So, I'll start with Tatts.
Straight off, I don't think he's scum. This interaction was the first to jump out at me:
Tattersail, on 03 December 2012 - 02:40 PM, said:
Blend, on 03 December 2012 - 02:34 PM, said:
Tattersail, on 03 December 2012 - 02:23 PM, said:
Vengeance, on 03 December 2012 - 02:04 PM, said:
So far I see several good cases that I could get behind.
The EM case is strong and yet so is the Khell case. Both have a lot of merit in my book. But you know who really needs to be lynched. Bubba, it has been a while since he played mafia and what better way to welcome someone back into the warm mafia embrace then to lynch them before they can post.
Vote Bubba
Plus he is an admin so the hate and rage that would roll off of him would be impressive.

Ha ha, so cruel I love it!
Remove Vote
Vote Bubba
You're being kind of wanton with your votes, don't you think?
No. Later on in the day then maybe, but this early in the game I don't think so. I'd like to build up some trains, see how people react, see how agress and disagrees with people. see who is trying to hard or not taking the game seriously enough. I see what you are saying but i'd prefer a lot of people to be active, adding pressure, building cases. You get no where by staying silent
If Blend had been seriously concerned that Tatts, as his partner, was throwing lots of votes around, then this would have been kept off thread. Particularly at this stage of the game there was no need for distancing, and so this interaction looks like prodding from two people who are unconnected.
Later, Blend builds a case on Tatts:
Blend, on 06 December 2012 - 02:10 AM, said:
Alright, upon closer inspection, I can say that I'm a little more suspicious of Starling. Day 1, he didn't really participate much - a post asking Tats why he moved away from supicions of EM, then voting for HO cause he was suspicious of the train redirect. I personally thought the case on HO was crap, yesterday, so I wasn't terribly surprised when the train redirected. Venge was certainly acting a bunch more scummy, even if he did CF as inno.
The thing that bothers me, though, is his behaviour for this day. He basically spent the entire day trying to paint Tats as a symp. He votes Shin, accusing him of having redirected the train, when there was like a triple cross post (which, admittedly, I was a part of) that all moved the train from HO to Venge, and pushing the idea that Tats is Shin's symp. When Shin rebuffs the accusations, he backs off from the Shin attack, but maintains his suspicions of Tats being a symp. I think that Starling is, in fact, the symp, and that he's trying to paint Tats as a symp so that we'll disregard Tats as a possible killer, or that we'll let him slide thinking that he's a symp, so there's no point in voting him off.
I know this jives with my earlier statement about Tats not being dumb enough to kill someone as obviously linked to him as KL was, but, I dunno, Starling's behaviour just rubs me the wrong way. For now, I will
vote Tattersail
As I think he's probably being protected by Starling.
I would still be willing to move my vote to Azath, but I think this is at least as solid a case, so I thought I'd put it out there.
Not particularly conclusive on it's own, but again, there had been no one connecting Blend and Tatts, and so no reason to distance. While it is certainly possible for one scum partner to build a case on another, it seems unlikely under these particular circumstances.
The biggest thing for me, though, is Bubba's case on Tatts. Based on his play over the previous day, I'm convinced he was the symp. The symp would never build a case on scum, and Bubba comes down very hard on Tatts' comments, in some cases wilfully misinterpreting them.
Bubba, on 09 December 2012 - 10:03 PM, said:
Tattersail, on 09 December 2012 - 09:51 PM, said:
Bubba, on 09 December 2012 - 04:53 PM, said:
Tattersail, on 09 December 2012 - 11:41 AM, said:
Starling I have a problem voting Azath today. I will not tomorrow it depends on who he finds tonight and the outcome.
How dodgy does it look that both Blend and Bubba are voting Azath when multiple people find them at least a little bit scummy.
Fair enough you think I'm scummy and you've.thought that since day one, that's fine. All I can do is make my thoughts known.
I think Blend is a symp or killer and Bubba is symp or killer leaving another symp or killer out there. From your comments above you suggest that you could be a killer but I will go on thinking that it would.be bad etiquette for a killer to play that way, by showing disinterest you get overlooked and that is why HO was frowned upon a few games back.
Shin or Khell is my bet for the other killer.
I'm happy to vote either of the ones I mentioned. Not so much on azath yet. Not starling gnaw or HO.
It does not make sense to do otherwise. Assuming two killers AND Azath IS one then well know more about him tomorrow. There is still another one out there.
I think Gust Hubbs death points fingers towards Azath and I think they (the killers) are setting us up.
This is your scummiest comment to date. How the fuck could the killers know who Azath was doing a find on?
Tatts, that comment pins you as the symp in my mind. You will do anything to protect your master.
You want mw to expand on that comment but ignore the rest of my post?
Gust made a case against azath and round up dead, this points us towards Azath. How do you not comprehend that?
How do you comprehend A finder looking for townies? I don't think that has ever happened in any game I have ever played/modded/or read. It is the worst excuse I have ever heard...well maybe not the worst, but it's up there. There were a lot of people on that train(and if you notice not ME. I didn't think he was scum at that point), I can see the killers picking GH for being on that train, but I can not see Azath picking GH for a find, on the basis of being town. Now you are all calling me "lazy and Disinterested" I am doing neither. I am ONLY acting when I see scummy behavior. I'm not voting on a whim. and I am sure as hell not trying to run the game. I made my case, I let everyone comment, read all those comments, then I acted on them. How the fuck is this called scummy behavior is beyond me.
Bubba, on 09 December 2012 - 10:07 PM, said:
Tattersail, on 09 December 2012 - 09:54 PM, said:
Sorry just read other replies. Bubba I make a long post in reply to what starling said and the thing you do is pick up on one sentence just like you did with Gnaw a few posts back. Is this your town play style I think not. The more.gov post the more you scream scum
No I am picking up on you trying to railroad me. And in my eyes protect scum. That is why I jumped on that comment. You are dead set on making sure Azath doesn't get lyched "un-till tomorrow" Why? We need to hit scum today to at least get their numbers down. And I see you delaying that. on purpose?
So, Tatts, probably inno.