[Barghast]

oh, shit, khell was recruited? sa-weet.

[Barghast]

nop one is on. LAAAME

i'm going to bed.

[Gamelon]

There seems to be a lot of drinking on thread this game...

Atra's CF is rather a relief, since aside from finally catching scum, I wasn't sure if we were going to find out if people had been recruited or not

[Mockra]

Awesome! Finally got scum!

So we need to work out when Atrahal might have been recruited and any connections with people. I mentioned Olar Ethil but I think I need to do a reread on that one and see how it looks and see how they interacted day 1.

Wasn't Atrahal in a bitch fight with someone Day 1? Did that stop day 2 or did they continue? Hmmm might need to go look into that as well. He's got so many posts a reread is going to be a bit of work.

Also Silanah, you have hinted at knowing stuff about Tellan, but when you went to vote yesterday it came across as indecisive, is there anything you can tell us on that at all? If you know something we don't, just come straight out with a firm lead and vote Tellan, I think that would be the sort
of sign that we can follow.

[Ruse]

A scum CF?

excellent!!

I never pegged atrahal as scum...he was receiving way to much attention from all over to have been recruited surely?

[Olar Ethil]

Morning, I'm going to be away for a while today so probably won't have much of a chance to post until later on.

Time to start looking for connections to a possible recruiter then and see if there was anyone Atrahal seemed to suddenly ignore or have a change of attitude towards.

I think he got into that scrap early on with Tellan, Mockra.

[Mockra]

Well I was wondering if he had gone after someone Day 1 and they recruited him to shut him up. I'm pretty sure he was involved in that big arguement that got all colourful? I really need to go back and review day 1. Thank god we got ages.

[Mockra]

Just went back and had a quick look your right there OE, it was with Tellan over the Rashan case he made which went all various colours.

[Tennes]

Atrahal's attention surely went away from Tellan. Silanah also thinks Tellan could be cult. I think Tellan could be a good bet. I am having a read through and taking time to adjust my thoughts, get my head together. Right now they are all jumbled up, starting with Ruse and Atrahal yesterday, Atrahal's reveal about who he was ie a poet, Ruse's poetry day one, it all comes full circle, BUT then you got Rashan and Atrahal bouncing off of each other. Rashan doesn't give a shit who gets lynched as long as it isn't him. If we are looking for connections then either Ruse being buddies with Atrahal, voting away from him and defending him when I was attacking Mockra yesterday or Rashan attacking Atrahal all game. Again these are just my initial thoughts without properly reading up. No cases being made yet just observation. I haven't even had a look at who Atrahal may have defended during the game. Right now we know that day one Atrahal was town so like us he didn't have a clue who was cult. Day two did his attitude change? I'll have another read through today with Atrahal the recruit in my head.

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 5.

There are 23 hours and 53 minutes remaining.

15 players are left alive:
Barghast, D'riss, Gamelon, Kalse, Korvalain, Mockra, Okaros, Olar Ethil, Omtose, Rashan, Ruse, Serc, Silanah, Tellan, Tennes


8 votes to lynch, 7 to go to night.

No-one has voted.

Players not voting: Barghast, D'riss, Gamelon, Kalse, Korvalain, Mockra, Okaros, Olar Ethil, Omtose, Rashan, Ruse, Serc, Silanah, Tellan, Tennes

[Ruse]

Tennes, on 22 March 2012 - 08:46 AM, said:

Atrahal's attention surely went away from Tellan. Silanah also thinks Tellan could be cult. I think Tellan could be a good bet. I am having a read through and taking time to adjust my thoughts, get my head together. Right now they are all jumbled up, starting with Ruse and Atrahal yesterday, Atrahal's reveal about who he was ie a poet, Ruse's poetry day one, it all comes full circle

Fully agree on the tellan bit.


but wait...did atrahal actually fake reveal poetry?
lemme check quick.

...DID TOO!, The cheaky fucker, thats a blatant setup right there..come now!!!

Tell me tennes, if i was actually partnered with atrahal or his recruiter or watever.
do you really think he would have gone and called himself a freaking "poet" when i have been getting stick for my day one poetry all game? What would that accomplish?

I bet he fucking did it because i was not attacking him all game he has tried to set me up for the next lynch by his "reveal"
If he actually turned out to be a poet thats another story, i could be seen as signaling or something.

bah!...BAH! i say!!

[Ruse]

thinking about it more....if it was a setup.
he must have bee scared about us finding his real recruiter something fierce.
so im betting that its someone that is was he rather blatantly symped or someone that rather blatantly symped him.

[Rashan]

Mockra, on 22 March 2012 - 07:53 AM, said:

Awesome! Finally got scum!

So we need to work out when Atrahal might have been recruited and any connections with people. I mentioned Olar Ethil but I think I need to do a reread on that one and see how it looks and see how they interacted day 1.

Wasn't Atrahal in a bitch fight with someone Day 1? Did that stop day 2 or did they continue? Hmmm might need to go look into that as well. He's got so many posts a reread is going to be a bit of work.

Also Silanah, you have hinted at knowing stuff about Tellan, but when you went to vote yesterday it came across as indecisive, is there anything you can tell us on that at all? If you know something we don't, just come straight out with a firm lead and vote Tellan, I think that would be the sort
of sign that we can follow.

The bitch fight was with Tellan, actually. That was where Tellan was fake symping me like crazy.

[Rashan]

Ruse, on 22 March 2012 - 08:19 AM, said:

A scum CF?

excellent!!

I never pegged atrahal as scum...he was receiving way to much attention from all over to have been recruited surely?

What can I say? My drunken mind is genius.

[Rashan]

Ruse, on 22 March 2012 - 11:33 AM, said:

Fully agree on the tellan bit.


but wait...did atrahal actually fake reveal poetry?
lemme check quick.

...DID TOO!, The cheaky fucker, thats a blatant setup right there..come now!!!

Tell me tennes, if i was actually partnered with atrahal or his recruiter or watever.
do you really think he would have gone and called himself a freaking "poet" when i have been getting stick for my day one poetry all game? What would that accomplish?

I bet he fucking did it because i was not attacking him all game he has tried to set me up for the next lynch by his "reveal"
If he actually turned out to be a poet thats another story, i could be seen as signaling or something.

bah!...BAH! i say!!

This doesn't make sense... there could be more than one minister with poetry as the cultural specialty. I have no idea what you're saying here.

[Rashan]

Ruse, on 22 March 2012 - 11:35 AM, said:

thinking about it more....if it was a setup.
he must have bee scared about us finding his real recruiter something fierce.
so im betting that its someone that is was he rather blatantly symped or someone that rather blatantly symped him.

I still don't know what you're talking about with the setup thing, but Khell IS known for being a blatant symp at times. Hopefully everyone who can will read back, I don't want to be the only one.



Also, I forgot to keep in mind that Atra wouldn't have been recruited on day 1, so the Tellan fight doesn't really mean anything. I still want to lynch him, but he has an equal chance to be connected to Atrahal as the rest of you.

[Ruse]

Rashan, on 22 March 2012 - 11:42 AM, said:

Ruse, on 22 March 2012 - 11:33 AM, said:

Fully agree on the tellan bit.


but wait...did atrahal actually fake reveal poetry?
lemme check quick.

...DID TOO!, The cheaky fucker, thats a blatant setup right there..come now!!!

Tell me tennes, if i was actually partnered with atrahal or his recruiter or watever.
do you really think he would have gone and called himself a freaking "poet" when i have been getting stick for my day one poetry all game? What would that accomplish?

I bet he fucking did it because i was not attacking him all game he has tried to set me up for the next lynch by his "reveal"
If he actually turned out to be a poet thats another story, i could be seen as signaling or something.

bah!...BAH! i say!!

This doesn't make sense... there could be more than one minister with poetry as the cultural specialty. I have no idea what you're saying here.

are you not reading the quote where Tennes thinks there is a connection between myself and atrahal because he revealed "Poetry"?


...sigh

[Rashan]

Oh. Sorry about that, then your point is good. Early morning

I just don't think anything should be drawn from that at all.

[Tennes]

So this has taken me most of the morning so far, I went back to day one with the thought that day one Atrahal was town so I wanted to highlight his interactions, the next part would be to have a look at shift in behaviour towards anyone or if he fails to mention anyone again etc.

#Atrahals first post he makes a case against Rashan

#75 Korvalian agrees with his case.

#91 Serc agrees Rashan scummy post.

#115 Atrahal mentions calligraphy

#120 He implicates both Tellan and Barghast. More so Barghast for not only defending Rashan but moving thoughts elsewhere (To Note, where has Barghasts Calligraphy gone?).

#123 Ruse spouts poetry to Atrahal but aimed at Silanah.

#125 Atrahal does not like poetry from Ruse

#142 Atrahal looks at Korv's case on Omtose and thinks Omtose is playing the town card

#146 likes case on Kalse by Karosis

#163 Tellan dislikes Atrahal telling Rashan to "fight goddam you"

#169 Tellan quotes Atrahals Posts

#170 then he (Tellan) votes for Atrahal for, "weak cases and content faking. Combined with a defensive post.

#177 Atrahal accuses tellan of protecting Rashan

#180 Tellan says because he disagrees with Atrahal he must be scum (sarcasm)

#181 Atrahal says Tellan's case is lame

#215 Tellan quotes Atrahal case on Rashan and thinks "it's bollocks", very long post.

#217 Rashan tells tellan that he has already rebutted that case and thanks Tellan to which Tellan WAS aware of but wanted to comment anyway

#225 It gets a bit silly now, Atrahal responds to Tellan's very long post

#229 tellan responds back

#240 back again

#244 back again

#265 Olar points out connection between Atrahal and Karosis

#272 Atrahal "rainbow" post

#276 Rashan lists his suspects. Rashan, Omtose, Kalse and D'riss. (Incidentally the only one out of these he did not go after since was Kalse)

#320 Kalse says there is no cause to think Atrahal is scummy and then builds case on Karosis.



This is where we are getting to the end of the day and we needed a lynch so the discussion was mainly on karosis from here on out.



Without looking further into day 2, 3 and 4 etc I would say from these findings that:

Kalse may have recruited Atrahal night one.

Ruse' exchanges and reaction since day one are suspicious.

Now I have to look further into the rest of the days because Tellan and Atrahal hardly spat anymore and I want to see if I can find anything between Barghast and Atrahal because Barghast has changed from his calligraphy. I won't have much more time this has taken me inbetween work roughly 2 1/2 hours to do.

[Tellan]

People seem to be ignoring that when I was here I still mentioned Atrahal as scummy long past day one. Sure, it wasn't as heated or frequent, but that's probably because I wasn't as active. I also voted him as things were swinging Omtose. If I'd voted Omtose, then it would've been 6 votes Omtose, 2 Atrahal at that moment (6-3 after Mockras vote, though part of his justification involved it being a feasible lynch).

@Barg, I explained why I voted serc at the time. He seemed like he was coasting a lot. Why him instead of another coaster? He seemed to actually be posting a bit while stuff was going on, and just edging around it.