[Hood's Path]

i can post my pms, they could be fake.

[Kaschan]

Fair enough.

My hesitation is because it is do or die now, basically. It has nothing to do with not wanting to vote Emur, I did yesterday, but didn't want to lynch too early. Now? 8 players, 3 probably scum. We lynch wrong, 4-3. Scum kills, 3-3. Scum wins.

[Kaschan]

I guess it all boils down to whether or not I trust you, HP. I am... concerned.

[Thyrllan]

Indeed it does.

It basicly means the killers are, WCS,

HP, ME, and someone else
or
Emur, someone, and someone.

So - I guess it is up to the 5 people who are not evils to choose correctly.

Just as a point to make, notice Emur wasn't around until I called him out, then he posted within 20 minutes saying he didn't have a power...

[Hood's Path]

we aint lynching wrong.

we now need to look back over everything and decide who his partners are. obviously driss is prime suspect for me because of day 1. i need to look back over that and see who else went back on it. there is also the train from yesterday to consider and one of them might be a better bet than driss tomorrow.

[Hood's Path]

six reading 3 posting, whats that all about.

[Kaschan]

Easy for you to say we aren't lynching wrong. You wanted to lynch Thyrllan at first as well. There are far too many possibilities to rush. What if Emurlahn was guarded?

[Emurlahn]

i was only on then because i happened to want to check the thread on my phone on the way home. Now with HP saying he targetted me, i didnt get an ability, so as i know im innocent either HP is scum trying to lead the game or someone guarded him. Im not too sure which yet but if he is then thyrllan is and i dont think theyd manage ot plan a charade like yesterday so im going to have to assume he was guarded, either by scum or some confused inno

[Emurlahn]

guarding me wouldnt have done anything if he gave me an ability, (healing is an iffy subject but im going to assume not) guarding HP would have blocked the ability though

[Kaschan]

You think scum has an evil guard, or an inno would guard the person supposedly giving out powers to inno?

[Thyrllan]

In an effort to spark some conversation, here are my thoughts on the 8 still alive

Path-Shaper said:

8 players still alive: Ampelas, D'riss, Emurlahn, Galayn Lord, Hood's Path, Kaschan, Ruse, Thyrllan

Ampelas - I have no idea.
D'riss - Probably inno... just because I say so! Just the vibes I get from him.
Emurlahn - playing middle of the road all game - lots of 'stuff' popped up on day 1 when he got 3 votes on him.
Galayn Lord - not too good a read on him right now.
Hoods Path - CI afaik. Unless someone else chose to send me catapults and didn't speak up in the thread, which would be a terrible play. I can't say HP's game has been good, but...
Kaschan - Not to sure. Could be connected to people, but eh.
Ruse - Any kind of power role wouldn't be playing like this. The only reason I can see him still being alive is that the evils hope he dosen't vote, which he really hasn't been. No lynches are like free NK's for the killers.
Thyrllan - Thats me! I know I'm inno.

So, I would order like this:

CI - HP, Thyrllan.
PI - D'riss, Ruse
Unkown - Ampelas, Galayn Lord, Kaschan
PE - Emurlahn. Which is why I poked Him. He then posted saying he had no role, and HP said he attempted to give a role to Emur last night.

Now, you can say 'But Thyrllan, you and HP could be partnered and have cooked this all up together.' My response to that would be 'Would we cook up such a terrible reveal, and then horrible reveal confirmation, in a game that we were told was TMDI 1-2?'. The answer is No.

If we didn't have a modkill, we could do some testing right about now.

[Thyrllan]

^ was crosspost with everything from my previous post.

[Emurlahn]

no im more inclined to beleive a scum guard, i doubt an inno would have guarded HP even if they thought he was scum as if he was telling the truth they would be hurting their team. A scum guard on the other hand would definitely want to stop him teaching any more people id reckon or to make him think that whoever he taught was scum
EDIT @ Kaschan

This post has been edited by Emurlahn: 30 July 2009 - 08:00 PM

[Kaschan]

I am town, Thyrllan. That I promise you.

Scum guard... is a fucking legit possibility, and I don't like admitting that. But why wouldn't they have blocked night 1 after the reveal? Hmmmm.

[Hood's Path]

i find it unlikely that they wouldnt have guarded me night one if they had that ability and as thyr recieved a power then it seems unlikely they switched to me last night if one does exist. sorry emur, your scum. if people dont believe me then fine, i tried to get us back on track, i had you pegged on day 1 and got lampooned for my trouble. you somehow avoided another lynch yesterday and as pointed out when i voted for you yesterday, finding out if you were inno or guilty was the lynch pin (pardon the pun) of the game so you were my best option.

i doubt gl is your partner as i cant see people switching. your vote for driss yesterday has me doubting that now that i go back and check, but i suppose it could be distancing. so my bet is ampelas and ruse/driss.

[Kaschan]

HP draws the same conclusion I did on scum guard. The actions would speak louder, if HP is indeed town. Gut says he is, mafia paranoia says I must be suspicious.

[Hood's Path]

yesterdays voting

the current voting is

4 Votes Emurlahn (Karatallid, thyr, hp, gl)
3 Vote Galayn Lord (Ruse, emur, ampelas)

kaschan you didnt vote.

[Hood's Path]

my mistake you removed.

i think its those three voting gl to be honest.

[Emurlahn]

I dont know why they wouldnt have done it night one, but i know im innocent and if you are then that means you were guarded.

[Kaschan]

It's getting down to the wire now, so I must ask this question, just for others opinions, as I am far too bemused right now without any semblance of help.

The concensus is 3 scum. We have had 1 kill both nights. If there is only 1 killer, what are the other possible roles? HP claims there are no symps.

So. Any ideas?

Edit: Removed bold, underlined.

This post has been edited by Kaschan: 30 July 2009 - 08:08 PM