Gothos, on 22 April 2011 - 06:10 AM, said:
I am a bit... worried about some of the stuff. No more birthsigns, less skills, less attributes - they're toying with what TES is, I guess. Let's hope they do manage to avoid making character development shallow with that perk tree.
I'm not concerned about Mysticism going - that was redundant, and useless once Mark and Recall etc were removed...as Todd put it, "It was kind of like the 'Magic school of magic', which is silly in retrospect". Acrobatics, I think, is going, which I found to be strange as it was a rather interesting skill to take for assassins - what with all the talk of better animations, surely they could have done something with this to include 'dodging' or more variety for stealth character's movements. Athletics is out, which kind of makes sense....
except they just added sprinting, which I would have thought would make that skill useful. But I guess I saw that one coming when fatigue was no longer impacted by movement, and barely impacted by combat/didn't have an effect on combat in return. I can live without those two, though. Especially as they do appear to be adding in other things to do than combat/quests - crafting, jobs, etc. Even so, this is the stupid streamlining (which I personally think of as dumbing down) that they took up from Daggerfall, in a minor way in Morrowind, and a major way in Oblivion. I get it, it makes sense, but seriously...don't cut skills if there's an obvious way to make them useful. Especially not when you are adding in things already WHICH HAVE A LOGICAL CONNECTION TO THOSE SKILLS.
Birthsigns, I'm kinda annoyed about. I get the free-form, less restricted decision aspect for Skyrim, but a birthsign was a great way to identify your character and get them started down a path. Sure, I only used one or two of the things, EVER, depending on what type of character I was going for, but I know other people like different ones, and experimenting with them was cool. Again, make them more interesting before you scrap them. I assume Bethsoft did this, but...
And attributes. Holy fucking hell, what has Bethesda done? I'm sorry, this post is becoming incredibly negative before the game has even released (again, don't get me wrong, I AM SUPER FREAKING EXCITE@!!!! for this game), but god dammit I can't help myself when I see things going down a dark path...
Anyway, why on earth are they removing a CORNERSTONE OF WHAT MAKES IT A ROLE PLAYING GAME. I'm all for stat-free RPG'ing (if such a thing can be effectively modeled, which so far it cannot), but attributes were IMPORTANT. They defined your character's progress. PROGRESS. You know, as in, PROGRESSION. That thing you need in a game? Skills are obviously taking the forefront, but dammit if they aren't belittling the statistics in favour of perks and shiny. I would LOVE to say they're doing it because the 'story' or the 'adventures' are more important to your role playing experience, and this is the only thing that's holding me back from seriously letting rip on the subject, but I'm just seeing another damn Oblivion game, as TES slides closer and closer to 'action' instead of 'RPG'. IF they can pull off the story, the interactions, the combat, the effects, interesting quests, complicated plots, unique areas/dungeons, less generic armour and loot, and bring you closer to your character and the world through those things (like very few games can), I will be happy. But until they do, taking away the stats, attributes, and other character-defining features is NOT a good move. It's a nice IDEA but unless they can get the implementation 100% right it just doesn't work in a game you're calling an RPG. Not even a self-proclaimed 'action-RPG' that has a history of dumbing itself down each iteration. I seriously hope Bethesda realise that they hit the sweet spot for story/guilds/unique back in Morrowind, and have accordingly fixed up the other things which drove people away from the game, and we're left with a true god-tier experience, but at this point I'm not sure I can hold to that faith.
Ugh. Preemptive ranting. Fuck my life.
On a more positive note....
SKYRIM!!!!!!!!!!!!!