[Mockra]

heh, in response to your question, he's new. the thought of there being 2 witches probably didn't occur to him.

Edit: cross post @ Meanas

This post has been edited by Mockra: 28 January 2009 - 10:56 PM

[Shadow]

Mockra what are your thoughts on Silanah?

Bah!! nvm, I already asked you. this thread is getting way to big for me to remember everything

This post has been edited by Shadow: 28 January 2009 - 10:55 PM

[Mockra]

Shadow, on Jan 28 2009, 05:50 PM, said:

No, I agree with not lynching Ano. I was right there with you. Personally I don't think he was scum. He played exactly how he did in the other 2 games I have been in with him, and he was inno both times.

Mockra- I am not trying to insult your play or not give you credit. But knowing that Emur was a Killer. That quote makes you look like a symp.

Regardless, just putting it out there. defensive much?

lol, no
I am perfectly resigned to the fact that people might lynch me as a symp. I have made a mistake in revealing, though with the information I had, I did not see how I can act otherwise. At least I have consolation that in all likelyhood the numbers are different from what I feared, so wrongfully lynching me will not in itself cost the innos the game.
but if people are gonna lynch me, I at least want it to be based on something passably solid.
obviosly, since I'm not scum, (as I will make sure to point out numerous times once you all get to spoilers), no case is really gonna be good, but i'd like people to at least try to look for something, other than simply picking up the first thing I said on day 1 and going ZOMG, symp!

[Mockra]

Shadow, on Jan 28 2009, 05:54 PM, said:

Mockra what are your thoughts on Silanah?

Bah!! nvm, I already asked you. this thread is getting way to big for me to remember everything

yes you did

[Meanas]

Mockra, on Jan 28 2009, 10:51 PM, said:

heh, in response to your question, he's new. the thought of there being 2 witches probably didn't occur to him.

I don't buy or excuse people for any kind of noob behavior. Gem beat that out of me.

Another thing that I thought of is Mockra might have used his BP and then revealed to make us think that Ando was the killer. Cause now all his real killer has to do is to not kill tonight. WIFOM I know but still.

As to knowing that Ando wasn't scum do to his play in previous games. That is so bad. I mean that would be like me knowing that Mockra and Thyrllan couldn't possibly be scum cause of how they play scum in previous games. Bad idea. I like them both but they could be scum. A good player trys not to change how he plays when he is scum or not. Without a CF you really have no idea if someone was scum or not. At least I don't.

[Meanas]

Shadow, on Jan 28 2009, 10:54 PM, said:

Mockra what are your thoughts on Silanah?

Bah!! nvm, I already asked you. this thread is getting way to big for me to remember everything

Silanah seems like he has managed to slide by seeming to be just helpful enough. Several people have made cases on him but none of them have ever seemed to stick. Usually cause most of the cases are just about how short his posts are and how he doesn't really seem to post anything of substance except for once in a great while. He could easily be a very cool killer/Necro who hasn't made one mistake so far.

[Mockra]

Meanas, on Jan 28 2009, 05:59 PM, said:

Mockra, on Jan 28 2009, 10:51 PM, said:

heh, in response to your question, he's new. the thought of there being 2 witches probably didn't occur to him.

I don't buy or excuse people for any kind of noob behavior. Gem beat that out of me.

Another thing that I thought of is Mockra might have used his BP and then revealed to make us think that Ando was the killer. Cause now all his real killer has to do is to not kill tonight. WIFOM I know but still.

As to knowing that Ando wasn't scum do to his play in previous games. That is so bad. I mean that would be like me knowing that Mockra and Thyrllan couldn't possibly be scum cause of how they play scum in previous games. Bad idea. I like them both but they could be scum. A good player trys not to change how he plays when he is scum or not. Without a CF you really have no idea if someone was scum or not. At least I don't.

that is the tragedy of this entire game.. and the blame can be placed squarely at Morgoth,

[Meanas]

Ok now I am out of here. Later guys

[Mockra]

Meanas, on Jan 28 2009, 06:03 PM, said:

Shadow, on Jan 28 2009, 10:54 PM, said:

Mockra what are your thoughts on Silanah?

Bah!! nvm, I already asked you. this thread is getting way to big for me to remember everything

Silanah seems like he has managed to slide by seeming to be just helpful enough. Several people have made cases on him but none of them have ever seemed to stick. Usually cause most of the cases are just about how short his posts are and how he doesn't really seem to post anything of substance except for once in a great while. He could easily be a very cool killer/Necro who hasn't made one mistake so far.

he suddenly got very energetic on day 3, once we lost the CF, spearheading the lynch of a supposed necro Kas, based on WIFOM of Morgoth's death.

the speed with which he pulled that off made me think Necro before, now i'm not so sure though...

[Meanas]

Mockra, on Jan 28 2009, 11:03 PM, said:

Meanas, on Jan 28 2009, 05:59 PM, said:

Mockra, on Jan 28 2009, 10:51 PM, said:

heh, in response to your question, he's new. the thought of there being 2 witches probably didn't occur to him.

I don't buy or excuse people for any kind of noob behavior. Gem beat that out of me.

Another thing that I thought of is Mockra might have used his BP and then revealed to make us think that Ando was the killer. Cause now all his real killer has to do is to not kill tonight. WIFOM I know but still.

As to knowing that Ando wasn't scum do to his play in previous games. That is so bad. I mean that would be like me knowing that Mockra and Thyrllan couldn't possibly be scum cause of how they play scum in previous games. Bad idea. I like them both but they could be scum. A good player trys not to change how he plays when he is scum or not. Without a CF you really have no idea if someone was scum or not. At least I don't.

that is the tragedy of this entire game.. and the blame can be placed squarely at Morgoth,

I have sent 4 or 5 huge rants about it to Path-shaper. Just about every time someone dies I get pissed again.

[Thyrllan]

Meanas, on Jan 28 2009, 10:59 PM, said:

As to knowing that Ando wasn't scum do to his play in previous games. That is so bad. I mean that would be like me knowing that Mockra and Thyrllan couldn't possibly be scum cause of how they play scum in previous games. Bad idea. I like them both but they could be scum. A good player trys not to change how he plays when he is scum or not. Without a CF you really have no idea if someone was scum or not. At least I don't.

I like you too.
Or I would be able to say so with more certainty if I knew who you were.
But I like everyone who plays, so I do like you.
Well, except that mystery guest guy.
He's creepy

This post has been edited by Thyrllan: 28 January 2009 - 11:10 PM

[Shadow]

Meanas, on Jan 28 2009, 02:59 PM, said:

As to knowing that Ando wasn't scum do to his play in previous games. That is so bad. I mean that would be like me knowing that Mockra and Thyrllan couldn't possibly be scum cause of how they play scum in previous games.

I didn't base my assumption just on that... I'm not that stupid. IThey aren't supposed to change playstyle, but often they do. Actually my belief that he is not scum is based more on how he played this game, The sheer amount of effort and work he put into making 3 huge cases. Generally scum don't do that. otoh.. My mafia gut is surprisingly wrong...a lot... I mean, a ...LOT.

@Mockra- You are really making it tough to believe you are scum. I hate you a little bit

[Mockra]

Shadow, on Jan 28 2009, 06:23 PM, said:

Meanas, on Jan 28 2009, 02:59 PM, said:

As to knowing that Ando wasn't scum do to his play in previous games. That is so bad. I mean that would be like me knowing that Mockra and Thyrllan couldn't possibly be scum cause of how they play scum in previous games.

I didn't base my assumption just on that... I'm not that stupid. IThey aren't supposed to change playstyle, but often they do. Actually my belief that he is not scum is based more on how he played this game, The sheer amount of effort and work he put into making 3 huge cases. Generally scum don't do that. otoh.. My mafia gut is surprisingly wrong...a lot... I mean, a ...LOT.

@Mockra- You are really making it tough to believe you are scum. I hate you a little bit

I always play honest when inno. it's much simpler that way.
incidentally, if D'riss is scum, I must say, great job on the counter-reveal.

[Shadow]

There is just nothing on Sil. I am beating a dead horse.

does it feel to anyone else like we are just sitting around waiting to lynch at the end of the day?

[Thyrllan]

Yes.
I think its down to lack of CF, making info sparse/unreliable.

[Mockra]

well, I'm around to answer any questions/listen to any theories people may have.

[Mockra]

I expect spoilers for this game will be epic.

[Morgoth]

Mockra, on Jan 29 2009, 12:41 AM, said:

I expect spoilers for this game will be epic.

we laufgh at syiu all lieks you;r'e litt egirls with vodgka

[Shadow]

Vote Morgoth

for being drunk before me, and making this game 10 times more difficult than it has to be.

[Hood's Path]

To be perfectly honest I have no idea who to vote for at this point. I was leaning towards Mockra and now I'm not too sure. I don't want to just take the simple way out and vote him because there is really nothing on anyone else. I read through the past posts of quite a few people to see if I could spot anything suspicious and nothing jumped out at me. I am at a complete loss at the moment!


Edit typo

This post has been edited by Hood's Path: 28 January 2009 - 11:59 PM