[Kalse]

I'm back and have to say - Korv - you are brave, I'll give you that , but it might be a moot point anyway as we are nowhere near reaching a consensus?

[Anthras]

Read up. Ampelas is seriously setting of my scumdar. And I feel a little better that I'm not alone in voicing concerns.

Now as to ending the day without a lynch, or speed lynching the first person who coughed. Do any of you stat whores know how often we actually hit a scum with a random day one lynch?

[Kalse]

Errr, once?

[Telas]

Alkend's comment on the Thyr/Amp thing had me do a reread of that too.

I got a joking vibe from it, but that said Amp looked scummier of the two. Having casted votes against Thyr twice
(one for failing to show up, which was a cross post with Thyr arriving. The other jokingly) while Thyr didn't vote at all.
I'm not sure why Alkend chose Thyr of the two, maybe he sees something we don't.

Though Alkend dropped his vote and then just disappeared too. Seemed a little strange as some of us were around.

[Korvalain]

Kalse, on 09 October 2009 - 09:42 PM, said:

I'm back and have to say - Korv - you are brave, I'll give you that , but it might be a moot point anyway as we are nowhere near reaching a consensus?

You can always string me up if you think it is a bad tactic for town, it is one way to prevent people fighting all over thread later on, and I guess I already ruffled a lot of feathers

Howwever, I think I have the statistics on my side when I say that high tmdi speedlynches on day 1 are generally a bad idea.

[Korvalain]

anyway, I'm out for the night. ciao ciao mesdames et messieurs.

[Korlat]

in all the games i've played here (since Mafia 13), we got a Day 1 scum lynch twice or thrice.

but, info is important.

[Anthras]

Yea I didn't remember it being more than once or twice. But I was \away for a while.

And I thought this was a M&P's level 2 or 3

[Korlat]

it ain't
apparently, we're talking 8/9 here

[Alkend]

Telas, on 09 October 2009 - 09:47 PM, said:

Alkend's comment on the Thyr/Amp thing had me do a reread of that too.

I got a joking vibe from it, but that said Amp looked scummier of the two. Having casted votes against Thyr twice
(one for failing to show up, which was a cross post with Thyr arriving. The other jokingly) while Thyr didn't vote at all.
I'm not sure why Alkend chose Thyr of the two, maybe he sees something we don't.

Though Alkend dropped his vote and then just disappeared too. Seemed a little strange as some of us were around.

I have meetings today, but I'm here, T-Unit. Hardly seems to matter because all that people are talking about is ST chronology and terminology and then a bunch of stupid things (super descriptive, right? I was so annoyed I couldn't stand to read all of it.).

ANYWAY, it's possible to say that Ampelas was symping Thyr with those two big signal votes. Look at the number of people sitting at 1 vote today. How hard would it be for a scumbody to signal his or her master with a fake vote?

To whoever asked about "Day 1 scum lynches" it did happen really recently, in a game without CFs. And then in Spycraft, lots of people THOUGHT the first guy lynched might be scum due to his crazy CF, but it turned out he wasn't. I AM wary of anyone who uses this kind of logic to try and deter a lynch, however.

[Alkend]

Anyway, you do bring up a good point about Amp/Thyr. If Amp is the scummier looking, vote him first. The logic goes lynch the master not the symp, but that has led to a lot of fake symping over time in various games.

Remove Vote
Vote Ampelas

I like Thyr's avatar better anyway.

[Anthras]

Quote

I AM wary of anyone who uses this kind of logic to try and deter a lynch, however

Why.


It seam pretty obvious we fail at it big time and all we end up doing is hurt the town.

[Korlat]

ok, re-reading the amp-Thyr thing, I'm not sure about thyr, but amp is definitely pinging on the "scum trying to make nice with everyone" radar.

also, inthe same vein, this:

Kalse, on 09 October 2009 - 07:25 AM, said:

Ampelas, on 08 October 2009 - 11:16 PM, said:

Also, I spy a Thyrllan...

(My emphasis) How could you have all missed this! Amp admits he's a spy. ...wait...wrong game, it's Klingon bombers we are looking for...hmmm, and they don't even have their brow ridges in this time period. There is no one else around to discuss this with though, which is probably a good thing.

I need to go back to my cabin to do some research. (Read I have to go to work and will be back later. Should be back before day times out even without the timer freeze/extension.)

this post seems odd.
If Amp is scum, 10 to 1 chances that Kalse is a symp

[Telas]

15 players still alive.

Votes so far:

1 vote Ampelas (Alkend)
1 vote Korvalain ( Tulas Shorn)
1 vote Kaschan (Korvalain)
1 vote Tennes (Tellan)
1 vote Tellan (Karosis)
1 vote Korbas (Korlat)

9 players still to vote.

Ampelas, Anthras, Atrahal, Kalse,, Korbas, Thyrllan, Tennes, Telas, Kaschan


This should be the current vote count

[Korlat]

ok, well I think we all know who Korbas is by now, and he ain't showing up for another 5 hours or so.

therfore

remove vote
vote Ampelas

I don't like people who are too nice.

[Korlat]

oh, and PS never answered how much time's left, the bugger.

[Telas]

ok well I'm off to get some food.

PS said it should time out around 4-5 am GMT, so about another 5 hours I believe.

[Kaschan]

Guys I just read up but now have to go.. maybe up to 30 hrs.... I got called in to a weekend job Anyway I am usually a believer in a lynch first day...but in this case there really hasn't been much to go on. I am not gonna throw a vote before I go. Amp/Thyr doesn't really strike me as scum interaction and I am kinda glad amp started up the serious talk...someone has to. Anyway, I am gonna leave it how it is. I might be able to get in 20 min or so in like 4-6 hrs... but i am not holding my breath. Sorry mods... my weekends are Shit.

[Alkend]

Anthras, on 09 October 2009 - 10:11 PM, said:

Quote

I AM wary of anyone who uses this kind of logic to try and deter a lynch, however

Why.


It seam pretty obvious we fail at it big time and all we end up doing is hurt the town.

I'm sorry, did you have a better way at winning this game other than lynching? Do you have some particular reason to not lynch Ampelas or Thyrllan or anybody-but-yourself? You like waiting around to see what happens at night?

[Bent]

15 players still alive.
4 hours 58 minutes remaining
Votes so far:

2 votes Ampelas (Alkend, Korlat)
1 vote Korvalain ( Tulas Shorn)
1 vote Kaschan (Korvalain)
1 vote Tennes (Tellan)
1 vote Tellan (Karosis)


9 players still to vote.

Ampelas, Anthras, Atrahal, Kalse,, Korbas, Thyrllan, Tennes, Telas, Kaschan

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 09 October 2009 - 11:53 PM