[Giles]

Well im gonna be off for maybe 4 hours doing taekwondo, at the moment the only person i can really see making waves is morgoth so...
vote Morgoth

[Yellow]

I'll be around til the deadline (or until the woman wants to go on facebook).

@The Dude, I'm actually surprised there are any cases at all. Day one is notoriously painful. Pity this one will be so short, and likely end in my death.

Fuckers.

edit - aha! Maybe not yet.

This post has been edited by Yellow: 17 October 2008 - 04:43 PM

[Lisheo]

Hello all, just finished dinner... I see Morgys got himself in yet another awkward situation

[J_Slr]

Vengeance, on Oct 17 2008, 06:08 PM, said:

Lacedaemonian, on Oct 17 2008, 10:50 AM, said:

I am voting for Morgoth. She clearly has an agenda and has been circling the dance floor all night.

:Patch:

^ could not have said it any better.....

On a side note though..... My brain hurts! Should have known better than to hope the post frequency would keep slow down....

[Tapper]

@ Yellow: it would be weird if Bent and Grief were up to their necks in your PMs while we on the thread would have 1 contribution only from you, no? Especially not since you argue against lynching you/ defending your low post count with RL reasons.

Anyway, I see some merit in your 'case' against Morgoth, so I would be willing to switch if we get a lynch that way.

[The Dude]

@Yellow and since it is day one everyone will look at my last post as Symping you

[Morgoth]

so people are just dumping votes on me, yet no one seems to know why? Apart fromDiBs and Yellow that is. See this is the biggest problem we have with mafia. The vocal players are killed for being vocal and the quiet players get even more incentive to remain so.

[Gem Windcaster]

Morgy, you have to admit Yellow has got a point.

[J_Slr]

So two questions then:

Can we get a vote count?

and why are our esteemed mods posting naked?

[Lisheo]

On the plus side you probably wont get enough votes to get lynched, mate. Its only day one.

[Morgoth]

Yellow, on Oct 17 2008, 06:36 PM, said:

What did I say? Don't fucking speed lynch me while I'm at work! This is why most of you lose most of the time.

Anyway...

Morgoth, on Oct 17 2008, 09:37 AM, said:

drinksinbars, on Oct 17 2008, 10:29 AM, said:

well silencer actually called me the symp so i was repsonding to that. And on first read through i did think you were acting dodgy morgo, so although i dont have much to work with i am keeping my eye on you. As for obdi and vengeance, it seems more like th eusual day 1 try to lynch someone before they turn up. Also you have made a lot of fille rposts morgo, and your post count is highest as a result. You also responded well to the case, but tried to convionce me by saying you didnt think i was a killer, when you know i am a terrible one for flattery

At the moment though i would say morgo, the dude and tapper are my top suspects.

@dk - its bloody baltic here, you evil git, i cant believe you are indoors when its so sunny outside. Unless you have to wrk in which case haha, i dont mind working when its freezing outside as my office is warm.

I would never flatter you for favour you big hunk of a man you. I know you suspect me and I'm not very surprised that you do. I believe I sent a message into SH early saying that DiBs will accuse me of being a symp for this, but it's too much fun. For my posting, well, I was supposed to write an article god forbidd. It was a lot easier to post here.

Right, this rang my bell a little bit, because for a start I have not sent any PMs to the spoilers board yet, because nothing interesting has happened and my role provides nothing interesting for the spoilers... but Morgoth is worried that people will think he's a symp. So, since nothing interesting has happened yet, it makes me suspicious that Morgoth's role makes him interesting to the spoilers board.

Also, he's doing his best to get on DiB's side at this point, by loving up to him. If I were a killer, I would want DiBs on my side as well.

Morgoth, on Oct 17 2008, 09:54 AM, said:

Tapper, on Oct 17 2008, 10:48 AM, said:

Hey, stop symping me, Morgoth

shut up, master. You don't want them to find you out now do you? Just follow my lead and everything will be all right.



Seriously though. The fact that I am defending someone that's not myself does not equall bloody symping. Jeez, my desperate atempts to keep poor Piper alive must surely be proof of that.. bah

I actually agree with this statement (which is not meant to be ironic, I'm just saying that the sheepish symp accusations piss me off as well).

Which makes the following a bit of a shame, but fuck there's about an hour left to the day:

vote Morgoth

And despite the below quote, it's not OMGUS, damnit!

Morgoth, on Oct 17 2008, 04:34 PM, said:

You know what, screw all this. I can't really pay attention as there's more to do here than I expected, and since I do not really suspcet anyone at this point:

Yellow because I like my name to be a curse, and as you know I've always been an advocate for lynching low contributors when no other options are present

I don't see how your case makes much sense. I told PS that I thought DiBs would label me a symp because of the way I posted. I know him. I was right. Does that make me suspicious? I fail to see why.

And You've posted three times. No wonder you've not sent anything to the spoiler board. I've sent a good handfull of messages already, pretty much every thought that popps into my head. Your reasoning just doesn't add up, but it seems people don't want that. They just want a train to latch onto.

[Morgoth]

Gem Windcaster, on Oct 17 2008, 06:47 PM, said:

Morgy, you have to admit Yellow has got a point.

No, I don't think he has. I know DiBs playing pretty well and can to an extent guess what he finds suspicious. Does that make me suspicious? Or perhaps just thoughfull? I spent a lot of time with this game last night, and as such many thoughts and many messages to PS. I just don't see how this should make me lynch worthy

[Lisheo]

I honestly think Yellow's enthusiasm to post Morgoth is a little odd, from the lowest poster vs the highest poster. And saying his role aint of interest so early??? Hmmm....

[Gem Windcaster]

Well, who has so many thoughts on day 1? Seriously, that does make you look a suspect.


Edit: @ Morgy again.

This post has been edited by Gem Windcaster: 17 October 2008 - 04:53 PM

[J_Slr]

Or bored with nothing better to do.....

[Tapper]

Morgoth, on Oct 17 2008, 06:45 PM, said:

so people are just dumping votes on me, yet no one seems to know why? Apart fromDiBs and Yellow that is. See this is the biggest problem we have with mafia. The vocal players are killed for being vocal and the quiet players get even more incentive to remain so.

That comes a bit close to whining, Morgy. You know how there always is a lot of natural selection going on amongst the top posters for who gets to lead the pack, a few slightly under that who patiently sit that out to fill the vacuum and then make their own voice heard after that, and a low-posting group that thinks all is well that way since they avoid a lynch for being a low poster instead.
The perfect proof of the above being true is how DiBs has and kept his vote on you since a couple of hours into the game.

Me, I just want a lynch to get the game going and to see a train, and I don't mind if we get it left or right.

Oh, and as far as I can see, you are not getting lynched for being a high-poster: I'm including you on my two-name lynch list because of Yellow's slightly meta-y argument that you admitted sending thoughts to the spoilerboard. It's such innocent admonitions that stand out on day 1, not your post count.(although making a lot of posts also increases the chances that you'll let something slip that will make others scratch their heads).

[Morgoth]

Gem Windcaster, on Oct 17 2008, 06:52 PM, said:

Well, who has so many thoughts on day 1? Seriously, that does make you look a suspect.


Edit: @ Morgy again.

Have you ever even read the spoiler board in games I play? It does not seem to be the case as I always send lots and lots of pms

[Gem Windcaster]

Well, Morgy's a veteran, so how much thought does he need to put into a pretty standard game?


Edit: cross post! @ Morgy, well that's true I guess.

This post has been edited by Gem Windcaster: 17 October 2008 - 04:56 PM

[Gavin]

Well looks to me the case on Morgoth is because he has sent a message to spoilers? If thats the case and it apparently, then thats gayer than a night out with Dibs.

Whats worse people are jumping on it. Come on people seriously we're voting people for sending messages to Spoilers? While Morgy has come across as a bit dodge still don't think its a case for voting on.

Since night is upon us soon and I need to go...
Vote Alt146

For being a little suspicious before and now just jumping on any bandwagon that looks like it might be the lynch.

[Morgoth]

Tapper, on Oct 17 2008, 06:55 PM, said:

Morgoth, on Oct 17 2008, 06:45 PM, said:

so people are just dumping votes on me, yet no one seems to know why? Apart fromDiBs and Yellow that is. See this is the biggest problem we have with mafia. The vocal players are killed for being vocal and the quiet players get even more incentive to remain so.

That comes a bit close to whining, Morgy. You know how there always is a lot of natural selection going on amongst the top posters for who gets to lead the pack, a few slightly under that who patiently sit that out to fill the vacuum and then make their own voice heard after that, and a low-posting group that thinks all is well that way since they avoid a lynch for being a low poster instead.
The perfect proof of the above being true is how DiBs has and kept his vote on you since a couple of hours into the game.

Me, I just want a lynch to get the game going and to see a train, and I don't mind if we get it left or right.

Oh, and as far as I can see, you are not getting lynched for being a high-poster: I'm including you on my two-name lynch list because of Yellow's slightly meta-y argument that you admitted sending thoughts to the spoilerboard. It's such innocent admonitions that stand out on day 1, not your post count.(although making a lot of posts also increases the chances that you'll let something slip that will make others scratch their heads).

Might be whining, but it is nevertheless the truth. We kill of vocal players early because they seem to be the only ones with enough posts to find something to latch onto. I should probably have learned prior to this, whenever I'm vocal i die within the first two days, whenever I'm more withdrawn I generally survive to the end game. Yet I like speaking my mind, about everything. How that should deserve my lynch, and yellows argument is just that, then there's just no way to defend myself.