Barghast, on Oct 28 2008, 09:01 PM, said:
Ok, now I'm definatly back. Why are you so lynch happy, Emurlahn? I'm very suspicious of that. It's day one, we don't understand how things will develop(anyone see the revealing of night actions coming? Makes things VERY interesting for the Heroes with powers), so why press for a lynch? I for one would prefer to vote Night, and welcome our new super-powered overlords, but I suppose if we have the possibility of voting someone off that we're sure is safe...
If you call my atempts at discussion pressing for a lynch, I think you might need to brush up on some definitions. Yes, I've suggested those two as possible lynches, and yes I think we should work to get what little information we can. It is possible we hit the wrong player, 1/16 chance of hitting Sylar an all, but we have to risk something I think.
Fener, on Oct 28 2008, 09:42 PM, said:
Emurlahn, on Oct 28 2008, 07:29 PM, said:
Anyways. It's good that you are here, Fener, for I've been playing with the thought of arguing that we should lynch you or Mockra, if we decide to lynch anyone. Since you're here we can discuss it.
Basically, my argument is that the way you jumped up defending Mockra makes you a likely candidate to be his partner, or his friend as discussed earlier regarding likely roles knowing of each other.
Sylar would not have a friend to defend him like that. And Peter as we've argued in all probability does not know who Claire is, even if she could know him. That should mean that you'd be a safe lynch in regards to one day victories.
I basically think it'd be good for us to narrow the playing field a little, and any new information now is good information.
The question in essence is why you were so quick to jump up in defence of Mockra when there really was no reason to. Mockra clearly overreacted badly to a mistake he himself made, yet you defended him very one sidedly. Why?
I like the way you posted this, almost like we had been having a conversation and that I was around. I was not around and we were not having a conversation. This is the post you refer to:
Fener, on Oct 28 2008, 01:27 PM, said:
Seemed to be a genuine mistake to me. You seem very aggressive Serc and ringing a very loud bell on day 1. I dunno I dont want to Alt guess but I am now.
Not really much of a defence. Serc was accusing Mockra of cheating, which I guess it could be argued he was. I was just saying I thought it was a genuine mistake as opposed to him doing it on purpose. The second part was just a joke and maybe could have done with a smiley.
Ok, I'm sorry I'm going to bed and can't dig up the quotes today, but your defence of Mockra were a lot more than just that on little quote.