[Hood's Path]

gl couldnt be partnered to emur, they diverted to him after the amp case. so those two are like bound to be joined at the hip, which is funny as i wanted to give amp the power night one but figured driss and tyr both couldnt be scum so gave it to thyr instead. and to those that said i am having a bad game, f*** y**



sorry couldnt help myself.

[Kaschan]

I removed vote because I took it to l-2 with 6 hours left. I should have re-voted when I realized I wouldn't be back for the timer. That is my fault.

[Thyrllan]

Just 3 killers who choose 1 target each night.

A normal game would have 2 killers and 1 symp at 12 people, right?

So, 3 killers is a little stronger since they would know each other, and might be used to combat the 'trainer' role.

At least that is what I am thinking.

[Kaschan]

Then why isn't HP dead. They would have known his reveal was legitimate.

[Hood's Path]

Kaschan, on Jul 30 2009, 09:06 PM, said:

It's getting down to the wire now, so I must ask this question, just for others opinions, as I am far too bemused right now without any semblance of help.

The concensus is 3 scum. We have had 1 kill both nights. If there is only 1 killer, what are the other possible roles? HP claims there are no symps.

So. Any ideas?

yeah but remember ps told thyr he got catapults so any info i gleamed isnt golden on that front. i get the distinct feeling the mods where playing silly buggers with me. they did imply it though and pointed me toward the scene at the start. it does also make sense as we arent in a room, we are controlling armies so to speak. i think the three scum are all just killers working together and splitting the kill.

[Emurlahn]

@kaschan Well a finder would be pointless for them a healer would be a bit ridiculous as it would mean that the killer would be healed every night and vigs would lose effectivenss and be more likely to harm scum with less benefit than normal so Im going to say its very likely we have a scum guard around, possibly a vig but thats less likely

[Thyrllan]

You answered your own question right there.

When you play as a killer, do you kill people who are unkowns, or people who will cause drama and division as the game goes along?

I have no way of proving I am inno, beyond HP. HP has no way of proving it beyond me. We run into a situation like this, where they can use WIFOM (well you would be dead if you are inno) to get that final lynch their way.

[Kaschan]

Are you seriously trying to say that they wouldn't knowingly kill a person who had reveal teaching technique because others are better targets? That's ludicrous. If he had said, "finder", he'd be dead. Plain and simple.

[Hood's Path]

Kaschan, on Jul 30 2009, 09:09 PM, said:

Then why isn't HP dead. They would have known his reveal was legitimate.

if driss is a killer then judging by the night one stuff they wanted to hold me over for a lynch. more so if driss isnt a killer as they would have expected then two innos to lead the charge against me day 2 and knew the ability i had was hampered by time limit and a narrow group to work in. thankfully my reveal with thyr was so ridiculously argumentative that it stayed most hands (apart from driss).

[Hood's Path]

the tell will be what happens when amp, driss and ruse come on.

[Kaschan]

That makes some semblance of sense, but my point remains. Why not kill the revealed power role, if not night 1, then night 2 after it was realized that he could be used as both a sort of finder & teacher, and you knew a lynch was less likely. Something is not adding up.

[Thyrllan]

Because he gave me a healing role. Who do you think I healed with it?

The only Inno role I knew was out there.

[Kaschan]

Yet, someone else STILL DIED.

[Galayn Lord]

Read up. I'm totally with Kaschan on this. This is a crucial lynch we have to be right. I am inclined to believe HP & Thyr, BUT if they are lying they could have fingered an inno, and if there are three scum (which seems to be the consensus) we are stuffed.

Given my proclivity for making wrong choices I feel almost paralysed.


Edit: Cross post

This post has been edited by Galayn Lord: 30 July 2009 - 08:25 PM

[Thyrllan]

Are you stupid?

Seriously?

Imagine you are a killer imagining yourself into my shoes.

I know HP is innocent, I have no information besides gut instinct on other people, and I have a one-shot heal. What am I going to do?

HUR DUR DURRRRR.

@Kaschan.

This post has been edited by Thyrllan: 30 July 2009 - 08:27 PM

[Kaschan]

Yes, I am stupid. And, I was just thinking that thought. But, Night One remains, when you didn't have a heal

Edit: Also, don't call me stupid. That's just being mean for no reason. I'm asking questions I find pertinent. If you don't like the "intelligence" of them, ignore them, please.

This post has been edited by Kaschan: 30 July 2009 - 08:27 PM

[Hood's Path]

well they knew i couldnt give thyr the power again so after last night he was no longer a healer. also kara was gunning for emur before anyone else yesterday and they had almost guessed right in killing him as i was very close to picking him because he voted emur and i felt he was han. i thought thyr would die and karat would reveal saving me again tonight while i tried again.

[Thyrllan]

Kaschan, on Jul 30 2009, 03:26 PM, said:

Yes, I am stupid. And, I was just thinking that thought. But, Night One remains, when you didn't have a heal

Edit: Also, don't call me stupid. That's just being mean for no reason. I'm asking questions I find pertinent. If you don't like the "intelligence" of them, ignore them, please.

I have no idea why he wasn't killed night one. Maybe because they thought he was a good lynch candidate and didn't want to knock him off? Maybe he is a killer that has to give power to his enemies in order for his lover/killer to be able to kill? I don't flippen know what is going through the killers minds, I can but guess.

I didn't call you stupid. I asked if you were.

[Hood's Path]

Kaschan, on Jul 30 2009, 09:26 PM, said:

Yes, I am stupid. And, I was just thinking that thought. But, Night One remains, when you didn't have a heal

Edit: Also, don't call me stupid. That's just being mean for no reason. I'm asking questions I find pertinent. If you don't like the "intelligence" of them, ignore them, please.

i did say yesterday after the reveal of thyr and the confusion that they probably believed my reveal was fake. i said there was no symp and my role is useless to them. they may have felt i was a symp trying to save himself.

@gl - i am 90% your an inno by emur and the others going for you yesterday so if you want to wait thats grand. i want to hear from ruse, driss and ampelas to see which way they jump and we shouldnt lynch until everyone has spoken.

[Ruse]

Hi everyone, here for about 20-30 minutes.

This is all nonsense. HP, is Thyr the killer?

I am a guard and I guarded you last night because while I felt good about my case on GL yesterday, I do NOT TRUST you at all. Why are you still alive if you are town?