[Gavin]

He should have been Modkilled a couple days ago actually... He was 26 hours without posting I believe. I didn't want to say too much as I wasn't sure of his guilt

[J_Slr]

I hope Silencer is hungry

[J_Slr]

OH well, its too late to change it now, I hope that they get JA today, because that should in theory level the field a bit

Here is a possible scenario:

9 players (3 evil):
lynch JA (comes up inno) + 1 Nk

7 players (2 evil):
People will take out Obdi or Silencer and the other will probably be nkd <- Actually Obdi should get NKd and Silencer lynched

5 players (2 evil):
Lynch or Lose time, hopefully by this point Dk will have woken up.....

I reckon that unless someone wakes up and targets Lisheo or Mocker. JA has to go for the Inno to come close to a chance of winning. Also I believe the Noob card should expire after day 2

This post has been edited by J_Slr: 24 October 2008 - 04:52 AM

[Path-Shaper]

lol, you're putting too much faith in the fact that they'll get JA
I wouldn't count on it, lol

*yawn*
it's 1 AM, i'm out for the night

J, feel free to take over.JA should be getting on soon-ish...

[Gavin]

I think it might come down to Silencer and what his defence is like. I reckon JA might switch to him or Baudin. While the others will go for JA or Lisheo. Sticking to Obdi would be a big mistake.

I still believe the game hangs in the balance at this point. It looks like an evil win from this position, but the trouble was there was a lot of speculation that needed to be tested out. Morgoth was one, Vengy the other. Once those two were out of the way its narrowed the field considerably and cleared a few people. Also the killers and JA have had to take more risks now to get the lynch. To the point where they are both Lisheo and JA cannot be ignored as being evil I would think.

[J_Slr]

@PS: I Know I am, unfortunately I can not see Innos winning with JA in the way.

@Gavin: Well I hope sticking to obdi is a big mistake, because JA wants him bad

[Yellow]

Path-Shaper, on Oct 23 2008, 11:18 PM, said:

alcoholics... it's a Thursday, ffs

Aaaah, the mid-week binge. Can it ever be topped?

Gavin, on Oct 24 2008, 05:06 AM, said:

Well read the spoilers now. Why weren't we told that the symps and masters knew each other? This pisses me off no end. If your going to post the rules, post all the rules damnit in a low difficulty game. It completely changes the Lisheo and Mocker refusal to votes for Morgoth, from noob reluctance to vote for an innocent, to people protecting someone. When Morgy came back innocent it just confirmed the rookie moment.

It was the only reason why Lisheo was behind Obdi, Veng and Silencer was because it appeared to be amateur hour with him and mocker wiith the refusing to vote someone he thought innocent, and then who came back innocent. I could only look at that in a positive light.

Oh well never mind.

I have to say I agree with this completely. I had Lisheo tagged 100% as Morgoth's symp, and then when he came back inno, that completely scuppered my impression of Lisheo. But I was right, because he was symping him. He's been symping JA all game as well.

I think if we'd have known about the symp thing (which definitely makes this game higher than TMDI 2), we would not be in the state we are in right now.

[Path-Shaper]

By the Gods! JA really does enjoy playing with fire

Jump Around said:

OK, tricky decision and move I made there.

Today, we will look at the new players, I see it coming, it's been building for some time. Mocker has played the scummiest game of the new players, and he's the probable target anyways. I'm playing reverse-psychology: if I start the day with a lousy case and vote on Mocker, then the natural reaction should be for everyone to pull back and pause. Weasel this, weasel that, I hope this can save him. People will see the two cases on Baudin, wonder why I'm so quick to jump the gun on someone else, that might get Baudin lynched instead. Or Lace.

I don't know who the other symp is, if any, or if he's still alive. I don't know how far away we are from winning. If dktorode starts a train on Lisheo or Mocker, he might convince the others, and with the CF I can't really defend him, or we lose 2 players for the price of 1. I put my vote on Mocker, harass Obdigore, argue that Lisheo is at worst a symp, and we pray for the best.

If that gets Mocker lynched, I apologize in advance.

[Tapper]

Nah, not so much playing with fire as much as trusting he is in control of the game. I wonder what will happen though when JA keeps his vote on Mocker, 1 or 2 get added and Lisheo &/or Mocker logs on... they might panic, and we haven't seen how they stand up to a case yet.
"lol-cat" and "txtspeak" are generally (imho) not the best ways to convince someone they're wrong, and both Lisheo and Mocker have done a lot of both.

This post has been edited by Tapper: 24 October 2008 - 07:44 AM

[J_Slr]

Jeez but there is a lot of crap in P-S's account!

[J_Slr]

Tapper you paint a pretty picture, can not wait to see how things play out

[Path-Shaper]

More from JA:

Jump Around said:

Well, let's see now.

If dktorode makes a case on Mocker, I'm quite sure we'll lose the crowd faster than it takes to say "piss-pants paranoia"

Let's hope he doesn't make his case on Lisheo, and we should be fine.

Silencer is useless to the innos, he's only reacting to me and suspects dktorode . Obdigore I'm sure is having wet dreams about me now, and The Dude is thinking Baudin. I don't know what Baudin is thinking, and the rest is killers.

Hopefully, we can get a good lynch today and win.

Here is hoping Dk takes on Lisheo

[Gavin]

I'm tempted to tell DKT the killers know their symps....

[J_Slr]

I have been tempted to tell everyone since I got here!!!!

[drinksinbars]

*ahem yellow*

i draw your attention to exhibit A

Yellow, on Oct 21 2008, 06:12 PM, said:

drinksinbars, on Oct 21 2008, 09:04 AM, said:

@yellow -im voting in green grabs everones marbles

Lol, what the fuck was that about?

[drinksinbars]

ja is a great player - setting up his killer because he knows fine rightly that nothing he says is taken straight and people seem to always believe the opposite.

@morgo - you werent against it from the start. A few games ago in one of the minis i ran which was my last normal game i forgot to increas ekiller numbers when the game grew to 18 players. there were 2 killers and 1 symp (think you were one) and the killers ailed to victory by sheer skill and persuasion. The fact that this game they had an extra number and the relationship worked both ways with the two symps knowing they were known, makes evil ridiculously overpowered.

[J_Slr]

So why is DKt the herald of High House Mafia?

[drinksinbars]

cause he talks to much

[J_Slr]

I have to honest Dibs, I think JA is one of the scariest mafia players we have here!

[J_Slr]

Jump Around, on Oct 24 2008, 11:09 AM, said:

Silencer, on Oct 24 2008, 12:08 PM, said:

Your reputation precedes you, JA.

You know, when I play inno, I do get scum lynched from time to time

That's why I would wish players to comment my case more than who made it.

Check the bolded statement, I think that would make me very suspicious of JA, I know he is a damn awesome player and to have missed the scum so far would make start to question him and his motives. (Grrr! This is meta and I hate it!)