[Mockra]

ok I know this is a little silly, but I thought to examine the train on JA

Train: Korlat, Fener, Gamelon,Thyrllan, Rashan, Mockra,Ruse,Emurlahn

on the JA train:
Thyrllan is dead
Gamelon is dead
Emurlahn is dead
Fener is dead

Korlat, Rashan, Ruse, do any of you feel like you survived the night the skins of your backs?
I almost feel like they got picked for being on the train. Though I think I will re read them anyway.

not:
Kessobahn is dead
Kaschan is dead
Silanah is dead

Going to look back at these dead ones and see if they said anything to worth dying over.
Except maybe Silanah, he/she/it was rubbing people the wrong way for a fair amount of time.
Or was it him? Aw fuck, I am just going to do a reread of the thread

Edit: Cross post

This post has been edited by Mockra: 17 December 2008 - 03:42 PM

[Shadow]

lol, I was on that train when I died too, if that helps,

[Mockra]

Shadow, on Dec 17 2008, 05:41 PM, said:

lol, I was on that train when I died too, if that helps,

LOL! I see now.

[Korlat]

i didn't feel i was under threat no, but then i expected one person to die, not seven.

@shadow - and yet the same anger that permeated all of silanah's later posts is present in your play. AND you were on the JA train, so what are you talking about as regards to that?

I am going to check silanah's posts before you died and those after to see if there is any difference.

[Korlat]

actually silanah's first post was just a few after you 'died'.

[Mockra]

Korlat, on Dec 17 2008, 05:53 PM, said:

actually silanah's first post was just a few after you 'died'.

Are you implying he pulled a Faceless Man, 3 hours into the game and then unFMed himself at the end of night?

[Korlat]

did i say that?

well it would be funny if his role was, faceless man - you have 3 hours to jump!!! you would read that and just shit yourself

This post has been edited by Korlat: 17 December 2008 - 03:56 PM

[Shadow]

no, seriously, people have to learn to separate their games.

after Game 12 we had Mexal paranoia for a while, where everyone would jump anyone that made sense and yell "ZOMG, he's helpful--SCUM!!!"

now, after Ghostbusters, whenever you agree with a dead person people are gonna scream "ZOMG, POSSESSION!!!"

seriously, think about it for a second--how stupid would bringing scum back to life AS A DEAD ALT sounds? do you not SEE the fundamental flaw with that--ffs, i'm already a fucking center of attention--the LAST thing scum wants when they switch bodies.

and yeah, YOU try being dead for two days, yet unable to post in spoilers what you think about what the people in thread are doing (or rather, not doing, because they're afraid they'll die after 35 posts ) and you may get a little irritated too..

and I'm not even sure Silanah posted before I died--he may have, but i'm not too sure about it.

RE: JA's train. yes, I voted on it. Because I didn't have Silanah's patience of trying to explain to you all how stupid it was. I tried--I said what happened last time. But people don't listen. the fastest way to show you how wrong you were was to actually get the number of votes necessary for a lynch--so I voted.
Make of that waht you wish.

ETA: well, what do you know... another cross-post.
and, afaik, FM takes two days to work, as a general rule--if you let an FM jump each day, that makes it waaay overpowered.

This post has been edited by Shadow: 17 December 2008 - 04:01 PM

[Korlat]

well i am out for a few hours.

remove vote

lets see what everyone has to say.

[Mockra]

Emurlahn, on Dec 15 2008, 03:29 PM, said:

Omtose, on Dec 15 2008, 01:25 PM, said:

So anyone got any ideas on possible win conditions or even teams or anything coz atm I cant see anything we have no opening scene, or winning conditions of any type. I wonder if we've got a battle royal mafia game

Vote Omotose

For trying to get us to discuss game mechanics which only help the scum

And this lady and gentlemen is why Emrulahn was Nk'd! Now if only I could find this Omotose fellow...

No seriously, I can't say I found much there, besides his griping about the fact we did not get a lynch after already losing 2 people to day kills.

[Mockra]

Shadow, on Dec 17 2008, 05:59 PM, said:

no, seriously, people have to learn to separate their games.

after Game 12 we had Mexal paranoia for a while, where everyone would jump anyone that made sense and yell "ZOMG, he's helpful--SCUM!!!"

now, after Ghostbusters, whenever you agree with a dead person people are gonna scream "ZOMG, POSSESSION!!!"

seriously, think about it for a second--how stupid would bringing scum back to life AS A DEAD ALT sounds? do you not SEE the fundamental flaw with that--ffs, i'm already a fucking center of attention--the LAST thing scum wants when they switch bodies.

and yeah, YOU try being dead for two days, yet unable to post in spoilers what you think about what the people in thread are doing (or rather, not doing, because they're afraid they'll die after 35 posts ) and you may get a little irritated too..

and I'm not even sure Silanah posted before I died--he may have, but i'm not too sure about it.

RE: JA's train. yes, I voted on it. Because I didn't have Silanah's patience of trying to explain to you all how stupid it was. I tried--I said what happened last time. But people don't listen. the fastest way to show you how wrong you were was to actually get the number of votes necessary for a lynch--so I voted.
Make of that waht you wish.

ETA: well, what do you know... another cross-post.
and, afaik, FM takes two days to work, as a general rule--if you let an FM jump each day, that makes it waaay overpowered.

Ok well, I have no clue what happened in game 12, so I will take your word for it. And I agree scum doing that makes no sense and is way to overpowered a mechanic, though someone else resurrecting scum by accident could happen. TBH though I doubt you are scum. On a quick scan of the people still alive, I would say D'riss is scum, but thats because he only has one post, which is not a fair reason to lynch him.

As for win conditions, does anyone else get the feeling this is one of those lost mafia games? Like the Pompei one, which was every man for yourself. (Well sorta)

All right enough rambling, going back to perv over the dead....

[Mockra]

Reading Silanah was not fun....

Whoever killed him has my thanks.
He spent forever discussing day kills and decided it was all wifom then exploded on us for the 'JA' lynch.

[Mockra]

Besides symping a little Korlat, I see nothing to get Kess killed.

So either I am missing something or these deaths were mostly random.... either way I am sick and tired of looking at the dead.

Vote: D'riss

Because I want you to get your ass in here and say something....

[D'riss]

Ask and you will recieve. Maybe. Im bit busy today, cause of a concert.

Anyhow, what my thoughts are:

JA lynch, while funny, was a bit of a waste of time. It seemed based on "whys he on the vote count if hes not playing" argument pushed by certain players. I mean, yes its mindfuck, but JA being here would make no sense, etc. It was just a silly waste of time thing to do.

There is a lot of dying, but someone is bringing people back. I reckon a lot of the killing is vigs. What I reckon is bad, is that with so much killing whoever it is bringing people back, who id guess is inno, could die. With so many dying, we'd want that role alive, as it would certainly help.
I dislike the no reveal rule already, tbh, as it seems ridiculous along with no CF. That makes it impossible to make connections etc, so if two are connected, normally lynch one, check the CF, but we cant. This game just seems like random chance, and a bit silly.

[Mockra]

SUMMONING COMPLETE
Remove vote


Good to see you, but now I have to leave for about an hour at least..... sorry

This post has been edited by Mockra: 17 December 2008 - 05:07 PM

[Shadow]

hmm, we seem to be getting nowhere, and since the thread's so damn quiet, i'll assume that a bunch of usually loud players got killed off.

regarding the NKs, I have to say i agree on the suggestion that there's been a bunch of vigs, possibly with the "use it in the firss 1/2/3/etc nights or lose it", and, in the best traditions of Malaz mafia people went overboard. As annoying as it is, most of us have done it at one point or another, so I won't blame anyone for it.

moving on to what we should do now, I hope our reviver is still alive, and I hope that his/their (if there's more than one) ability is a multiple use one.

Aside from that, well, I still like my Korlat case and I (reasonably) dislike the suggestion of lynching myself.
The D'riss thing is a bit thin at this time, though I'm never really averse to a low-poster lynch.

[Bent]

Sorry guys work is kicking my ass today, Can't do a proper vote count until I get off in about 4 hours. But you have 30 hours or so remaining. I'll try to get back in a couple hours.

[Shadow]

lol, no worries, Bent
there's only one vote right now--mine. and it's on Korlat.

[Shadow]

all righty then, since it seems I'm talking to myself, I'm off to run a few erands, and then I gotta grab something to eat.

back in about an hour.

[Ruse]

I'm waiting for a PM about mechanics to be answered by the mods before I start throwing anything around ...

Not that we've got anything to work with.