[Vengeance]

Ok I can't help but snicker at the way that Shadow keeps bringing up everybody as suspects. You want to know why he is suspicious and very probably the next lynch. That is why. People who should be ruled out get dragged back into the suspect pool and frankly that has a tendency to look scummy and sympy. It is great for him to make lists like that but if he doesn't want people to think that he might be a symp then he needs to send them to PS.


-Vengeance loves Khell....

This post has been edited by Vengeance: 29 April 2009 - 09:24 PM

[Vengeance]

Shadow, on Apr 29 2009, 04:10 PM, said:

Well, for one thing, I'm....not ruling out, but certainly putting you and Serc at the bottom of the list of possible evils because of this. Possibly, possibly Korlat as well, as Tennes said he had a 'gut feeling' about them (but that doesn't rule out that Korlat could have had symp status - although if they did, they were very shit symps).

I was hoping someone else could analyse this info as well, though. I'd especially like opinions on whether it's worth pointing out who didn't interact or mention Tennes, as well as who did.

Oh my god if that is what it takes to get him to rule people out then scum can just say that they have a gut feeling about a partner and wala the partner is in the clear. Wow not good. Right conclusion but wrong way to get it. :snigger:

Hopefully someone will jump on and say that very thing.

[Slick Mongoose]

Vengeance, on Apr 29 2009, 10:11 PM, said:

Ok I can't help but snicker at the way that Shadow keeps bringing up everybody as suspects. You want to know why he is suspicious and very probably the next lynch. That is why. People who should be ruled out get dragged back into the suspect pool and frankly that has a tendency to look scummy and sympy. It is great for him to make lists like that but if he doesn't want people to think that he might be a symp then he needs to send them to PS.


-Vengeance loves Kell....

But.... that's just playstyle. Sure, he should be stronger on picking a suspect, but it shouldn't trump his early attack on Mockra for the "symp clue". That's evidence.

[Path-Shaper]

Vengeance, on Apr 29 2009, 05:11 PM, said:

Ok I can't help but snicker at the way that Shadow keeps bringing up everybody as suspects. You want to know why he is suspicious and very probably the next lynch. That is why. People who should be ruled out get dragged back into the suspect pool and frankly that has a tendency to look scummy and sympy. It is great for him to make lists like that but if he doesn't want people to think that he might be a symp then he needs to send them to PS.


-Vengeance loves Kell....

Bent loves Khell so much I can spell his name right....silly cat.

[Path-Shaper]

Peanutbutta, on Apr 29 2009, 04:11 PM, said:

Path-Shaper, on Apr 29 2009, 01:08 PM, said:

Path-Shaper, on Apr 29 2009, 04:06 PM, said:

• Right now it's 6 inno : 2 scum
  
• If the innos mess up today...
  • 4 inno : 2 scum
    
  • If they mess up tomorrow
    • 3 inno : 1 scum
      
    • If they mess up scum win (1 inno : 1 scum)

Fail?

Edit - Bent at peanut

Just a typo, Bent. The logic is the innos get it right either today or tomorrow but not both. Underlined post should be "If they get it right tomorrow."

Also, I completely forgot to mention one thing. Three players completely missed a lynch cycle. That should clear them (or at least indicate that if they are a killer, another killer is in the pack of active posters).

You know, instead of doing the whole pie chart thing its easier to say, Innos must lynch scum in the next 2 days or they lose.....Justt saying.

[Vengeance]

Path-Shaper, on Apr 29 2009, 04:17 PM, said:

Vengeance, on Apr 29 2009, 05:11 PM, said:

Ok I can't help but snicker at the way that Shadow keeps bringing up everybody as suspects. You want to know why he is suspicious and very probably the next lynch. That is why. People who should be ruled out get dragged back into the suspect pool and frankly that has a tendency to look scummy and sympy. It is great for him to make lists like that but if he doesn't want people to think that he might be a symp then he needs to send them to PS.


-Vengeance loves Khell....

Bent loves Khell so much I can spell his name right....silly cat.

Well I must say I don't really like the direction that Shadow and Amp are going in right now. Although if they hurry and lynch Omtose before he has a chance to reveal that would be the funniest thing yet.... :snigger:

[Vengeance]

Uh oh it turns out I had involvement with almost everybody...:snigger: Who so ever agreed with me or I defended must obviously be scum...:snigger:

[Vengeance]

Ahahahaha.... Omtose and Amp are starting to get that sneaky feeling about Khell again. Poor guy he missed a connection and it does look bad.

[Path-Shaper]

From Tapper

Quote

This made me laugh so much:

Serc:

Quote

I doubt the killer(s) will stick to a pattern once it's been revealed, but the fact that it's been there all game is kinda interesting. Could also be setting up Korlat, who knows. Dammit, why is the only drink left in this bar wine, and why is there so much in front of me?

thumbsup.gif

I love wine.

[Shinrei]

drinksinbars, on Apr 29 2009, 04:16 PM, said:

GO TEAM SHIN!!! write yourdeathmatch post you twit!

Sorry...

I will soon, I promise. If another game gets up and running, it's public holidays all next week so I should have time to play AND write my deathmatch post.

It's half done. Meaning its only half-undone. Meaning....Its...not done........but will be?

[Vengeance]

Quote

If you made this case against anyone else, I would be in full agreement with you.

I love Khell. He totally realizes that he is toast and that there is nothing that he can do about it. There is to many connections between him and me. Shit I should have symped more people. But I was to busy keeping my own nose clean. :snigger:

[Peanutbutta]

IMO, Khell/Shadow has played one of the best games of the lot. He's highly vocal but has managed to direct at least one lynch while simultaneously not getting lynched or killed. Furthermore, he's usually at least as correct as he is wrong, far more so than most of the players have been.

Hard to not give the pro play to the killers or symps because let's face it, they have only gotten killed from finders, not mistakes, but I'd give Khell a close runner up.

[Path-Shaper]

Shadow is trying to come up with another plan to save his bacon. Poor guy is getting fingered for suspicious play but it's been the quiet ones running this show. Note that he wants to potentially lay the blame on Gamelon. If he can somehow pull it off and get votes on Gamelon (which would reveal scum), he'll be CI since there obviously can't be many scum left in the game.

Quote

Must...survive....must...keep going....must stop digging my own grave.

Next game, I'm keeping quiet. Actually, screw that, this is way more fun.

I really hope Omtose is an ignorant inno, and not a clever evil. But I really must admit, if his suspicions of me were on anyone else, I'd be the first in the queue to vote!


Tellan or Gamelon, one of them is evil. Well, maybe not, in which case they're going to be the next inno whom I sacrifice in order to keep myself alive. Or, at least, that'll be the plan. Somehow, I think they're going to find it a lot harder to give me another chance.

[Gavin]

I don't understand the Shadow hate either, he should be VPI. He's doing a lot of digging as well I admire his effort. He's even stumbled onto something but so much info that its gone unnoticed. Thats classic symp stuff from Ruse.

Shadow said:

- Ruse mentions that Tennes' behaviour is sort of the opposite in what he noticed and made him suspect Kessobahn.

That all said though, killers need to step up and make a case or at least start pointing fingers. Ruse tried with Tellan, but Omtose has gone the alt guess and Ruse backed down again. After Shadow if they do even lynch him, who do they lynch next?

This post has been edited by Gavin: 30 April 2009 - 02:27 AM

[Path-Shaper]

My guess....Korlat...silent, un noticed....its who I'd push for.

Also I am going to bed, anyone around, feel free to hop in PS and play around, give updates, post pms etc. Night Gavin

[Gavin]

I reread Korlat at one point, and there wasn't much for a case, so it would have to be a laying low not doing anything sort of case. Might fly, but might not. Will be interesting to see how it goes.

So Shin, how did you enjoy your second game of Mafia?

[dktorode]

ugh...

*longs to play*

*cry's in corner*

[Shinrei]

Mafia is great. If a game starts up soon after this one, it'll be perfect since I have a 3 day holiday in addition to the weekend.

Two things:

Why do people (korlat) still seem to be ignorant of Omtose being Ano's partner? I'm too new to have finely tuned mafia detective skills, but Omtose's post where she starts a gentle case on Shadow, FOLLOWED by Ano's PM post which indicates his partner saying "I've started a gentle case on Shadow" is like getting hit over the head with a 2x4. Especially given the fact there are very few posts after the previous lynch and nothing to indicate anyone OTHER than Omtose.

And Gem... maybe this is Mafia noob talking, but I have zero understanding about the game you played. You seemed to be all over the place and openly confrontational at the drop of a pin. Why?

[HoosierDaddy]

I think she was pissed at the game the Innos were playing, Shin, and tried to shake things up by self-destructing.

Also, I think she was bored with RI.

This post has been edited by HoosierDaddy: 30 April 2009 - 08:18 AM

[Gavin]

Its pretty obvious Omtose is the partner for me as well. My only defence for Korlat is that he isn't around much so he might have skimmed through catching up. Also I've noticed you get a completely different perspective with catching up on a bunch of posts, and being there at the time and replying and reading. But yeah should still pick up on it.

I can't explain Gem to you HoosierDaddy is probably right.