Emurlahn, on 12 June 2012 - 12:57 PM, said:
Rashan, on 12 June 2012 - 12:54 PM, said:
Emurlahn, on 12 June 2012 - 10:04 AM, said:
Well, as far as I'm concerned, the only people who are off the plate are the CLs. If I had any indication that you were a CL I would change my vote, but as you have said that you're a Penguin recruit, it behooves me to reduce the opposing faction's numbers, thus making it easier for my faction to reach plurality.
That being said, you MAY have been a Penguin recruit previously, but I still smell flying rodent on you. Sure the case might be a little shaky, but I'm still going to follow my CLs' orders unless reasonably deduce that you are a CL. The Spite case wasn't much more solid, and the 1st BM case (I don't remember who it was, seems so long ago!) was even shakier. I think you're the Bat, so my vote stays.
Anyone else reading this?
You are going against the majority of what people want here and going for a recruit. I was recruited last night so what you say is wrong. PI could recruit me tonight and i'd be on your team, unless it takes two nights to recruit a recruit which would make more sense.
Gunning for a recruit is not the best option, no. But then again, you also MIGHT be the Batman, so from Rashan's point of view it's not a LOSS if you are, as you claim to be, a Penguin recruit. His logic is sound even if it goes against the desires of the thread; going for the Batman is a priority but for someone who is already recruited, I can't say as it is time-relevant. Bearing in mind Cults need time to recruit in order to have plurality once the Batman goes down...you can see why an admitted cultist would not be adverse to wasting a day on you, given the possibility that you're the Batman, and even if you aren't, his faction benefits?
Again, though, I see you trying to circumvent an entire argument with that empty claim. And now you're speculating mechanics like Fener was; two nights is a possibility, but an unlikely one considering that then the Cults would have almost zero chance of winning (remember: they need PLURALITY, and there were FOUR of them, one recruit every two nights just DOES NOT STACK, mathmatically speaking...). Game balance dictates that victory is a close thing, not a cake walk...