[Kilava]

Rikkter, on 21 August 2019 - 11:46 PM, said:

Kilava, on 21 August 2019 - 11:24 PM, said:

Rikkter, on 21 August 2019 - 11:20 PM, said:

If I had to go by gut, I’d have to say Shelly and Gait are killers. Other than day 1, Gait hasn’t gotten any heat, and Shelly sure got prickly over the idea of voting Gait as a no show. Second, Gait was really keen on trying to push my lynch as soon as I took off prior to timeout. This makes me think that I must have hit a little too close to home.

There was some talk about Shelly day 2, but Galayn managed to make day 2 all about him.

I’d be fine with either a Shelly or Gait lynch.

So I gather that you're definitely not buying the Shel reveal?

Yeah it feels wrong.

yeah with Gamelon's vote for me, I feel like he's trying to steer away from a Shel vote - I think the likelihood of them being partners quite high at this point.

[Gamelon]

Kilava, on 21 August 2019 - 11:45 PM, said:

Gamelon, on 21 August 2019 - 11:40 PM, said:

Here are the options for partners as far as I see them based on my reread and today’s play:

Gait-Kilava
Gamelon-Sheltatha
Kilava-Sheltatha
Kilava-Rikkter

Can anyone make a case for a different combination? You can see why I would choose to go for Kilava. And this is on top of their playstyle, which is what set the alarms ringing for me in the first place. I’m getting to the very end of my time here today.

Vote Kilava

Love you too Gam. Oh I thought we were waiting to create a consensus to vote? Guess not.

You are funny. ‘Why aren’t you voting then Gam?!’ ‘Hey, what the hell do you think you’re doing by voting, Gam?!’

I said I’d be out way before timeout. I’ve left my vote off as long as possible. I did hope to see Ven and Sheltatha pop up and hear their thoughts, but unfortunately not. And that’s it from me. Night all.

[Gait]

Gamelon, on 21 August 2019 - 11:40 PM, said:

Here are the options for partners as far as I see them based on my reread and today’s play:

Gait-Kilava
Gamelon-Sheltatha
Kilava-Sheltatha
Kilava-Rikkter

Can anyone make a case for a different combination? You can see why I would choose to go for Kilava. And this is on top of their playstyle, which is what set the alarms ringing for me in the first place. I’m getting to the very end of my time here today.

Vote Kilava

So removing yourself from the equation, this just boils down to Kilava + someone else right?

[Sheltatha Lore]

I still think we should aim for a consensus. I actually think highest possibility of scum, in order, are:

Gait
Gamelon
Rikkter
Kilava

Given that those are the only 4 I would vote for and the only four where scum could lie from where I stand, that is my preference and order.

[Gait]

Night Gam

[Kilava]

Gamelon, on 21 August 2019 - 11:48 PM, said:

Kilava, on 21 August 2019 - 11:45 PM, said:

Gamelon, on 21 August 2019 - 11:40 PM, said:

Here are the options for partners as far as I see them based on my reread and today’s play:

Gait-Kilava
Gamelon-Sheltatha
Kilava-Sheltatha
Kilava-Rikkter

Can anyone make a case for a different combination? You can see why I would choose to go for Kilava. And this is on top of their playstyle, which is what set the alarms ringing for me in the first place. I’m getting to the very end of my time here today.

Vote Kilava

Love you too Gam. Oh I thought we were waiting to create a consensus to vote? Guess not.

You are funny. ‘Why aren’t you voting then Gam?!’ ‘Hey, what the hell do you think you’re doing by voting, Gam?!’

I said I’d be out way before timeout. I’ve left my vote off as long as possible. I did hope to see Ven and Sheltatha pop up and hear their thoughts, but unfortunately not. And that’s it from me. Night all.

You're the one that's funny, jumping down my throat and then doing the very thing you accuse me of, but fair enough, if you gotta vote you gotta vote.

[Rikkter]

Vote Sheltatha

[Gait]

My #1 preference is Shel clearly, then after that Gam.

Amongst the other two I prefer Rikkter's more straightforward posts but really it's ehhhhh.

[Kilava]

The way to reach a consensus is to list who we most likely see as the killer pair, and then vote for whoever we have most in common. For me it's 1. Gamelon and 2.Shel
That way we're most likely to hit scum with a lynch. If we go by what we've listed so far, it's Gamelon. That is, if everyone agrees that is a sound way of thinking.

[Rikkter]

Gamelon is lower in my list. For me it’s 1) Shelly 2) Gait 3) Kilava or Gamelon

[Gait]

There's also quite a gap in the spacing of mine. Like, #1 weighs considerably more. Just listing these things doesn't convey it well.

[Sheltatha Lore]

I would go for Gam before Kilava. It is not looking like Gait is going anywhere.

[Kilava]

Ah okay, then Shel is who it's leaning towards now, I believe? We need Ven to help out here.

[Sheltatha Lore]

yup, because I will not self vote.

[Kilava]

Gait, on 22 August 2019 - 12:13 AM, said:

There's also quite a gap in the spacing of mine. Like, #1 weighs considerably more. Just listing these things doesn't convey it well.

Yeah, for me it's Gamelon that is very much higher on the list.

[Kilava]

Sheltatha Lore, on 22 August 2019 - 12:18 AM, said:

yup, because I will not self vote.

I understand that, but since there are two killers, theoretically we'd have a better chance of hitting scum if do it like this.

[Sheltatha Lore]

Sure, if you are that confident I am scum. But don't you find it odd that I accept getting lynched on day 3 and don't actively stick around to find out? And do you really think me clever enough (with all my fuckups) to orchestrate revealing as a potato not a tomato? Sure, I am scummy in appearance, but the cost of lynching me is loss of the only remaining roled town. If you hit scum with someone else, I could stop the remaining scum and we could come out on top.

I know that 2 of you will give no credence to my words, which makes it that much harder. But at least give Ven lead of the thread as the only truly agreed upon townie here. And Ven believes me.

[Kilava]

Sheltatha Lore, on 22 August 2019 - 12:35 AM, said:

Sure, if you are that confident I am scum. But don't you find it odd that I accept getting lynched on day 3 and don't actively stick around to find out? And do you really think me clever enough (with all my fuckups) to orchestrate revealing as a potato not a tomato? Sure, I am scummy in appearance, but the cost of lynching me is loss of the only remaining roled town. If you hit scum with someone else, I could stop the remaining scum and we could come out on top.

I know that 2 of you will give no credence to my words, which makes it that much harder. But at least give Ven lead of the thread as the only truly agreed upon townie here. And Ven believes me.

Yeah, Gamelon is my number 1 choice. If enough of us can agree he's most likely one of the two scum, then we have something to go on, you know?

[Rikkter]

IGait is much higher in my books. He has managed to well to stay off everyone’s radar ergo scum.

[Kilava]

Rikkter, on 22 August 2019 - 12:43 AM, said:

IGait is much higher in my books. He has managed to well to stay off everyone’s radar ergo scum.

You don't think Gamelon is likely one of the scum? The way he's been attacking without any actual arguments scream scum to me.