Ah my favourite debate, surfaces again, the Encyclopedia Malazica has feather witches readings for you to look at if you want
here
My personal theories, the Empty hold seems to change from when we first see it, to the seocnd time, Udinass refers to it as:
'The Hold that had existed, unseen, at the very beginning. The Empty Hold - heart of Letherii worship - that was at the very centre of the vast spiral of realms. Home to the Throne that knew no King, home to the Wanderer Knight, and to the Mistress who waited still, alone in her bed of dreams. To the Watcher, who witnessed all, and the Walker, who patrolled borders not even he could see. To the Saviour, whose outstretched hand was never grasped. And, finally, to the Betrayer, whose loving embrace destroyed all it touched.' (MT, p.31, UK Trade)
In that reading the throne is empty, the Mistress seems to be the QoD, the Walker seems to be edgewalker, the Wander Knight is probably traveller, the rest I'll leave you to debate on.
In Feather Witches reading the positions seem to have changed, reflecting now the conflict on the Letherii continent as the two forces contest with each other.
The Watchers stand in place as if made of stone! Their faces are masks of horror.
Not sure on this one, presumably a member of the Edur and vice versa a member of the humans who are shocked at what is happening, but can do nothing to stop it... Hannan Mossag or Fear and the First Eunuch, Brys or Tehol come to mind, all of whom desire peace but could not achieve it.
The Mistresses dance with thwarted desire
Seren and Mayen
The Wanderers have broken through the ice and cold darkness comes with its deadly embrace
To me this suggests the Jheck and the andii spirits, both of whom have come from the icefields of the North. Though it could equally refer solely to the andii spirits, as it fits them more exactly, and the andii are split between those who MUST follow the Edur, and those who work agaisnt them and are not bound
The Walkers cannot halt in the growing torrent that pulls them ever onward
Hull, who encouraged the war and now cannot stop it, and seems tto eb identified with walkers, and possibly king Ezgara Diskanar, who also could not prevent the war and now the Letherii rush ever onwars into it, though that's tenuous. Binidas possibly? he's also a walker like Trull and one of the Brothers Brys? also dragged along by the war
The Saviours -face one another, and both are doomed, and in broken reflection so stand the Betrayers, and this is what lies before us, before us all
This is a difficult one, Trull seems an obvious contender for the position of Betrayer, and plausibly saviour as well. Rhulad also seems to fit both these roles, as figure who has betrayed the Edur to the CG, yet is seen as the saviour.
Other's who could fit in here, include Udinass or the Ceda, but I prefer the ocupation of the two roles by Trull and Rhulad alternatly, for the pleasing symmetry if nothing else.
So:
The Empty Throne: empty
The Watchers: (Nifidas, the First Eunuch?, Brys? Tehol?)/(Hannan Mossag? Fear?)
The Mistresses: Seren Pedac/Mayen
The Wanderers: The Andii spirits/The Jheck (or possibly solely the andii)
The Walkers: Hull/(Ezgara Diskanar? Binidas? Brys?)
The Saviours: Trull/Rhulad
The Betrayers: Rhulad/Trull
The references to the brothers suggest the Sengar brothers occupy many of the positions or those associated with them, and a possible pleasing symmetry would be to have the Beddict bortehrs associated with the positions.
What do you think?
I'd say the following is the most likely, with one of the two sets of brothers occupying the majority of the positions:
The Empty Throne: empty
The Watchers: (Tehol or Brys)/Fear
The Mistresses: Seren Pedac/Mayen
The Wanderers: The Andii spirits
The Walkers: Hull/(Binidas or Brys)
The Saviours: Trull/Rhulad
The Betrayers: Rhulad/Trull
Help
