[Set'alahd Crool]

Yup. That was me

[Morgoth]

I liked NoK, it was a bit stumbeling in the begining, but got better as it moved along.

The Dassem part was the best part, i've got to agree with that. Especially since it put Whiskeyjack's and thus Kallor's skill with a sword in a better perspective.

Also, I got the impression that Temper was the most competent fighter of in the sword. No matter his technique, he managed to hold of a champion assumed to be the better of all but Dassem. He dispatched an elite member of the claw in mocks hold with little difficulty. And most importantly, he stood his ground against a Jhagut tyrant (or so she seemed to me).
Also, Kiska i think it was, describes Temper as a huge man, and he is shown several times to hold an almost inhuman strenght.

Dassem being traveler fits even better now.
"What will you do?"
"Travel. Head West"
He just fits so nicely as Traveler.

Gothos can travel between Azaths, is it not then natural to asume that the other guradians can as well? If so the the female Jhagut could have come from any Azath.

As an end note, I think Ferrule is Barathol from the BH prologue. Ferrule is of Sethi heritage, Barathol is described as a tribesman from the south. Ferrule returned to his homeland, Barathol lives on the subcontinent. My knowledge of the timeline is not perfect yet 11 years does sound fairly right to me. Also, Ferrule is described as a man fond of close in fighting, more a brawler than a swordfighter. An axe would be the right weapon for such a man I think. And he also has a special helmet, just like Temper

[Folken]

Answer my question damn you!...ANSWER!

[Imperial Historian]

quote:

Kellanved 'annoyed' them by annexing Unta and ousting Price K'ass D'avore, who ruled there or was successor to the throne.

That's what i initially thought... but then we find that the d'avorans had rebelled previosuly and got beat by the untan royal house, and i think they were kicked of there lands then, u'd have thought kelvenned invading unta and defeating the royal house would have made them allies of a sort...

Perhaps the reason for the hatred is that kelvanned didn't return the land to them...

Corrin being tatersail... i don't think so, one we surely would have heard if tatersail had been in the BB's at any point, two tatersails first action in the service of the malazan empire was in the mouse, before Nok, after which she got shipped out... so i don't see her coming back to malaz so soon... plus corrin is a veteran, and you don't become a veteran in 6 months.

Good to see you've finally joined us Dakk

[vaiski]

Quick Ben noted in MoI that Blend has "raw put pure talent, right in her bones, and she doesn't even know it" so obviously not Kiska.

As for the duel, "Only Skinner had come away alive from their clash" - doesn't sound like Skinner had the upper hand to me.
Anyways, regarding whole best swordsman thing, I still hold to Brood's opinion. I'm not saying that he knows, has seen or heard about every swordsman out there but he does have a lot of experience of wars and battles.

[Imperial Historian]

I have to say... after reading the bits in NoK that it is clear that dassem is teh vbets swordsman of them all, and is amazingly cool altogether.

NOW MAJOR SPOILERS, IF YOU ARE EVEN CONISDERING READING THE BOOK DONT READ THIS BIT AS IT MIGHT RUIN ONE OF THE BEST BITS IN THE BOOK FOR YOU

We basically see dassem fighting in seven cities, he and his sword go to remove the last champion of the seven cities cause, sturgen who somehow has the magical blessing which means he is amazingly fast. Dassem and sturgen duel, and during teh fight teh sword and dasseem are cut off from teh rets of the army, and during the fight he is hit by something, its not clear what, though it is suggested that it has somethign to do with the claw, anyway dassem is near mortally wounded, he manages to fend off sturgen, who then procedes to demolish most of the rest of the sword, before being stopped by temper long enough for the rest of the army to reach them. During this time whilst mortally wounded dassem easily manages to fight off all the seven cities veterans save sturgen the champion, which is pretty amazing.

After this dassem is brought back to the alazan camp, and is being "looked after" by surly and the claw. Temper and Ferrule the remaining members of the sword, join dassem in the tent, killing tehre claw gaurds on the way, lasseen leaves the tent and leaves her two top assasins and a few other claws in the tent to assainate temper, ferrule and dassem.

Temper realises that dassem will never succumb to hood, she hates him so much, so attempts to kill him hoping this will rouse him, dassem then knocks tmper out and procedes to kill all the claws in the tent, within a few seconds, which is again damned amazing, and one of teh coolest moments in the book. (Note: we say a couple of claws surrounded by the bodies of a few squads of veteran bridgeburners at one point, and the only reason the bridgeburners seem to have won is because one of them let off a cusser)

After that temper, dassem and ferrule travel off into the west, seperating along the way, dassem goes off to travel the world alone.

The ice warriors are the ice spectres yes.

[vahlar]

Does anyone else think Edgewalker sounds like a Tiste, perhaps an Edur being in shadow and all?

[gyrehead]

I've got a couple of questions now that I read it and then gone back through after reading comments here and parsing through the five series books.

Jenna wanted the Ice to come through because she wanted it to free her, right? But I got the sense that this was a gamble on her part and that the Ice taking hold of the Deadhouse was not a sure "good" thing for her. Was she somehow responsible for the Stormriders attack? Or did she just sense it and hope for the best?

What happened to Ferrule? I have only read the series once and cannot remember if his fate was mentioned.

Do we know who or what is killing the Stormriders? For some odd reason unknown I thought maybe that was where Kellanved and Dancer were before their assault on the Deadhouse.

Is NOK the first in the series that ICE has planned or the bridge to that series with the first book being what he already has written? And has he ever refered to what the series would be called to avoid confusion?!

Overall I enjoyed the book very much, though it lurched a bit in the first half. The second half picked up and moved quite well. Though there were a couple of instances that a good editor could have helped. Some of the duplications in action seen through first Kiska's eyes and then Temper's eyes could have been a little less redundant and still manage to convey the information that each was privy to.