[Path-Shaper]

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Well I made my move. Retaliatory killer. You should have put it in if you didn't. I will probably be lynched. As Fener and co don't really like me. But once again I manage to symp a killer...Nice...


Lets see who bites on my reveal shall we..

Yeah, you've done an awesome job, cause anything with a kill ability does not want to target you if they believe you

Yeah and I actually spent a good part building it up so it is totally believable. We shall see.

yup I may stay awake for a bit longer to watch the fireworks

But I get to fake reveal as much shit as I want about supposed conversations with you....

not if you don't want me to lock you out of your alt at some point

original PMs and any updates that may change PMs are allowed to be discussed/revealed/lied about.
within boundaries. this is fairly tricky stuff.

Well obviously if a fake reveal is going to be believed then it has to stay as much in line with a real reveal as possible. As I have only said that I confirmed some things with you that doesn't even come close to anything other then good play.

true, you're within the bounds so far

[Path-Shaper]

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Well I made my move. Retaliatory killer. You should have put it in if you didn't. I will probably be lynched. As Fener and co don't really like me. But once again I manage to symp a killer...Nice...


Lets see who bites on my reveal shall we..

Yeah, you've done an awesome job, cause anything with a kill ability does not want to target you if they believe you

Yeah and I actually spent a good part building it up so it is totally believable. We shall see.

yup. I may stay awake for a bit longer to watch the fireworks

But I get to fake reveal as much shit as I want about supposed conversations with you....

not if you don't want me to lock you out of your alt at some point

original PMs and any updates that may change PMs are allowed to be discussed/revealed/lied about.
within boundaries. this is fairly tricky stuff.

Well obviously if a fake reveal is going to be believed then it has to stay as much in line with a real reveal as possible. As I have only said that I confirmed some things with you that doesn't even come close to anything other then good play.

true, you're within the bounds so far

The problem becomes that there is so much WIFOM going on in my head right now that truly I don't trust anyone. I don't like Fener and would like to lynch him but I also think that Atrahal is lying through his teeth. But I have defended 2 scum so far in this game and so I am not a good judge of who is what and what not.

Saved for posterity. Morgy will have a field day once he reads it

[Path-Shaper]

Potentially defining moment:

Quote

Quote

Quote

Atrahal should be fucking modkilled for that shit.

Can you link me or give me the post number?

Post #945 talks a lot about his conversation with you and clarifications that were made.

answer:

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Atrahal should be fucking modkilled for that shit.

Can you link me or give me the post number?

Post #945 talks a lot about his conversation with you and clarifications that were made.

ah, i see.

I think he referenced there to my clarification in post 899 (page 23, on 40 posts a page).
since thta was an in-game statement readable for all, I don't mind a quotage there, at least not to that statement as it was no PM.

If you read it differently, feel free to differ and alert me again, please then also give me your interpretation

I want this game to be fair, and that means listening to the players.

eloth:

Quote

Quote

Quote

Can I call out Atrahal for having a different worded PM than me?
i just realised mine doesnt read take, it says submit

no you definately can't.


It's effective wording of a PM.

It might be that either I or Bent rephrased stuff at some point or copy/pasted from a different place to keep things more clear, I don't want such minor details that may well have unintentionally been caused by a mod to affect the game.

Ah, thank you.
Just needed to make sure.

It is stuff like this that makes modding a living hell and drains all the fun from it. Lish should know better, Breadmaster I can understand (it's a lot more technical), especially if he missed 899. But damned, when did we become lawywers, who start spelling out the judge's verdict for spelling mistakes to get their client to go free?

[Path-Shaper]

Bread, you've earned lots and lots of credit for your awesome defense there against Pfener.
If anyone had put up such a fight against the odds (or if others had been online while their trains caught steam) this game would go past 2000 posts and would be truly epic.

Very well played, sir.

[Path-Shaper]

Quote

Vig Anthras

If I don't get lynched, that is.

thanks for submitting. things look bleak, but your defense is admireable. kudos for that.

[Malaese]

 Path-Shaper, on Jul 20 2009, 04:51 PM, said:

Potentially defining moment:

Quote

Quote

Quote

Atrahal should be fucking modkilled for that shit.

Can you link me or give me the post number?

Post #945 talks a lot about his conversation with you and clarifications that were made.

answer:

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Atrahal should be fucking modkilled for that shit.

Can you link me or give me the post number?

Post #945 talks a lot about his conversation with you and clarifications that were made.

ah, i see.

I think he referenced there to my clarification in post 899 (page 23, on 40 posts a page).
since thta was an in-game statement readable for all, I don't mind a quotage there, at least not to that statement as it was no PM.

If you read it differently, feel free to differ and alert me again, please then also give me your interpretation

I want this game to be fair, and that means listening to the players.

eloth:

Quote

Quote

Quote

Can I call out Atrahal for having a different worded PM than me?
i just realised mine doesnt read take, it says submit

no you definately can't.


It's effective wording of a PM.

It might be that either I or Bent rephrased stuff at some point or copy/pasted from a different place to keep things more clear, I don't want such minor details that may well have unintentionally been caused by a mod to affect the game.

Ah, thank you.
Just needed to make sure.

It is stuff like this that makes modding a living hell and drains all the fun from it. Lish should know better, Breadmaster I can understand (it's a lot more technical), especially if he missed 899. But damned, when did we become lawywers, who start spelling out the judge's verdict for spelling mistakes to get their client to go free?

Lish also timed his reveal after putting on thread he was waiting on a PM from PS. Which was true, but basically PI'd him. Just the nature of people, they want to win and this group knows nobody will pull the modkill trigger at this point in the game on the chance it ruins it. Should really play a game of "dirty" mafia (no rules), where anything and everything goes...people can quote PM's, fake quote them...anything they can think of to win. Then at least it's even footing.

[Path-Shaper]

 Malaese, on Jul 21 2009, 02:10 AM, said:

 Path-Shaper, on Jul 20 2009, 04:51 PM, said:

Potentially defining moment:

Quote

Quote

Quote

Atrahal should be fucking modkilled for that shit.

Can you link me or give me the post number?

Post #945 talks a lot about his conversation with you and clarifications that were made.

answer:

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

Atrahal should be fucking modkilled for that shit.

Can you link me or give me the post number?

Post #945 talks a lot about his conversation with you and clarifications that were made.

ah, i see.

I think he referenced there to my clarification in post 899 (page 23, on 40 posts a page).
since thta was an in-game statement readable for all, I don't mind a quotage there, at least not to that statement as it was no PM.

If you read it differently, feel free to differ and alert me again, please then also give me your interpretation

I want this game to be fair, and that means listening to the players.

eloth:

Quote

Quote

Quote

Can I call out Atrahal for having a different worded PM than me?
i just realised mine doesnt read take, it says submit

no you definately can't.


It's effective wording of a PM.

It might be that either I or Bent rephrased stuff at some point or copy/pasted from a different place to keep things more clear, I don't want such minor details that may well have unintentionally been caused by a mod to affect the game.

Ah, thank you.
Just needed to make sure.

It is stuff like this that makes modding a living hell and drains all the fun from it. Lish should know better, Breadmaster I can understand (it's a lot more technical), especially if he missed 899. But damned, when did we become lawywers, who start spelling out the judge's verdict for spelling mistakes to get their client to go free?

Lish also timed his reveal after putting on thread he was waiting on a PM from PS. Which was true, but basically PI'd him. Just the nature of people, they want to win and this group knows nobody will pull the modkill trigger at this point in the game on the chance it ruins it. Should really play a game of "dirty" mafia (no rules), where anything and everything goes...people can quote PM's, fake quote them...anything they can think of to win. Then at least it's even footing.

Sounds very interesting
And Lish's thingie had escaped me. no wonder, at midnight and being swamped with PMs.








damn, fucking adrenaline will keep me up all fucking night.

[Path-Shaper]

I think I gave away too many abilities on the final night. It wouldn;t have made a difference, tho.

[Lisheo]

Sorry about that, but I was actually planning on claiming the action, wrote half the message, then wasn't sure whether reveals of complex abilities (not roles) were allowed.

[Path-Shaper]

 Lisheo, on Jul 21 2009, 02:25 AM, said:

Sorry about that, but I was actually planning on claiming the action, wrote half the message, then wasn't sure whether reveals of complex abilities (not roles) were allowed.

i'm glad that it didn't come down to truly nasty stuff.
hopefully Breadmaster agrees to that as well, but we need to get rid of the lawyer-approach in mafia. keeps things a lot more relaxed.

[Lisheo]

 Path-Shaper, on Jul 21 2009, 01:29 AM, said:

 Lisheo, on Jul 21 2009, 02:25 AM, said:

Sorry about that, but I was actually planning on claiming the action, wrote half the message, then wasn't sure whether reveals of complex abilities (not roles) were allowed.

i'm glad that it didn't come down to truly nasty stuff.
hopefully Breadmaster agrees to that as well, but we need to get rid of the lawyer-approach in mafia. keeps things a lot more relaxed.

Usually I'm not so technical.
But usually I'm dead by day four. XD
sorry, veng

[Path-Shaper]

Anyways, 2.30 in the morning... 7.30 the alarmclock rings.

will be seeing you then.

Huge huge thanks to Bent for co-modding & comments on the set-up. Game wouldn't be here without him.
Thanks to all the others who helped out in SH.
Special mention to Malaese for being just addicted enough to read SH

Lastly, thanks to the final six for keeping me on the edge of my chair for the entire night so far.
Mentions to Morgoth, Gem, Gavin, Dkt are also in order for playing a very good game, and to the killers who bit the dust day 1 through no real fault of their own.

[Tapper]

Hope you all liked it.
I'm secretly immensely pleased with the way the game went, there were huge concerns over killers being overpowered and I saw town ready to achieve an easy win after night 1...... but bwgan, breadmaster and baudin did an awesome job removing townroles, too.

[Vengeance]

 Path-Shaper, on Jul 20 2009, 02:50 PM, said:

Lisheoth, titled Anthras:

Quote

Morgoth?
And Fener is m45, i think.

[Vengeance]

 Lisheo, on Jul 20 2009, 07:32 PM, said:

 Path-Shaper, on Jul 21 2009, 01:29 AM, said:

 Lisheo, on Jul 21 2009, 02:25 AM, said:

Sorry about that, but I was actually planning on claiming the action, wrote half the message, then wasn't sure whether reveals of complex abilities (not roles) were allowed.

i'm glad that it didn't come down to truly nasty stuff.
hopefully Breadmaster agrees to that as well, but we need to get rid of the lawyer-approach in mafia. keeps things a lot more relaxed.

Usually I'm not so technical.
But usually I'm dead by day four. XD
sorry, veng

No worries... I was staring at the thread thinking why am I being voted on so quickly. Only scum would do that. Hold up.

It happens.

[Vengeance]

 Tapper, on Jul 20 2009, 07:38 PM, said:

Hope you all liked it.
I'm secretly immensely pleased with the way the game went, there were huge concerns over killers being overpowered and I saw town ready to achieve an easy win after night 1...... but bwgan, breadmaster and baudin did an awesome job removing townroles, too.

Wonderful game Tap

[Korbas]

 Barghast, on Jul 17 2009, 12:42 AM, said:

 Tapper, on Jul 15 2009, 02:23 AM, said:

 Bent, on Jul 14 2009, 04:03 PM, said:

Well, it may be a very quick ending indeed.

Well, the killers will have to take one another out, too
But if they lynch a killer day 1, then all on the train start vigging night 2, yeah, we see an awful lot of dead people very fast.

@Sorritt - but look what happens when we lynch a killer!
We would have had three people with vigs, man. XD

Still, I agree, it turned out OK, with two scum dead on night one. But pisses me off that I got lynched for nothing and was actually gunning for a killer.

Man, what no one seems to realize is that vigs are 100% BAD for the town. Either you vig an innocent, or you vig a killer and become a killer, still putting the town down one player. Giving people vigs was just plain EVIL, Tapper.

[D'rek]

Well that was certainly action-packed in the last few days there. Phew. The whole "take" a night action really messed me up and I'm really not sure quite how I managed not to get lynched for that...

[D'rek]

 Korbas, on Jul 20 2009, 09:00 PM, said:

 Barghast, on Jul 17 2009, 12:42 AM, said:

 Tapper, on Jul 15 2009, 02:23 AM, said:

 Bent, on Jul 14 2009, 04:03 PM, said:

Well, it may be a very quick ending indeed.

Well, the killers will have to take one another out, too
But if they lynch a killer day 1, then all on the train start vigging night 2, yeah, we see an awful lot of dead people very fast.

@Sorritt - but look what happens when we lynch a killer!
We would have had three people with vigs, man. XD

Still, I agree, it turned out OK, with two scum dead on night one. But pisses me off that I got lynched for nothing and was actually gunning for a killer.

Man, what no one seems to realize is that vigs are 100% BAD for the town. Either you vig an innocent, or you vig a killer and become a killer, still putting the town down one player. Giving people vigs was just plain EVIL, Tapper.

but they sure do make it entertaining!

[Korbas]

 Path-Shaper, on Jul 17 2009, 06:09 PM, said:

PFener:

Quote

I wonder if anyone else realizes how strategic it is to vote yourself early every day in this game. It puts people in a very awkward position by voting you.

Make no mistake, I despise this alt, but my moves are designed with strategy in mind.

Risky, but it might pay its dues.
frankly, I included the alt without giving thought to the bad vibes it has. Basically, i now hope that a good game by the fener player will break the curse

Voting yourself on day 2 was retarded. But I guess since you were RI, you were allowed to do retarded things.