Shadow, on Jan 28 2009, 07:05 PM, said:
Omtose, on Jan 28 2009, 09:27 AM, said:
Oki, I caught up.
two things need adressing:
1. the two witches. I think it is not totally fucked-up that we have 2 of them, operating independently, especially not since the game swelled to a gigantic size, and team inno probably already had 2 finders. All things considered, even if it is a blanket kill & recruit stop, there are also 2 possible NKs (vigs excluded) in the game, and the chance that 2 independent ones might fire theirs on the same night when things get hairy. Lastly, they'd also hinder the Medium on account of there being no dead guy to ask answers of.
Doesn't mean that I'd legitimize both reveals, but their story is not directly conflicting either - I guess I hope our Psychic mindreader-hypnotist(s) are actively investigating them tonight.
As such, I do find it complete and utter bull to now lynch either of them to test their reveal. There's no CF to tell us anything, after all.
Also, we have to examine who would reveal like this and get away with it - we currently have lynched a psycho and one undead (probably a recruit) and then, imho, most or all necros. The Creature wouldn't reveal like this, and I doubt a final necromancer would - same for the psycho's - so that means either a recruit or a symp and neither can win the game on their own.
2. Ruse. I see you fingering a LOT of people. Casting doubt here and there - see my reaction above for a gross error (if I'm positive) or deliberate misrepresentation (if I'm negative) on your part. You've also called Mockra a symp, pushing his half reveal, now calling attention to D'riss, naming Galain and oh, wait, Silanah too, I think.
Never presenting a definate case.
I name thee symp, and since I don't have a whole lot better to do right now:
Vote Ruse.
Why are you voting for a suspected symp? Who is he protecting? Who hasn't he fingered. (get your mind out of the gutter!)
I don't think he is protecting. I think he's done some maths and has come to the conclusion that we're running out of necromancers
Perfect time for the symp to start getting team inno to lynch amongst itself and start pointing out targets - and a very safe start is middle-of-the-roaders or people previously accused. The double witch-reveal also lends itself to the natural causing of suspicions.
As for why vote for a possible symp?
Lemme see. First and foremost, right now, I haven't spotted someone who behaves killer-ish, which would of course be the best choice, so I'll have to settle for a secondary target. nWe've run out of the logical lynching chain for the cult, too. Secondary targets are symps, I'd say - and failing those, well, pressuring inactive people into contributing or leaving the middle of the road.
Right now, the people I'd like to see more contribution of are D'riss, Galain, Thyrllan - but none of them has been very suspicious imho so far.
HP - maybe scum, but probably not.
Actually, I see today as an interim day, we can afford to be wrong in our lynchtarget I think, especially if we have taken care of the Creature.
That makes today an ideal day to take care of people who rubbed others wrongly... and I guess I belong on that list, as well, thanks to my day 1 behaviour. Actually, of the list I made earlier of 'town must lynch these cause they're behaving too suspiciously' list, only myself and Galain are still alive.
This post has been edited by Omtose: 28 January 2009 - 06:33 PM
Help
