[Korbas]

Atrahal, on 04 June 2012 - 09:19 PM, said:

Osseric is Batman!

Goddammit.

Okay.


Remove Vote

[Emurlahn]

Good Job Atrahal, I didn't remove vote either so my vote is still on Meanas.

Remove Vote

Vote Spite

His last post was about the Joker or a Joke on the Joker but the post was a Joke which wasn't funny

[Meanas]

Ok, putting on my reading glasses, lighting my pipe, and sitting down before the hearth and getting all scholarly yo.

First of all, 5 people will need to outlast day 1, correct? Best way to do that is be middling, calm, composed, maybe even just the slightest bit spammy

Korbas, getting too worked up.
Atrahal, maybe, but still being too playful (and seriously you think someone knows who batman is already? seems a stretch to me)
Emur, more likely, but trying to lead the thread, more likely bold town.

[Korbas]

Should we make everyone say Osseric is Batman?

[Meanas]

Korbas, on 04 June 2012 - 09:23 PM, said:

Should we make everyone say Osseric is Batman?

Ooooooh ooohhh OOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!

[Meanas]

cough, sorry... glasses were knocked askew for a sec there.

[Atrahal]

That pattern of events won't work, as cult leaders won't always recruit town, and will strike out if they attempt to recruit other cult leaders or BM. The odds of doing that increase as town population goes down. Town still loses if cult leader numbers stay high, but who knows? Perhaps BM has an alter ego? Point is, it's too early to start turning on people without evidence, and there has been no evidence worth the name so far.

[Emurlahn]

Meanas, on 04 June 2012 - 09:22 PM, said:

Ok, putting on my reading glasses, lighting my pipe, and sitting down before the hearth and getting all scholarly yo.

First of all, 5 people will need to outlast day 1, correct? Best way to do that is be middling, calm, composed, maybe even just the slightest bit spammy

Korbas, getting too worked up.
Atrahal, maybe, but still being too playful (and seriously you think someone knows who batman is already? seems a stretch to me)
Emur, more likely, but trying to lead the thread, more likely bold town.

What about Rashan he's high up on the list. I also got your first post were I do believe some people may not have.

[Emurlahn]

Korbas, on 04 June 2012 - 09:23 PM, said:

Should we make everyone say Osseric is Batman?

Osseric is Batman although I don't believe that he is. There are 0 prohibitions against reveals as per the OP. Although you cannot quote your PM.

[Korbas]

Against role reveals, sure. Its probably just the Joker fucking with us.

Osseric is Batman.

[Atrahal]

I'm Spartacus!

[Atrahal]

Also:

Remove vote

[Meanas]

Emurlahn, on 04 June 2012 - 09:25 PM, said:

Meanas, on 04 June 2012 - 09:22 PM, said:

Ok, putting on my reading glasses, lighting my pipe, and sitting down before the hearth and getting all scholarly yo.

First of all, 5 people will need to outlast day 1, correct? Best way to do that is be middling, calm, composed, maybe even just the slightest bit spammy

Korbas, getting too worked up.
Atrahal, maybe, but still being too playful (and seriously you think someone knows who batman is already? seems a stretch to me)
Emur, more likely, but trying to lead the thread, more likely bold town.

What about Rashan he's high up on the list. I also got your first post were I do believe some people may not have.

He's an interesting one alrighty. He likes pointing fingers, trying very hard to play a serious game while not looking serious (making cute remarks and the like). I also like how he keeps pointing out "signaling" when there really is no reason to signal. I mean, any recruit is told who recruited him, correct?

I'll bite

Vote Rashan

[Eloth]

Meanas, on 04 June 2012 - 09:17 PM, said:

22
4 cult leaders
1 bowel movement
17 town

BCS: BM lynched once, cultists all recruit successfully
4 leaders each with a follower (4)
1 bowel movement
12 town

Repeat
4 leaders with their followers (8)
1 bowel movement
7 town

Repeat
4 leaders with their followers (12)
1 bowel movement
2 town

Repeat, BM dead, town LOSE!!!! awwwwwww

not likely, more infighting, but I wouldn't expect to come out clean. Play for the long haul

Interesting that you call this your BCS aka BEST CASE SCENARIO. It isn't for anyone but the recruiters. I don't think the B and W are that close to each other on a keyboard to make this just a common typo.

[Emurlahn]

The thing is i'd vote along but I pose a question. If you were the recruiter and there were 22 players playing this game and you'd have to last at least 1 maybe 2 days for a symp to show up or a succesful recruit to go through then how would you play? Personally i'd want to lay low, amongst the lower echelons of our comrades. That way if accused of low posting I could blame RL issues or come up with any kind of excuse. 4 cult leaders. Not all of them would play the same. You could say middle of the road people but we have had enough games to know what works and what doesn't. From Spite up to Fener would be a good guess for at least one if not two or three cult leaders. So that is Spite, Osseric, Sheltatha, Korvalian, Omtose and Fener.

My reasoning would be that this is going to be a long game so I wouldn't want to be alted, or caught on my lack of knowledge of the town role and if I stay low until I recruit then i'll have a symp to steer the thread away from me and my faction.

My vote is on Spite due to his comment just after the Joker broadcast. Osseric is in doubt because of the deciphered message. Someone mentioned Omtose earlier and the other three also look suspect.

[Emurlahn]

These all have 6 -8 posts each by the way. I'm going to read through but it could take some time.

[Emurlahn]

Fener speculates on Batman being an offensive player and not defensive. I don't know who he is talking to but he seems to either know about Batman or is just trying to disprove someone who said he is a defensive character.

Quote

I can see the argument from both sides, so I'm fine with dropping the discussion on it, but even the dissecting of the syntax aside, the POINT of the Batman role in this game is to kill the recruiters. This makes him unequivocally an offensive role. Regardless of his defensive abilities, he is not a defensive role.

and his last post was this

Quote

Ah, I would not have picked up on that, but I guess it does make sense. The message just still seems worded oddly. It would seem like the villains would be trying to hide from Batman, not flush him out into the open. A Batman lynch is good for them (although he could have an LP), but basically asking everyone on thread to reveal who Batman is doesn't seem to make sense from the cult recruiters' point of view. Except for the fact that obviously they don't want to target him for a recruit, but the odds of that are so low on day one it's not worth discussing.

make of that what you will. I see someone who hasn't voted at all yet and is just speculating on Batman mainly.

Omtose

Quote

Underwear outside my pants just isn't my style. I find Rashan's on thread speculation interesting. Rashan would be a great alt for BM. Or maybe he's offerring himself up to get recruited by Two-Face.

I like this post by Omtose at least he is pointing fingers.

Quote

Downplaying Batman's role? The rules clearly state that he is a PREDATOR with abilities to TAKE DOWN the recruiters. This is not a defensive role.

This post resembles fener's post. They are both responding to Korbas who said, "

Quote

Batman is defensive, it seems.

"



For now i'd be willing to eliminate both of these from the recruiter suspect list unless something else crops up.

[Emurlahn]

Korvalian wants Dragonsecks but doesn't get it. (recruiter wanting to up their post count?)

Votes for Shelly, calls Eloth a symp and then makes that error people are talking about.

Quote

Galain is a admitting to being a criminal!

Is this a slip? When Korbas calls him on it he removes vote and goes to bed.

Korvalian is a maybe.

[Emurlahn]

Shelly has about 8 posts all of which are a vote. I don't know why he's done this as it makes your vote seem less important yet I cannot see a recruiter doing this, unless that was his intention in which case

Osseric

easiest to quote wow looky here...

Quote

• I do not, actually. You guys were eager. What have I missed? Please skip the sex if anyone answers.
• Still recovering from last game. My soul is worn thin at the moment.
• Anyone that dresses in tights should be labeled a criminal. So ESPECIALLY batman.
• You would have been better off not stepping up to take a swing at that pitch.
• talking about korv feeling the need to defend not your remark
• Only a slight possibility so far, and not for the same reasons as you. Probably nothing, though. Right?
• What is sad is that this is actually the type of reasoning we will end up using for our Day 1 anyway.

Bored townie? Or something more? No thoughts on the game, nothing to add or produce discussion just a few one liners.

[Karosis]

Right, I see people have been busy in my absence, let's go and take a gander.