[Peanutbutta]

teholbeddict, on Apr 30 2009, 10:27 AM, said:

Khellendros, on Apr 30 2009, 12:26 PM, said:

So someone please explain to me what happened with Gem/Meanas? Why did she go kablooie?

Yes what the hell was that?

/shrug

She says she sucks at it and didn't want to do it anymore, pretty much.

Not like everyone can always have a role. Need to learn to play with the hand you're dealt, IMO.

[teholbeddict]

Peanutbutta, on Apr 30 2009, 12:30 PM, said:

teholbeddict, on Apr 30 2009, 10:27 AM, said:

Khellendros, on Apr 30 2009, 12:26 PM, said:

So someone please explain to me what happened with Gem/Meanas? Why did she go kablooie?

Yes what the hell was that?

/shrug

She says she sucks at it and didn't want to do it anymore, pretty much.

Not like everyone can always have a role. Need to learn to play with the hand you're dealt, IMO.

Are you joking???? That screwed our thinking for the whole game! Why not just ask for a modkill for crying out loud!

[Bent]

Gem got pissed that the game seemed to be...nothing...then one hour left...then (her thoought of) scum, made a case....sheep hop on...inno dies.

She was mad that no one was working. She was also upset that her defense was basically being ignored. At least I think thats why. As to why I didn't modkill her for it. Meh, fake reveals happen all the time and she really thought Serc was scum, so hoped to get her target killed by getting herself lynched...not a bad idea, if she had been right, and you had lynched her target. So no, not a modkillable offense imo.

[Bent]

Malaese, Gavin Khellendros, adnd Peanutbutta need to be brought into the HHM group so they can join in on the mafia holics anon threads.

Edit... missed tehol. Tehol as well...if you guys want, pm Morgoth or Silencer and they will add you. Not sure if Ment can do it or not.

This post has been edited by Bent: 30 April 2009 - 05:36 PM

[Mentalist]

@ Gavin: the way thing are looking, i'll be sitting out games for a while ayhow, so I don't care.

RE: Gem: well, crap, that messed up the number-thinking something fierce,

RE: my own suicide--I was fairly sure i'd get lynched anyhow, and going back to my initial feel on Ruse (at least I was consistent there) woudn't have gotten me anywhere.

and still don't hink this is TMDI2--if all 4 were killers initially, then yes.
the way you had it bent, finders were unreliable, and guards were useless.

[Mentalist]

Bent, on Apr 30 2009, 01:35 PM, said:

Malaese, Gavin Khellendros, adnd Peanutbutta need to be brought into the HHM group so they can join in on the mafia holics anon threads.

Edit... missed tehol. Tehol as well...if you guys want, pm Morgoth or Silencer and they will add you. Not sure if Ment can do it or not.

I can't
ask morgy

[Khellendros]

@PB - Just read about your suicide to save another finder revealing, that was awesome play, congrats! Sorry we were too dumb to follow that train of thought through and just suspected you of being a symp instead.

@ Ment - You're right, I highly doubt anyone other than you would have been lynched then anyway, so it's not totally your fault


And Gem's thing did totally threw us off, I feel. Of course, there's every chance that scum would have won anyway, they were looking pretty good then all the same....but it didn't help.

Gamelon (Morg, was it?) was lucky in one sense - we followed up the Mockra lynch by lynching Meanas, D'riss and Emurlahn, all connected in some way to Mockra - but after three inno results on those lynches, I think subconsciously we all decided to stop going down that route...just when the only one left was Gamelon

[Mentalist]

if you were to listen to me telling you Ruse stank to high heaven of scum,

I should have fake-revealed finder,

[Bent]

Mentalist, on Apr 30 2009, 01:37 PM, said:

@ Gavin: the way thing are looking, i'll be sitting out games for a while ayhow, so I don't care.

RE: Gem: well, crap, that messed up the number-thinking something fierce,

RE: my own suicide--I was fairly sure i'd get lynched anyhow, and going back to my initial feel on Ruse (at least I was consistent there) woudn't have gotten me anywhere.

and still don't hink this is TMDI2--if all 4 were killers initially, then yes.
the way you had it bent, finders were unreliable, and guards were useless.

Well, I almost made DW a Jester. But thought better of it. lol. And as to the Tmdi - in the clue game there was one killer and one sym for 13 people, double the people double the scum. It was unbalanced to start because of so few scum roles, and 5 roled innos. So next time, I'll increase the inno roles and see if you guys can win. Meh, no big deal.

[Bent]

Khell - Game was Tapper....sure he'll be flattered to see you thought he was Morgy though.

[bwgan]

Well done bad guys And well played Khell and Tehol. Khell, I have no idea how you managed to survive so long! And Tehol, boy you worked hard...even if you lynched me! I told you I was innocent...what's the matter, don't I have an honest face or something?

Seriously, it was fun to watch, and I have learnt NEVER relax in mafia, it will bite you on the bottom and no mistake.

[Gem Windcaster]

Sorry guys, I didn't mean to ruin anything for you. This game is meant for having fun, and I wasn't having fun at all, also I was bored, which is worse. A part of me wanted to screw over the inno team, basically since everybody sheepishly argued I was scum I thought why not be one? That's why I have kept rooting for the scums. Which was fun.
Bent is right though that I thought that the killers were among the Shadow-Serc-D'riss group. I was awfully wrong, which of course is ironic and hilarious.

Good game everone! And Yay scum win!

This post has been edited by Gem Windcaster: 30 April 2009 - 05:50 PM

[bwgan]

Besides there's an easy way to throw Gem off next time we play! What, what? I never said nothing...


Edit: Oops, she's back...hi Gem thought you'd gone!

This post has been edited by bwgan: 30 April 2009 - 05:52 PM

[Gem Windcaster]

Shh don't don't tell anyone bwgan!


Haha, bwgan, I seeee you!

This post has been edited by Gem Windcaster: 30 April 2009 - 05:57 PM

[Mentalist]

Bent, on Apr 30 2009, 01:45 PM, said:

Mentalist, on Apr 30 2009, 01:37 PM, said:

@ Gavin: the way thing are looking, i'll be sitting out games for a while ayhow, so I don't care.

RE: Gem: well, crap, that messed up the number-thinking something fierce,

RE: my own suicide--I was fairly sure i'd get lynched anyhow, and going back to my initial feel on Ruse (at least I was consistent there) woudn't have gotten me anywhere.

and still don't hink this is TMDI2--if all 4 were killers initially, then yes.
the way you had it bent, finders were unreliable, and guards were useless.

Well, I almost made DW a Jester. But thought better of it. lol. And as to the Tmdi - in the clue game there was one killer and one sym for 13 people, double the people double the scum. It was unbalanced to start because of so few scum roles, and 5 roled innos. So next time, I'll increase the inno roles and see if you guys can win. Meh, no big deal.

THAT NEVER WORKS!!!!

innos end up targetting each other.
if you kept it 4 killers + symp, it would have worked well, I think.
but no replacements--it really messes with you if the killers are paired, and are constantly so.

[teholbeddict]

@Gem So you purposely screwed you own team? Why does that not sit well with me? I'm new to this but I thought part of the whole point of mafia is that it's a team game? I always looked at it more as it didn't matter if you did well as an individual because it was all about the team. Am I wrong here?

@Bwgan Thank you I did do my best, I tried to work as hard as I could! I'm sorry I pushed for your lynch, but it was all that gibberish dear!

[Gem Windcaster]

teholbeddict, nice play! Yeah, just put me on your list, or something.

[Bent]

HA, 11 people are viewing spoilers. I would call this game a success. @ Ment - I like the symp becomes killers mechanic. If you would stop lynching all of the innos, and hit scum before day 5 then the inno roles might be more imortant. Right?

[Mentalist]

@ TB: that's the general idea, but Gem doesn't play by the rules.

[Vengeance]

Bent, on Apr 30 2009, 01:01 PM, said:

HA, 11 people are viewing spoilers. I would call this game a success. @ Ment - I like the symp becomes killers mechanic. If you would stop lynching all of the innos, and hit scum before day 5 then the inno roles might be more imortant. Right?

I loved the symp taking over for the killers. In a game with so many people I think that it worked just fine......





Also mad props to Gem honorary symp...