shows up at once

[Serc]

Kalse removed his vote from Thryllan. This in itself almost destroys the case against Thyrllan. It implies he is no longer sure. And our speculation was that the dead know something and their unified vote for Thyrllan was possible signalling.

[Liosan]

Eh, Serc you seem to be a bit jumpy and explain it as wanting to get something going. Fair enough. You don't want a random lynch, ok. Seeing as how we'll go to the shade thread those people are only mostly dead anyways. Perhaps Mad Max is the Lich King.

Osseric is at times nonsensical to me and is thoroughly defending Thyr. So, I'd be okay with either of them for sheer clarification purposes.

I have a feeling, someone else mentioned it, that we've got an adventurer that gets full CF and/or can lover talk to a dead person. The person shrieking about ghosts wouldn't be a bad bet for lover connect.

The problem we have is minus the thread as a whole having a full CF we've got no fucking clue who we are lynching. They then go to the Shade thread and have the possibility of coming back.

Everything I've seen so far is dog-chasing it's tail mechanics wise.

Everything is speculation right now that we have. The more we can clarify the better. We haven't successfully lynched someone, so maybe if we really DO and it wasn't the top-vote getter they really do die. The point is we have no clue. The only remedy to that is clarify. We shouldn't do it willy nilly but we can't just shout at each other that "it's speculation." That gets us nowhere.

I'll vote for Thyr, Osseric, Rashan, and Serc as of right now. Kaschan has remained quiet and Shel seems to be playing it cool, so I'm intrigued by them as well.

[Liosan]

Look again, Kalse must have revoted or Path-Shaper made a mistake.

[Path-Shaper]

Liosan, on 05 July 2012 - 07:02 PM, said:

Look again, Kalse must have revoted or Path-Shaper made a mistake.

Path-Shaper did not make a mistake.

[Liosan]

I get here and you all decide to shut-up.

[Osseric]

So kalse just wanted to say vote Block theory is wrong.

[Barghast]

maybe so


I'm around Lio, got anything to add to the convo?

[Rashan]

I'm back everyone, sorry for my absence, was rereading and then i had to leave. First off,

Remove Vote


I'll withdraw my vote for now, my Kaschan vote was to pressure him but then i forgot about it. I'll have more time tomorrow, i'll cast my vote before timeout, should still be around by then. We shouldn't go without a lynch today, a random lynch could be dangerous to town's victory (obviously).

[Serc]

Liosan, on 05 July 2012 - 07:00 PM, said:

Eh, Serc you seem to be a bit jumpy and explain it as wanting to get something going. Fair enough. You don't want a random lynch, ok. Seeing as how we'll go to the shade thread those people are only mostly dead anyways. Perhaps Mad Max is the Lich King.

Osseric is at times nonsensical to me and is thoroughly defending Thyr. So, I'd be okay with either of them for sheer clarification purposes.

I have a feeling, someone else mentioned it, that we've got an adventurer that gets full CF and/or can lover talk to a dead person. The person shrieking about ghosts wouldn't be a bad bet for lover connect.

The problem we have is minus the thread as a whole having a full CF we've got no fucking clue who we are lynching. They then go to the Shade thread and have the possibility of coming back.

Everything I've seen so far is dog-chasing it's tail mechanics wise.

Everything is speculation right now that we have. The more we can clarify the better. We haven't successfully lynched someone, so maybe if we really DO and it wasn't the top-vote getter they really do die. The point is we have no clue. The only remedy to that is clarify. We shouldn't do it willy nilly but we can't just shout at each other that "it's speculation." That gets us nowhere.

I'll vote for Thyr, Osseric, Rashan, and Serc as of right now. Kaschan has remained quiet and Shel seems to be playing it cool, so I'm intrigued by them as well.

Sigh. All valid points except your willingness to vote me. It wasn't because we called out you and Rashan for not saying much today, was it?

Strange you pop on within minutes of me saying so. Fener even voted for you last night from SH.

It wasn't a direct accusation. But it is highly likely that we are all chasing our tails. But would you have us do nothing? I'm open for debate.

[Liosan]

I said doing nothing was the worst thing we can do if you read that. We need to clarify things. The only way to do so is through action. It is why I'm willing to vote and the four I would prefer are listed at the end.

And, I just got here. I don't lurk and suck at low-posting.

[Serc]

There is Rashan. Now we just need more from Kaschan and Telas.

[Liosan]

Oh, I'm pretty sure Fener voted me for calling him a fucking dipshit after his seemingly random ninja-vig, but maybe not. We won't know until/if he gets back will we?

[Liosan]

Further, while I think it is noteworthy that they are acting in concert, we probably shouldn't take direction from the shades. They would have had us lynch a possible cult-deducer. Let us play our game and them theirs, and if they align, all the better.

[Serc]

Liosan, on 05 July 2012 - 07:18 PM, said:

Oh, I'm pretty sure Fener voted me for calling him a fucking dipshit after his seemingly random ninja-vig, but maybe not. We won't know until/if he gets back will we?

I'll give you that one. Makes sense. Well that's all I can think of. I think I've contributed as much as can be asked.

[Serc]

Liosan, on 05 July 2012 - 07:21 PM, said:

Further, while I think it is noteworthy that they are acting in concert, we probably shouldn't take direction from the shades. They would have had us lynch a possible cult-deducer. Let us play our game and them theirs, and if they align, all the better.

I sort of agree. But us being able to see their votes has to mean something. Maybe we don't follow them, but I say we should still take them into account somehow.

[Liosan]

Oh, it's something to consider. Especially when acting in concert, such as if someone reveals on thread here and the actual player is already dead, they could help us out there by showing us their votes. But, as far as we know for now that thread is just as susceptible to cult manipulation as ours is.