[Gavin]

I thought it was Fener (Slick Mongoose) who was Finder but had played super aggresive and was under suspicion all game. He was close to be lynched (L-2) and Fener revealed Finder with partner and that he had a guilty find.

The reveal was a little unbelievable and PB fake revealed Finder and claimed he found Fener inno the night before.

[Path-Shaper]

From Big Shin:

Quote

This is where I am right now:

Provisional: Kill Korvalain.
If Korvalain is lynched, kill Fener.

Why Fener? I don't have a real read on who might be roled at this point (other than Korv). I view Telas as dangerous, and he could be next after Fener. Fener, because he still fits the lower post profile, but being pushy enough to not get noticed perhaps. Furthermore, he's risen to my defense over Sil's case. At this point, I don't need someone around who appears to be helping me. I can't assume he will continue to do so.

Emur is on the kill list too. Sil is possible since it would seem so obvious if I was killer, do 'theres no way I would do it'. (playing that card). Problem is, by that point I think players would be ready to go after something obvious out of frustration so I may have to discard that thought. Besides, keeping the person who made the case originally around to harp like a seagull at me could continue to help rather than hurt my credibility.

Quote

Quote

Quote

If I don't get put up for lynch by a finder/guard on day 3, I have a 'case' on Lio that I'm planning to present. If I don't make it, I"ll share it on SH just for fun. It'll be direct proof as to how closely I've paid attention to this game - being killer turns mafia into religion.

HD - Mafia is srz bizniz.

I always thought that being a killer is a very informative process. You know that the others are innocent, yet you see what kind of scummy thing they end up doing.

When you're inno there's always a part of you that hopes that whoever you're making a case on is really a killer.

JA

Ha! Paranoia kicking in, but this PM makes me think of a "your learning time is over" foreshadowing.

It's true what you say though. I've taken Tapper's post in SH of the last game to heart. Inno's need to push and make cases, but they also have to play as cleanly as possible. Also, they can't be so attached to their case that they put blinders on.* Otherwise, innos just become part of the problem.

*If Sil wasn't actually right, I would accuse her of this.

[Gem Windcaster]

Gavin, I completely agree with what you wrote about playing. I have too, found that disagreeing with a case make people scream 'scum!' - nowadays I usually try to focus on another case instead and don't go into too much discussion about the cases I think suck. Though using a case on someone else as a case on the person making that case is tricky - because of the symp factor. But I guess it all depends on how you do it.

Lately though I think there have been much screaming going on - was it always that much screaming? I can't remember, but sometimes I think people should just calm down. RP is okay, mindless screaming at each other not so much.

I also agree that we have a good community here - what happens in the games stay in the games - except the lists, but we love those. I also agree that constructive criticism in the spoilers help me become a better player. Yay for malazan mafia!

[Path-Shaper]

Big Shin said:

Quote

Im here. damn that reveal is mighty, uh, revealing... on 1 vote? madness tho I suppose if its true it could work for Korv as a sort of WIFOM bit, eveyone expects BB to kill him tonite if hes really the guard so the BB will be sure to NOT kill him to keep us suspicious!

Korv, then Telas methinks...

Good call on getting rid of the guard despite the lure of leaving him around to raise suspicions. It's always better not to play with fire.

[drinksinbars]

Gavin, on May 15 2009, 12:43 PM, said:

I thought it was Fener (Slick Mongoose) who was Finder but had played super aggresive and was under suspicion all game. He was close to be lynched (L-2) and Fener revealed Finder with partner and that he had a guilty find.

The reveal was a little unbelievable and PB fake revealed Finder and claimed he found Fener inno the night before.

which just made the rest of the innos convinced one was the symp. never fake reveal if you are ri, its just not good for your team.

[Path-Shaper]

Titled "life is interesting"

Gamelon said:

That is all.

[Sir Thursday]

drinksinbars, on May 15 2009, 01:18 PM, said:

Gavin, on May 15 2009, 12:43 PM, said:

I thought it was Fener (Slick Mongoose) who was Finder but had played super aggresive and was under suspicion all game. He was close to be lynched (L-2) and Fener revealed Finder with partner and that he had a guilty find.

The reveal was a little unbelievable and PB fake revealed Finder and claimed he found Fener inno the night before.

which just made the rest of the innos convinced one was the symp. never fake reveal if you are ri, its just not good for your team.

Seemed like a good play to me - he threw himself in front of his finder, who otherwise was going to be lynched...though I guess it would have been better if the finder hadn't been paired...

Sir Thursday

[Path-Shaper]

The loony vigs are spelling bad news for my precious Uncle Ben:

Meanas said:

Fener said:

Quote

Quote

Couldn't help it! Sorry if I screwed up any plans you had, lol.

Plans? Plans are a detriment! I make this shit up as I go along, its the most fun way!

You might get NKed, you won't get lynched.

How do you feel about Ruse?

You want to vig him? I'm down.

With my luck, hes probably an inno, BUT NOONE ARGUES WITH OBDI AND GETS AWAY WITH IT!

You bastards, don't vig him yet

[Path-Shaper]

Some action from our roled players

Finder:

Telas said:

People are going for Emur, and quite possibly go for Ruse tommorow.

Want to find on people I trust less.

It's between Meanas, Gamelon, and Liosan atm.

Will go for a provisional on Meanas please.

Big Shin:

Quote

Motherfucker. Emurlahn.

Provisional, Kill Meanas. (hunch)

(subject to final confirmation please, in case this PM is after hammer)

[Path-Shaper]

Confirmations:

Finder-

Telas said:

Confirm action on Meanas.

Vigs:

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

So make your choice sir, to vig or not to vig.

Nah, if Korv is the gaurd, hes he obvious target for the killers, and if he comes on and gaurds ruse, and the kill goes through, Ill know then I was wrong.

Lets save it

Ok,

Path-Shaper no action

I doubt Korv is coming back, but meh.

Confirmed

Killer:

Quote

I think Meanas is guard, or roled at the very least. I'm not going to kill him. I'm going to move him to the top of the list of people to move into after I die.

Confirm, Kill Korvalain.

I don't think it's going through though...

If it does, here's hoping Fener's case takes off!

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 15 May 2009 - 01:23 PM

[Path-Shaper]

Good game D'rek, I'm still not sure based on what case you were lynched

[Path-Shaper]

Missing action from UB:

Quote

Hmm well for a NA...silence is an interesting NA. It more or less gives whoever's silenced a free pass the next day, but people will be suspicious that someone silenced would be silenced to vindicate/absolve them. Which means I could potentially frame someone, but to do that it'd be best to frame someone who might be symping them. URgh

Well Emur's Inno CF kinda fucks me over. And since Korv might be guarding me, if they see that no one was silenced I might be in trouble. Silencing myself opens up the WIFOM, but that's a risk I'd rather avoid.


Hmmmm

Probably better if I stay on the offensive. My victim is more or less removed from the game for that day, unable to make cases, etc. I think I'm going to start the day by trying to push back at Fener (utilizing Gamelon's incorrect case, painting him as Meanas' symp or something) so I'd be better off cutting off Korv's reveal defense.

But what if Gamelon kills him? I could target Tennes, who doesn't contribute much anyway, but that could also be Gamelon's target.

Shitt.

Fuck it. I'm probably going to regret this, but
Silence Telas
just because I can't decide otherwise.

Well, all have confirmed but one, so I activate Korvalain's guard provisional on Meanas.

At this point I'm not even sure he's coming back anyways, he did sound pissed.

[drinksinbars]

good move by shin, as meanas will be partnered and cleared by investigation

[Path-Shaper]

OK, started day.

Now I'm off for a few hours.

JA

[bwgan]

I will step into P-S then...*thinks to to self* PLEEEEASE don't let them speedlynch anyone.

[Path-Shaper]

OMG - there are 7 messages in there already! :Surprise: ...bear with me, this may take a few mins!



Edit: - bwgan

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 15 May 2009 - 02:03 PM

[Path-Shaper]

This one entitled Mor45 from Meanigore (living up to his name!)

Quote

And again he has shitty play.

God in my dresden game I am making him a red court vampire that dies if he speaks during the day, making the dya 36 hours long and modkills 24 hours.

RAWRHGHWQFHWGHWGHWDLHSLDKHG.

Reply from Fenerent

Quote

Quote

And again he has shitty play.

God in my dresden game I am making him a red court vampire that dies if he speaks during the day, making the dya 36 hours long and modkills 24 hours.

RAWRHGHWQFHWGHWGHWDLHSLDKHG.

He is a Christian?

If not, thats piss poor, in my book, very piss poor. Also, whoever D'riss is, your going to hell. Thats all. lol

Big Shin - having a good time

Quote

Meanas...

If he's roled, as I think he is, I hope that if I'm lynched, someone else fingers me first so he can piggy back on the case rather than have to reveal. In which case, he's the perfect spot for my soul.

GENIUS!

or

RIDICULE!

Either way, I'm having fun!

And more from Big Shin

Quote

Odds are now 6 on 3, counting the switch.

I'm not too unhappy about that, even if I die after the weekend freeze. 7 people left out of 13 original innos. There have to be some roled dead in there somewhere, unless I totally suck.

I wasn't blocked, which means I was probably found. I have to believe the odds on 1 of the 2 were pretty good.

Again, here's hoping Fener does my work for me...

Uncle Ruxty

Quote

Showing up right after night ends would be mighty suspicious (even though it's about when I log on daily but meh -.-) so I think I'll have to lurk and log on after school when I get home or something.

More to come

- bwgan

[Path-Shaper]

Entitled 50 bucks - convo between Meanigore and Fenerent

Quote

Quote

Quote

Quote

says Ruse is silenced.

or pretending to be silenced...

That too. Gotta go, must...leave....game......

Uh, I lose.

Quote

Big Shin

Duh.

I was so happy about the NK going through, I failed to notice it wasn't PB.

Telas is PB?

Ninjaficate list is now in this order:

Meanas (subject to whether I'm on my way out or not)*
Telas
Tennes
Sil
Fener
D'riss
Liosan


*debate being, is it better to shield myself from said power by killing it and continuing on myself, or save it to take it over and gain it for team scum. Has to be played by ear I guess. Don't hurt me PS, but when it comes down to making that soul shift choice, you may not get a confirmation as immediately as my others since I'll be drawing flowcharts, consulting oracles and making blood sacrifices.

Will update first page in a mo.

Ruxty is confused

Quote

WTF did I silence Telas?

doh.gif doh.gif

Fucking confused people! FUck!!!

[Path-Shaper]

Ruxty - titled M45

Quote

I just realized that obdi managed to push a case on morgoth45 and get him lynched even while silenced. clap.gif

Phew...stop pming people...I can't cope with the stress!


- bwgan

[Path-Shaper]

@ JA, there was already a read message in the in box re night 2. I haven't deleted it as I assume you are keeping it for a reason?

- bwgan

Must NOT forget to update 1st page.