[Gem Windcaster]

alt146, on Oct 17 2008, 05:18 PM, said:

I see yellow is back. Anyway, I gotta go now.

vote Morgoth

For being the person most likely to be lynched today.

Explain this please, alt146. As Gavin says, it looks like you're just jumping on movements in the grass...

[Obdigore]

Remove Vote
Vote Gavin
For symping morgoth.

;0

[J_Slr]

Vote Alt146

You (among others ) seem to be a little to lynch-happy.

[Lisheo]

I agree with Gavin. While I'm only a newb to the game, reading peoples PMs in SH was always amusing, at least vote someone who shows genuine evidence of being dodgy, Im torn between voting Alt and Yellow, but atm Im keeping my vote on Yellow now, he seemed far too eager to get someone voted off this early with Alt just jumping on the bandwagon, and the only kind of player who wants someone off this early is scum.

EDIT: No screw it, I can understand Yellow, Morgy voted for him with no reason first, so...
Remove Vote

Vote Alt146

This post has been edited by Lisheo: 17 October 2008 - 05:04 PM

[Gem Windcaster]

The natural thing here would be to vote Obdi for symping alt146.

[Yellow]

I'm not saying that Morgoth is a stone-cold, slap-on killer, but he's the only one that has stood out to me so far.

1) because he was sending PMs to spoilers when nothing was going on. Nothing inherently wrong with that, but it's completely the opposite of myself unless I have some kind of role.

2) He was trying to cuddle up to DiBs after getting in a bit of an argument, which makes me think of someone desperate to not get painted a killer, but still trying not to piss anyone off.

Like I say, nothing about this is rock solid, it's just my gut feeling.

[Lisheo]

Can we get a vote count?

[Gem Windcaster]

Yellow, the only reason we vote for people here is because we think they're scum, not because they' stand out. Either you think Morgy is a killer or you don't - make up your mind.

[The Dude]

Any chance we could get a vote count?

EDIT Bah, cross with Lisheo

This post has been edited by The Dude: 17 October 2008 - 05:07 PM

[Lacedaemonian]

And she was selling drugs to the bairns out back.

[Morgoth]

Yellow, on Oct 17 2008, 07:04 PM, said:

I'm not saying that Morgoth is a stone-cold, slap-on killer, but he's the only one that has stood out to me so far.

1) because he was sending PMs to spoilers when nothing was going on. Nothing inherently wrong with that, but it's completely the opposite of myself unless I have some kind of role.

2) He was trying to cuddle up to DiBs after getting in a bit of an argument, which makes me think of someone desperate to not get painted a killer, but still trying not to piss anyone off.

Like I say, nothing about this is rock solid, it's just my gut feeling.

Seeing that we're playing alt-less, meta reasoning will end up being a part of any argument, and counter argument. It's DiBs. This is the tone we generally have between the two of us. Yes, claiming I thought him a likely innocent can be seen as cuddeling up to him, and to an extent I'm sure I wanted a strong ally which he would undoubtedly be, but at the same time I hold by that conviction still.

If you're refering to the naming him a hunk, I just don't know how to respond.

[Grief]

It is Day 1. There is 1 hour 20 minutes remaining.

18 Players alive : Alt146, Baudin, Dibs, Dktorode ,Gavin, Gem, J_Slr, Jump Around, Lacedaemonian, Lisheo, Mocker, Morgoth, Obdigore, Silencer, Tapper, The Dude, Vengence, Yellow

10 votes for lynch 9 votes for night

4 votes for Morgoth ( DiBs,Lacedaemonian, alt146, Yellow, Baudin)
1 vote for Tapper (Silencer)
2 votes for Yellow (Morgoth, Tapper)
1 vote for Vengeance (Jump around)
1 vote for Jump around (dktorode)
3 votes for Alt146(Gavin, J_Slr, Lisheo)
1 vote for Gavin(Obdigore)

Not voted : Gem, Mocker, The Dude,

This post has been edited by Grief: 17 October 2008 - 05:13 PM

[Yellow]

Gem Windcaster, on Oct 17 2008, 06:07 PM, said:

Yellow, the only reason we vote for people here is because we think they're scum, not because they' stand out. Either you think Morgy is a killer or you don't - make up your mind.

Thanks for telling me why we vote for people I'm voting for Morgoth because he stands out as the most likely to be a killer.

[Gavin]

Well I am going to bed, doesn't look likely for a lynch but stranger things have happened at sea, but I gotta say there's some rather strange stuff going on here at the moment looking at the voting. Going to have to go back and reread this bit tomorrow.

[Gem Windcaster]

Yellow, on Oct 17 2008, 05:11 PM, said:

Gem Windcaster, on Oct 17 2008, 06:07 PM, said:

Yellow, the only reason we vote for people here is because we think they're scum, not because they' stand out. Either you think Morgy is a killer or you don't - make up your mind.

Thanks for telling me why we vote for people I'm voting for Morgoth because he stands out as the most likely to be a killer.

NP, you were being a bit dodgy.

[Yellow]

Morgoth, on Oct 17 2008, 06:08 PM, said:

If you're refering to the naming him a hunk, I just don't know how to respond.

Hand job?

[Yellow]

Grief, on Oct 17 2008, 06:10 PM, said:

It is Day 1. There is 1 hour 20 minutes remaining.

We're so not going to get a lynch today.

[Lisheo]

If we are gonna lynch everyone who stands out as being dodgy, Id have quite the list of people to vote for, with you and Alt topping the list, for tryin to get someone lynched for no real reason. True, he's Morgy lmao, but I cant see anything in his posts that suggests he could be a killer. And it'll only help the scum if he was to get lynched with no evidence, and turn out to be innocent.

[The Dude]

Something about the way Alt146 just keeps popping in and out, not saying much but watching everything seems a bit fishy. Doesn't look like we are going to get a lynch but I really don't think Morgoth is that suspicious and haven't played enough games to subscribe to the meta-reasoning on why he might be.

vote Alt146

for reasons mentioned above.

[Vengeance]

I haven't seen anything that has looked dodgy enough to lynch yet, and I doubt that I will. All of the day one cases are meta even more so then they are when we have alts.