[Gamelon]

We have gotten literally zero scum CFs, so that means that either the Evil Coroner is still in the game, or Fanderay was indeed scum and yesterday was never DDay to begin with... If Fanderay was indeed scum, then Serc's healer reveal is likely true, so it comes down to either Alkend or Okaros as scum for me.

I know you all are probably going to gang up on me, but that's where I stand. My vote goes to either Okaros or Alkend today, methinks. And if Serc ended up being full of shit this entire time, he has played a great game.

[Serc]

Just got in from playing badminton.

[Alkend]

Gamelon, on 29 March 2017 - 09:18 PM, said:

vote Alkend

Being vote 1 on D-day. That's strike 2.

I swear, you're making me think I'm wrong about Serc. And I really don't like that.

[Gamelon]

Please, if anything the fact that yesterday wasn't, in fact, D-Day makes the idea that you've been the killer all along even more likely.

I removed as I'd like to hear from others, but I'm pretty confident it's gotta be you at this point.

[Alkend]

Gamelon, on 29 March 2017 - 09:23 PM, said:

We have gotten literally zero scum CFs, so that means that either the Evil Coroner is still in the game, or Fanderay was indeed scum and yesterday was never DDay to begin with... If Fanderay was indeed scum, then Serc's healer reveal is likely true, so it comes down to either Alkend or Okaros as scum for me.

I know you all are probably going to gang up on me, but that's where I stand. My vote goes to either Okaros or Alkend today, methinks. And if Serc ended up being full of shit this entire time, he has played a great game.

No he hasn't. If he's scum, the rest of you just stubbornly avoided doing the obvious.

[Alkend]

Gamelon, on 29 March 2017 - 09:24 PM, said:

Please, if anything the fact that yesterday wasn't, in fact, D-Day makes the idea that you've been the killer all along even more likely.

I removed as I'd like to hear from others, but I'm pretty confident it's gotta be you at this point.

Whereas I'm really regretting my prayer that you get vigged Night 1 didn't come true.

Because I'm going back to your "too dumb to be scum ™" Day 1 performance, and I'm not sure I should've been so dismissive of it.

[Gamelon]

The thing I keep coming back to is that we have gotten literally ZERO scum CFs.

So what, the Evil Coroner was promoted to killer, but kept his evil coroner powers?

If there were 2 scum left in the game, the game would be over today. So that means that the killer is definitely still around, and we have to have an evil coroner somewhere? Why else have ONLY inno CFs?

[Alkend]

The only thing that's preventing me voting Game right now is the fact that it's based on gut, and I always play diametrically opposite to what my gut says.

In terms of pure logic, Serc remains the most suspicious player. But Game's racking up points quick.

[Serc]

First I want to hear from Okaros as he is only play I trust right now.

It all goes back to the Fanderay CF, I am thinking that he was the killer and the evil coroner manipulated the CF.

Then was promoted as per OP.

In fact that is why no night kill night one makes sense. Fanderay was planning his reveal and had to withhold to give it credit.

[Gamelon]

So it says in the promotable Coroner role description that if he gets promoted to killer, then he can't affect CFs anymore, but CFs will still be posted.

So that means that Fanderay HAS to have been scum. It's the only thing that makes sense. So Fanderay was the killer. Lynched on Day 2, CFs as Inno because Evil Coroner is still evil coroner. Evil coroner gets promoted, then becomes killer, and all CFs since are inno.

So yeah, if Fanderay's reveal was fake, that puts a lot more points in the Serc is most likely actually our healer. Which means that either Okaros or Alkend are scum.

If it's Okaros, I'll be very disappointed. If it's Alkend he's done a very good job at staying in my blind spot, but I have no choice but to turn on him today.

vote Alkend


Looks like it's going to end up being between me and Alkend. Serc and Okaros to decide. I have little hope for my life, and thus a town win at this point.

[Serc]

Like I said. I am going to sleep on it. Okaros I will read what you have to say in the morning.

[Alkend]

Serc, on 29 March 2017 - 09:31 PM, said:

First I want to hear from Okaros as he is only play I trust right now.

It all goes back to the Fanderay CF, I am thinking that he was the killer and the evil coroner manipulated the CF.

Then was promoted as per OP.

In fact that is why no night kill night one makes sense. Fanderay was planning his reveal and had to withhold to give it credit.

In order for that to work, we'd have to start out with only an evil coroner to begin with.

Once again, you are leading us far away from the most plausible explanation.

This is why we really should've lynched you instead of Mockra. Then my conscience would be clean in walking for Game on the off chance you are actually telling the truth.

[Gamelon]

Yeah, I'm outta here for the day too. Look forward to seeing which way you guys end up voting!

I hope you all vote with me and win this for town, but this game has been all kinds of fun either way!

[Gamelon]

Alkend, on 29 March 2017 - 09:35 PM, said:

Serc, on 29 March 2017 - 09:31 PM, said:

First I want to hear from Okaros as he is only play I trust right now.

It all goes back to the Fanderay CF, I am thinking that he was the killer and the evil coroner manipulated the CF.

Then was promoted as per OP.

In fact that is why no night kill night one makes sense. Fanderay was planning his reveal and had to withhold to give it credit.

In order for that to work, we'd have to start out with only an evil coroner to begin with.

Once again, you are leading us far away from the most plausible explanation.

This is why we really should've lynched you instead of Mockra. Then my conscience would be clean in walking for Game on the off chance you are actually telling the truth.

What are you talking about?

[Serc]

Alkend, on 29 March 2017 - 09:35 PM, said:

Serc, on 29 March 2017 - 09:31 PM, said:

First I want to hear from Okaros as he is only play I trust right now.

It all goes back to the Fanderay CF, I am thinking that he was the killer and the evil coroner manipulated the CF.

Then was promoted as per OP.

In fact that is why no night kill night one makes sense. Fanderay was planning his reveal and had to withhold to give it credit.

In order for that to work, we'd have to start out with only an evil coroner to begin with.

Once again, you are leading us far away from the most plausible explanation.

This is why we really should've lynched you instead of Mockra. Then my conscience would be clean in walking for Game on the off chance you are actually telling the truth.

What? How so?

Why does Gamelon get it but you don't? That goes in his favour.
You're trying to play off the CF manipulation. I am saying Fand was the pyscho killer dude and one of you three was the promotable coroner. Wtf.

[Alkend]

Evil Coroner only acts if town Coroner is dead or guarded.

So, for Serc's hypothesis to be plausible, there'd have to be NO town coroner to start with. I.E., town would have started with no credible CF to begin with.

[Gamelon]

Alkend, on 29 March 2017 - 09:39 PM, said:

Evil Coroner only acts if town Coroner is dead or guarded.

So, for Serc's hypothesis to be plausible, there'd have to be NO town coroner to start with. I.E., town would have started with no credible CF to begin with.

Which is completely plausible based on the role descriptions and OPs.

[Alkend]

Yeah, but how is it balanced?

[Serc]

Alkend, on 29 March 2017 - 09:39 PM, said:

Evil Coroner only acts if town Coroner is dead or guarded.

So, for Serc's hypothesis to be plausible, there'd have to be NO town coroner to start with. I.E., town would have started with no credible CF to begin with.

Which is believable as I could have stopped a kill on more than one occasion.

He would have to put extra roles to keep us guessing.

Or am I just thinking my role is more important than it is?

[Gamelon]

2 scum vs 7 town, one of which is a healer. Pretty balanced as far as I'm concerned.