Help
There most definitely is an impression of scrambling in Ara's behaviour, and I don't wholly agree with some of the methods you employ in determining use's partner, but this
Aranatha, on 07 January 2019 - 03:31 PM, said:
This is getting funny. Let's pick apart Ruse's posts on D3, because there's more bullshit in them that I've seen in the entire game so far.
This one is a gem:
Aranatha's vote - there is no Aranatha's vote. I haven't voted - you have. In the first post on D-Day, which is scummy af. I will not vote until we hear from Jalan and Ay.
he'd call me scum as a last defense - I called you scum on D2. I voted against you. It's rich to now claim I'm saying you're scum as a 'defense', after I've built a case against you on the previous day. Who's really on the defense here?
his actions make me thing I'm right - which actions?
because after day 1, I have been pretty sure (unless I'm crazy) that Jalan is town - so you're saying you have a read on Jalan as town and me as scum and you're storming out with a vote first thing on D-Day? With no discussion, no re-reads, no arguments? Even tho you know you could be Insane Finder? Yeah, great move.
NEXT:
I'm not claiming insane. I'm just saying I could be. I have no way of knowing for sure.
So you say you don't know for sure but you still open D-Day with a vote. Great.
And for the grand finale:
You are pushing the assumption that I'm insane - another thing you made up. I am not assuming you're the insane finder, I'm assuming you're scum. And I have been since D2.
There has been no PUSHING for a lynch, only a vote. - what is a D-Day vote if a not a push for lynch, ffs.
If you just went out and said: I have a read on Aranatha as scum and Jalan as town I'd be inclined to believe you're the Insane Finder whose goal is to give us useful information (obviously, you wouldn't know whether you're insane or not). But you're opening with a vote. You're pushing for a quick lynch on D-Day which can mean one of two things: you're either full of shit or you're a townie playing so bad I almost want to lynch you on principle.
This one is a gem:
Ruse, on 06 January 2019 - 04:23 PM, said:
I'm not surprised by Aranatha's vote against me. It was a given that he'd call me scum as a last defense. I didn't up my participation because he called me out, I was just busy, but had been frank about my opinions in the few posts I'd made.
So... I could be the crazy one, but his actions make me think I'm right he's scum. Ironic that he picked Jalan to pair with me, because after day 1, I have been pretty sure (unless I'm crazy) that Jalan is town. If it helps to debunk Aranatha's claim, I'll point out that there has been zero distancing between us, which would be stupid play for killers in such a small game.
This IS dday unless we lynch scum, so I'd hope we lynch Aranatha. If we do, I expect to be dead, so I doubt I can provide anymore insights. I'll reread and post my guess on Aranatha's partner.
So... I could be the crazy one, but his actions make me think I'm right he's scum. Ironic that he picked Jalan to pair with me, because after day 1, I have been pretty sure (unless I'm crazy) that Jalan is town. If it helps to debunk Aranatha's claim, I'll point out that there has been zero distancing between us, which would be stupid play for killers in such a small game.
This IS dday unless we lynch scum, so I'd hope we lynch Aranatha. If we do, I expect to be dead, so I doubt I can provide anymore insights. I'll reread and post my guess on Aranatha's partner.
Aranatha's vote - there is no Aranatha's vote. I haven't voted - you have. In the first post on D-Day, which is scummy af. I will not vote until we hear from Jalan and Ay.
he'd call me scum as a last defense - I called you scum on D2. I voted against you. It's rich to now claim I'm saying you're scum as a 'defense', after I've built a case against you on the previous day. Who's really on the defense here?
his actions make me thing I'm right - which actions?
because after day 1, I have been pretty sure (unless I'm crazy) that Jalan is town - so you're saying you have a read on Jalan as town and me as scum and you're storming out with a vote first thing on D-Day? With no discussion, no re-reads, no arguments? Even tho you know you could be Insane Finder? Yeah, great move.
NEXT:
Ruse, on 07 January 2019 - 01:20 AM, said:
Fanderay, on 07 January 2019 - 12:00 AM, said:
At this point I think it's safe to say that one of you is scum. I'm inclined to believe that Ruse is claiming insane finder. Whether I believe him or not? Not sure.
It would be nice to get at least an "I'm here" from Jalan and Ay.
It would be nice to get at least an "I'm here" from Jalan and Ay.
I'm not claiming insane. I'm just saying I could be. I have no way of knowing for sure.
So you say you don't know for sure but you still open D-Day with a vote. Great.
And for the grand finale:
Ruse, on 07 January 2019 - 02:43 PM, said:
You are pushing the assumption that I'm insane, which I am finding more and more unlikely. I think revealing you as scum early allows the rest of town time to reread and make a sound decision. There has been no PUSHING for a lynch, only a vote.
You are pushing the assumption that I'm insane - another thing you made up. I am not assuming you're the insane finder, I'm assuming you're scum. And I have been since D2.
There has been no PUSHING for a lynch, only a vote. - what is a D-Day vote if a not a push for lynch, ffs.
If you just went out and said: I have a read on Aranatha as scum and Jalan as town I'd be inclined to believe you're the Insane Finder whose goal is to give us useful information (obviously, you wouldn't know whether you're insane or not). But you're opening with a vote. You're pushing for a quick lynch on D-Day which can mean one of two things: you're either full of shit or you're a townie playing so bad I almost want to lynch you on principle.
I see as a solid response despite the scrambliness
Personally there's not much about possible partnerships of both of you to tell which is more likely to be scum and I don't have the time to go through what there is about that (and I don't give Ara's analysis much weight either)
Ara's behaviour still comes off as scummy to me but I think it's mostly in correspondence with their play whole game, not sure what exactly that means
There was little in Ruse's play to make me think scum until this day, well there was them only coming out when called out, also there's the concept of being "too clean". Now I'm kinda having hard time imagining this play as town. So if you were a finder, there's the question what made you so sure you're not the insane one and your vote isn't gonna lose us the game, because there was exactly a 50% chance of that and you voted immediately after the day started without providing any analysis or reason really and still haven't done so until now, if you are town this is straight bad play, Aranatha also has some good points in their last reply that you just shrug off.
I find Aranatha scummy but I'm really having trouble interpreting Ruse's play right now. Exam tommorow and procrastination's bitch and I don't feel capable of making any coherent conclusions right now and really should get to bed. The exam's around the same time as eod so I'll just have to make up my mind sometime in the morning, sigh.
