[Thyrllan]

Anything revealing your role is not allowed. The amount of times they posted "Don't reveal" should indicate that nothing relating to your role can be posted.

I was talking about separate posts. Like, in one, they say "I investigated X", and then in the next post they say "I'm a finder". I didn't make that very clear, sorry. Either way, I don't think we can rely on finds in this game.

And, just btw: "I think X is a finder, he investigated X" is not...very speculative.

[Kaschan]

Thyrllan, on Dec 17 2008, 02:02 AM, said:

Anything revealing your role is not allowed. The amount of times they posted "Don't reveal" should indicate that nothing relating to your role can be posted.

I was talking about separate posts. Like, in one, they say "I investigated X", and then in the next post they say "I'm a finder". I didn't make that very clear, sorry. Either way, I don't think we can rely on finds in this game.

And, just btw: "I think X is a finder, he investigated X" is not...very speculative.

It's all about wording

[Korlat]

er if you say you investigated someone, thats a role reveal what else could you mean?

This post has been edited by Korlat: 17 December 2008 - 09:18 AM

[Thyrllan]

Eh. I keep screwing up what I mean.

OK. Template: (lol)

Post One
I think X is a killer.

Post Two.
I'm a finder.

^^

As I said, I can't see finders working in this game. Unless they can post pics or something, or there is some special mechanic. Otherwise there is no way for them to tell us their find results without role-revealing, unless they have a symp. Speculation on others roles is allowed. Argh. It's pointless discussing. I'm not believing any finds this game anyway.

[Thyrllan]

Anyway, that's me out.

Night guys.

[Emurlahn]

Thyrllan, on Dec 17 2008, 09:01 AM, said:

Oh please. What, you would have preferred three dead inno's on day one? Really?

I would have preferred it if we actually played the game, instead of going on and on about voting off someone who isnt even playing.
Christ... its like we are in the sign up thread over here.

[Emurlahn]

Korlat, on Dec 17 2008, 09:42 AM, said:

you all missed one of the biggest points, i didnt want to bring it up because i thought it was obvious. We have no coroner finder, but we also have no role revealing which means no finder reveals, not even fake ones. We have no way of knowing until the game ends any players alignment. The only thing we can discuss is winning conditions.

What are trains going to tell us exactly? We do not know if those lynched are good or evil, who was on the train just shows who has a need to lynch, nothing else.

unless a finder reveals a killer but sacrifices himself for a mod killing in return
I cant see how we could possibly win this game if we will never know anyones alignment.
It all seems rather pointless to me.

[Korlat]

i see bubba posted in heaven, hopefully night will end soon.

[Path-Shaper]

HEy, Bent here. Catching up.

[Path-Shaper]

Ok, I am headed to work, it may take about an hour or so to get there and get out so I can post the scene. Sorry, but please be patient, looks like I am alone in this, no idea what happened to JA, and Bubba posted in SH but then left, so, be patient please.

[Korlat]

hmm someone is still posting in heaven as path shaper...

[Kessobahn]

*sigh*

[Fener]

Catching up after a bit of an absence. To be honest I'm quite happy about a no lynch. We have lost 2 players already in Day 1, I can't see any particular infomation out there as to what a train on a third player would have told us. With no CF a train isn't going to tell us much.
Probably should have voted Night instead of JA really.

I think after Night comes and ends we should have a clearer picture of where we stand. The number if any of people killed which can cause us to either panic or conclude Day killers or something else. Also if there is a cult or anything and they recruit, voting might actually be something useful if someone defends someone else. And of course lastly we can look for posting style changes or whatever else is going on for people re-entering the game.


Just my thoughts anyway.

[Path-Shaper]

It is day 2

Shadow is alive
Thyrllan is dead
Gamelon is dead
Emurlahn is dead
Kaschan is dead
Silanah is dead
Fener is dead
Kessobahn is dead

36 hours remaining
8 people alive
5 to lynch 4 to go to night

Not voted : everyone else

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 17 December 2008 - 01:03 PM

[Korlat]

err, who the fuck is still alive?

[Korlat]

dead -Gamelon 36
Korlat 35
dead -Silanah 35
Mockra 31
dead - Kaschan 28
dead - Emurlahn 25
reborn -Shadow 24
Tennes 17
Omtose 14
dead - Thyrllan 13
Rashan 11
dead - Kessobahn 10
Ruse 9
dead - Fener 8
dead - Liosan 5
D'riss

ok so we have driss, ruse, rashan, omtose tennes, mockra, shadow, and korlat (me) left.

Clearly we have some vig happy players about, unless the killers get a serious whack of kills.

@shadow - any indication why you died? any indication of why you came back?

i assume someone out there must have a rejuvination technique, while others have vigs. Hopefully thats random deaths out of the way and we can try and play.

i am officially lost, i was trying to make sense of this, but i cant. anyone?

[Path-Shaper]

You forgot JA. He was lynched, remember. OK, now I am just being mean. Sorry, but I couldn't help myself.

~Zing!

[Emurlahn]

HOLLY FUCK









....DIES

[Shadow]

rofl, wow
that's a lot of death
and Liosan didn't come back, only me.
heh, I guess I should say "thanks: to whomever revived me (I'm assuming, from looking at the role guide that that's why I'm back.)

and no, no clue why I died. eager vig would be my guess.
and I had 35 posts, before PS went on a deleting spree. it was quite frustrating, actually, watching the game for two days, unable to comment ANYWHERE ( I still sent PS a coupla pms fvrom my regualr account, just to make myself feel better), and watching that I for most of the time, I remained top poster.

[Bent]

Emurlahn, on Dec 17 2008, 08:33 AM, said:

HOLLY FUCK









....DIES

I will not delete this, even though he's dead. Fucking funny, and also Christmasy.