[polishgenius]

Marathoned.


Gonna copy-paste my thoughts from elsewhere coz I can't be bothered to write it all out again, lol:



To begin with, the writing is very sharp on a dialogue level. The series is balancing a lot of different tones and that could easily be a mess but the writing and delivery of the lines is just really good.

The acting too - I don't know if the role was written for Knightley but it might as well have been, it fits her like a glove, and everyone else slots in around her nicely.

But I think really stood out to me and had me hooked is, going back to that balancing of tones: a trope that I like when I see it is when you see one character essentially operating on the rules of a different genre or story type to the rest of the story (often the villain, but also people like Omar in the Wire). Usually it's one or two characters, but here it's almost like every faction is from a different type of spy or crime show. Again, that could be a mess, and it certainly gets daft, but the writing is strong so it works.



I don't watch as much spy tv as a lot of people - coz I really don't watch all that much tv at all - so it might be a bit more familiar to others, but I think it stands out reasonably well, without being massively innovative. Which it isn't really aiming for anyway.




tl:dr - it balances a lot of different tones and plot ideas via some really well-written good old British snark.

[Abyss]

Abyss, on 06 December 2024 - 05:15 PM, said:

polishgenius, on 05 December 2024 - 09:36 PM, said:

Started Netflix's new spy thing, Black Doves today.


About to finish Netflix's new spy thing, Black Doves.

sux / DNF or rivetted / marathon'd?

polishgenius, on 06 December 2024 - 08:54 PM, said:

Marathoned.
...tl:dr - it balances a lot of different tones and plot ideas via some really well-written good old British snark.

Watched ep1 last night, very enjoyed, in for the run, tnx!

[QuickTidal]

Abyss, on 10 December 2024 - 05:13 PM, said:

Abyss, on 06 December 2024 - 05:15 PM, said:

polishgenius, on 05 December 2024 - 09:36 PM, said:

Started Netflix's new spy thing, Black Doves today.


About to finish Netflix's new spy thing, Black Doves.

sux / DNF or rivetted / marathon'd?

polishgenius, on 06 December 2024 - 08:54 PM, said:

Marathoned.
...tl:dr - it balances a lot of different tones and plot ideas via some really well-written good old British snark.

Watched ep1 last night, very enjoyed, in for the run, tnx!

Don't know what you all are talking about...

....Googles....

Keira Knightley? As a spy? Okay, you have my interest....

Ben Wishaw, Sarah Lancashire, Andrew Koji

Oh now you have my attention!

Going to binge...wish me luck.

[Whisperzzzzzzz]

My fiancee and I just binged it. Great fun! Sam is bad at his job though.

[Abyss]

Whisperzzzzzzz, on 10 December 2024 - 06:24 PM, said:

My fiancee and I just binged it. Great fun! Sam is bad at his job though.

He's very good at the snark tho'.

[QuickTidal]

SECRET LEVEL on Prime.


It's good, but it's not great...most of the episodes are SO dark it's as if the GOT crew shot them...Animation that's this dark normally doesn't impress me...

The best of the lot is EASILY the Warhammer 40k Episode "AND THEY SHALL KNOW FEAR"....it's fucking exquisite...but I mean it's super insider baseball for 40k fans rather than casuals...

like

Spoiler

Is a casual viewer going to get how super typical it is that a small group Primaris Space Marines would totally drag a big metal box across their whole ass mission, just to pop it open in from of the enemy and let their blind psyker/Astropath out to run interference for them? Or how the Sorcerer of Tzeentch gets into their minds and infects many of them with Chaos? Like yeah they would get the gist, but it feels that much more compelling to a 40k nerd.


Also, can we talk about how well they translated the rather large and beefy space marines moving super fast? Like I don't think that's a thing that gets translated often...that these can be like tanks, but when they want to they can MOVE.

Give me a whole ass 40k show about Titus and Co.

The rest of the eps were fine to middling...but this holds absolutely no candles to LOVE, DEATH, & ROBOTS...which as far as animated anthologies go, is the tippy top.


YMMV but aide from the 40k ep, the other two I liked were the ARMORED CORE ep and the SIFU one.

[Primateus]

Honestly, QT, I'm surprised you didn't go for the Unreal Tournament: Xan episode. It would seem to me that it's something right up your alley.

I'd also highlight the Pac-Man episode as a fresh, very fresh, and new take on Pac-Man.

I have yet to see the new half of episodes, so at the moment I would agree that And They Shall Know No Fear is the best episode of the lot.

Crossfire could have been good, but it just seemed a bit too on the nose. Armored Core was fine and Sifu was good, but not really my style. The D&D episode was also good, but I felt that it went from serious stakes to world-ending serious stakes in the blink of an eye.

[QuickTidal]

Primateus, on 18 December 2024 - 02:16 PM, said:

Honestly, QT, I'm surprised you didn't go for the Unreal Tournament: Xan episode. It would seem to me that it's something right up your alley.

I'd also highlight the Pac-Man episode as a fresh, very fresh, and new take on Pac-Man.

I have yet to see the new half of episodes, so at the moment I would agree that And They Shall Know No Fear is the best episode of the lot.

Crossfire could have been good, but it just seemed a bit too on the nose. Armored Core was fine and Sifu was good, but not really my style. The D&D episode was also good, but I felt that it went from serious stakes to world-ending serious stakes in the blink of an eye.

I agree the Pacman episode was pretty good, I loved making him into this cloaked nomad...that worked well....but again too damned dark. Same for the D&D ep.

Also I didn't realize the new eps dropped for the back half. Will have to check them out.

[Macros]

Tried House.

Did about 13/14 episodes
Egh, don't get the hype, if I want a snarky doc I'll watch Dr Cox on scrubs.

House episode writing
Open on random, they collapse
Into hospital, mis diagnosis
They go into a seizure
Further mis diagnosis
This person is going to die
Revelation of seemingly irrelevant information.
House diagnoses, cures.

Repeat