Help
OK I'm back. The timing of day end seemed off to me, so I had to skim back to when we resolved night, which happened early because everyone had gotten their actions in. Let me get caught up and I'll post my thoughts.
Mafia 91.5 - Mean Girls
#382
Liosan 
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 92
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 07 September 2012 - 11:38 AM
Korvalain, on 07 September 2012 - 09:22 AM, said:
That last bit is to mean that I am not just attacking Lio I am making a case which involves all three of them and Galain's dodgy play. Maybe Lio is caught up in it all and that is Galain's plan. So I am going for Karosis as others have also found him scummy.
Korv, which questions have I not answered yet?
I answered what you are saying about a supposed 'spat' and the use of the word 'one'. Is there something else???
#383
Liosan
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 92
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 07 September 2012 - 11:46 AM
It looks like we have just a few hours, and it looks like we are all going off in different directions. Osseric's continued lack of content is bothering me, and I'm starting to think it's all bullshit. How can anyone sign up to play a Mafia game and have NOTHING to contribute. All we've gotten is 'This post gives me the heebie jeebies scoob' and fuck that. I'll be damned if I'm going to let a killer hide behind that kind of playing.
vote Osseric
vote Osseric
#384
Karosis
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 9
- Joined: 17-June 09
Posted 07 September 2012 - 11:52 AM
I agree with you that Osserics lack of content is annoying and even if he is innocent he's not really helping us, but at the moment id rather go for Emurlahn or Spite just because they've both had actual posts that have made me go "wow thats weird" (paraphrasing 
). Ofc if it doesn't look like either of those is viable i will gladly change my vote before i head off to work in the interest of actually getting a lynch.
). Ofc if it doesn't look like either of those is viable i will gladly change my vote before i head off to work in the interest of actually getting a lynch.
#387
Korvalain
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 10
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 07 September 2012 - 12:07 PM
Liosan, on 07 September 2012 - 11:38 AM, said:
Korvalain, on 07 September 2012 - 09:22 AM, said:
That last bit is to mean that I am not just attacking Lio I am making a case which involves all three of them and Galain's dodgy play. Maybe Lio is caught up in it all and that is Galain's plan. So I am going for Karosis as others have also found him scummy.
Korv, which questions have I not answered yet?
I answered what you are saying about a supposed 'spat' and the use of the word 'one'. Is there something else???
Lio are you deliberately fucking with me here?
What are your thoughts about Karosis? About Galain?
Why pluck a target out of thin air (Osseric) when there isn't much time and viable targets are out there?
You didn't answer or reply to most of my posts earlier on, Galain did it for you.
Yes Olar and Karosis had an argument day one.
Karosis also pointed a finger at you which you responded in kind to. Now i'd like your take on the Karosis/Galain case I have just made but then you just ignore the whole post and reply to the little one liner at the end.
#388
Osseric
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 5
- Joined: 17-June 09
Posted 07 September 2012 - 12:12 PM
ok, I'm back for this morning
If my math is right, there's 2 hours left but there doesn't seem to have been much activity since I left. Where is everybody? The weekend hasn't started yet as far as I know.
I'm already getting tired of the low poster BS coming my way, so feel free to lynch me off. Keep going for the lowest poster each time, then all the killer(s) has to do is stay in the lead, pile on the easy target and before you know it, D-day will arrive.
Quit wasting time
Because nothing seems any more plausible than my theory about OE & Karosis
Vote Karosis
I will be around until end of day to move my vote if needed
If my math is right, there's 2 hours left but there doesn't seem to have been much activity since I left. Where is everybody? The weekend hasn't started yet as far as I know.
I'm already getting tired of the low poster BS coming my way, so feel free to lynch me off. Keep going for the lowest poster each time, then all the killer(s) has to do is stay in the lead, pile on the easy target and before you know it, D-day will arrive.
Quit wasting time
Because nothing seems any more plausible than my theory about OE & Karosis
Vote Karosis
I will be around until end of day to move my vote if needed
#390
Liosan
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 92
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 07 September 2012 - 12:38 PM
Korvalain, on 07 September 2012 - 12:07 PM, said:
Liosan, on 07 September 2012 - 11:38 AM, said:
Korvalain, on 07 September 2012 - 09:22 AM, said:
That last bit is to mean that I am not just attacking Lio I am making a case which involves all three of them and Galain's dodgy play. Maybe Lio is caught up in it all and that is Galain's plan. So I am going for Karosis as others have also found him scummy.
Korv, which questions have I not answered yet?
I answered what you are saying about a supposed 'spat' and the use of the word 'one'. Is there something else???
Lio are you deliberately fucking with me here?
What are your thoughts about Karosis? About Galain?
Why pluck a target out of thin air (Osseric) when there isn't much time and viable targets are out there?
You didn't answer or reply to most of my posts earlier on, Galain did it for you.
Yes Olar and Karosis had an argument day one.
Karosis also pointed a finger at you which you responded in kind to. Now i'd like your take on the Karosis/Galain case I have just made but then you just ignore the whole post and reply to the little one liner at the end.
FFS...
1) I answered that I am not a killer or a symp with them or anyone else. I haven't formed any strong opinions on either of them. Karosis and OE's spat could have been changed, Galain's removing of votes seemed odd.
2) I think Osseric is just playing an act. Was he the REAL one you were trying to protect Day 1? You seemed very sensitive about his post padding.
3) Bullshit. I replied to multiple posts of yours, you are ignoring my comments when I've made them. Just go masturbate and think of me. It's what you really want.
4) I did respond to you about the Karosis comment and you ignored it.
#392
Galain
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 6
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 07 September 2012 - 12:46 PM
Korvalain, on 07 September 2012 - 09:12 AM, said:
I want to go over my thoughts again. I am almost certain that Galain is at the very least our symp. Now I am not sure if he is fake symping Liosan here or if he is doing it on purpose. Galain keeps discrediting me by calling me suspicious. So I take that with a pinch of salt. Now I can not be sure he is symping Liosan because I am attacking Liosan or because he wants me to focus on Liosan rather than Karosis. Well here are a couple of his posts that stand out to me. The first is his potential signal to Karosis. The others are his defence of Liosan. What I also find strange is that Liosan is ignoring my accusations and hasn't answered my questions. Why would a town player do that?
It's Fener. There is observable behavior. He's always the baddest of scum.
Remove Vote
The problem with this idea is that if you don't lynch day one then you go into day 2 with very little extra information to work with and one less innocent to get the lynch
Read much?
That's on d day.
Also, the new Fener is Karosis, if I remember correctly. He's been scum every time more than fener, recently.
Vote Karosis
just do spelling fixes only, and make sure to note what you edit.
And Spite! I'm glad you're posting. You better not turn into AnsibleSpite scum like a few games ago and low post your way to victory.
Remove Vote
Vote Spite
His vote on Karosis is because "Karosis is the new Fener". He admits later that this is a joke vote. A joke vote that doesn't stick, in the middle of a huge post when the final vote goes elsewhere? The killers usually do not know their symp so the symp has to either let them know by signalling or by defending them and making other players seem less than what they are. Galain is scummy as hell.
Admits? Of course it was a joke vote. And go back a few games. I'm pretty sure I've made the exact same joke vote in multiple games, especially around the newb/vet game area. Karosis really need get the scum draw a ton.
Gonna reply to this post rather than the other one to avoid more confusion.
Of the three you analyzed, i'm very suspicious of emurlahn, but i'm somewhat hesitant to follow up on a day 1 target without closer analyzation. I will do so once i'm off the phone, will be a while. I want to take a look at some of the players i am most suspicious of in relation to the lynch train.
The signaling bit is lame. Joke voting. The equivalent of a fener vote, then a vote against spite just to piss him off after he called my fener vote useless and annoying or something of the sort. When i'm at a computer i catch up all in 1 post, to avoid post padding. So those easily could have been seperate posts.
Be back in a while.
He would go for an Emurlahn lynch but doesn't see anything in Lio or Karosis. He is downplaying his signal, calling it joke voting. Then what is the point, why Karosis rather than anyone else? When have we said Karosis is the new Fener? How many games has he come up scum?
I want to lynch Lio and Karosis as much as I want to lynch, say, Meanas. I find Emurlahn's posts suspicious. All the suspicion layed against the other two is based on me, and I know I'm not scum, so I don't hold any particular hate for them. Now, if I reread and there's actually something valid there, I can reconsider. But at the moment, your accusations have been pretty baseless in my mind.
Why do you think Galain has to justify his observation here?
Because of the exact thing you just did, meany face. In my posting from my phone, i was the first to vote him. But in reality i was third or fourth, so it looked like i was jumping on the bandwagon. I dont expect you to believe me, really, but its true. I refuse to lie about things related to real life in mafia. Being on my phone makes me have to post as i catch up because i cant copy paste.
See this is the post that makes me feel like he was listening to Liosan and voting for the same reason. I point out that I wasn't symping Mockra and Lio said that maybe someone would find it as symping. Then Galain comes on and uses it as his excuse to vote.
I've explained this. Just as you explained that you weren't symping Mockra. You dont believe me, why do you expect me to believe you?
What? Near the start of the game you didn't. That spat between you and karosis early on can be seen as distancing cause there wasn't anything substantial in it. The way Galain is behaving points fingers at both you and Karosis for me. That post about one arguing about me symping Mockra was off, then Galain uses it as his reasoning for a Mockra vote AND then he says he didn't read what others had said, "he promises".
Yes Emur, Osseric, and Meanas have scummy play. They do. I am more convinced of you though. I probably won't get the numbers to lynch you because you are a voice of reason, you are one of the higher posters etc.
Cut it out dude. The post made it look very likely that you were symping mockra. Just because you explain something, doesn't make suspicion vanish. I don't really find you that scummy atm, because mockra came up innocent, but this kind of logic is poor imo.
Right Lio here says I have a gripe about no content when that isn't it at all. Yet Rather than continue discussion with him Galain comes on and defends Lio. As you all know we have no information regarding other players or alts, so how is it that Galain is defending Lio? This is what makes me think he is the symp. I just cannot figure out if he is symping Lio or Karosis or both.
Because I 100% agree with his position on lynchnig Mockra! Hell, I came to the same conclusion myself before even reading his posts. There is no discussion. Your "discussion" is "I explained it, you should take my word as law, you shouldn't have pursued something that legitimately looked like symping."
Okay, so the internet is out. I'll do my best here, but gonna struggle doing multiple quotes. So I'll just pick this one. It doesn't do anything to make Emurlahn less suspicious, really. He was third (fourth, I think, since I removed) on the train. But along with him at the beginniner are Liosan, Fener, and myself. Liosan is under attack from Korvalain. I don't agree with Korvalain at all, -but- I need to go back and reread his posts just to make sure I'm not missing anything, or going omgus because he accused me. Fener is dead. I am under attack from Korvalain. So of the train starters, he is attacking the two not dead. But he also omits himself, who comes in at 5th on an 8 person train (again, leaving my vote in there). 5th is the tipping point, where the train passes half way. I see some merit in the accusation that Korvalain got Mockra lynched on purpose.
We really have to choose here, Korvalain and Emurlahn are both suspicious, but on polar opposite sides. And they aren't the only two choices, just the two more suspicious in my mind. Korv's insistence that we lynch Emurlahn earlier is actually my primary reason for not voting him. Hm.
Anyway, hopefully the internet will be fixed after work. Will be reading from phone when I can.
See his use of under attack. What is this? He also conveniently has left Karosis out of each of his posts.
I am concerned with Galain's play. I think we have a killer in at least one of Lio or Karosis and my gut is saying it is the latter.
Remove Vote
Vote Karosis
Galain, on 04 September 2012 - 11:40 PM, said:
Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 08:42 PM, said:
Alright - that makes no sense to me. Ages ago, I managed to lynch a fellow innocent on day one in a serious game (not sure you lot know what that means, tbph) due to a random, fun vote on day one operating on the principle that it didn't matter anyway, might as well be a complete ass. Never again. There has to be a reason. There are compelling math reasons to lynch every day so I'm down with that but I don't start off with stupidity, I'd prefer to have a proper adult reason based on observable behaviour. There's no reason, especially with 36 hour days, that we can't have a real conversation that is related to the situation at hand. I'm off to bed soon, so please don't lynch me before I have a chance to respond
It's Fener. There is observable behavior. He's always the baddest of scum.
Remove Vote
Karosis, on 04 September 2012 - 08:46 PM, said:
Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 08:42 PM, said:
Alright - that makes no sense to me. Ages ago, I managed to lynch a fellow innocent on day one in a serious game (not sure you lot know what that means, tbph) due to a random, fun vote on day one operating on the principle that it didn't matter anyway, might as well be a complete ass. Never again. There has to be a reason. There are compelling math reasons to lynch every day so I'm down with that but I don't start off with stupidity, I'd prefer to have a proper adult reason based on observable behaviour. There's no reason, especially with 36 hour days, that we can't have a real conversation that is related to the situation at hand. I'm off to bed soon, so please don't lynch me before I have a chance to respond 
The problem with this idea is that if you don't lynch day one then you go into day 2 with very little extra information to work with and one less innocent to get the lynch
Read much?
Karosis, on 04 September 2012 - 08:59 PM, said:
I vaguely remember seeing somewhere that depending on whether you have an odd or even number of players left that its sometimes better to go to night and wait for the next day. I cant remember which way round it was though as this was a while back
That's on d day.
Also, the new Fener is Karosis, if I remember correctly. He's been scum every time more than fener, recently.
Vote Karosis
Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 09:23 PM, said:
Oh, FFS, you are clever while seeming like the opposite aren't you?
slight bits? As in the enitirety of my post? Read it again - you missed everything, not just the bit about math reasons. What part of it were you responding to, ffs?
You're Brujah aren't you? NO, don't answer.
if editing posts is illegal in 'new malazan mafia' than kill me now because that is not on.
slight bits? As in the enitirety of my post? Read it again - you missed everything, not just the bit about math reasons. What part of it were you responding to, ffs?
You're Brujah aren't you? NO, don't answer.
if editing posts is illegal in 'new malazan mafia' than kill me now because that is not on.
just do spelling fixes only, and make sure to note what you edit.
Spite, on 04 September 2012 - 09:45 PM, said:
I'm here. And I see we have had an argument this early in the first day. interesting.
And Spite! I'm glad you're posting. You better not turn into AnsibleSpite scum like a few games ago and low post your way to victory.
Spite, on 04 September 2012 - 09:58 PM, said:
I noticed the ETA btw. And I completely agree that what he said was foolish but it does not mean OMGUS comment this early in the game. (I would have jumped and made one such comment too, but really. it does not mean you should do it as well.)
That vote for Fener. It made me cry. useless voting in... worst way possible.
That vote for Fener. It made me cry. useless voting in... worst way possible.
Remove Vote
Vote Spite
His vote on Karosis is because "Karosis is the new Fener". He admits later that this is a joke vote. A joke vote that doesn't stick, in the middle of a huge post when the final vote goes elsewhere? The killers usually do not know their symp so the symp has to either let them know by signalling or by defending them and making other players seem less than what they are. Galain is scummy as hell.
Admits? Of course it was a joke vote. And go back a few games. I'm pretty sure I've made the exact same joke vote in multiple games, especially around the newb/vet game area. Karosis really need get the scum draw a ton.
Galain, on 06 September 2012 - 12:52 PM, said:
Korvalain, on 06 September 2012 - 10:41 AM, said:
Again apologies. None of the above are votes from me they are quotes from galain and Meanas.
So in conclusion for the above post. Lio looks suspect for being a low poster, increasing his posts and going after low posters. Emur and Meanas look suspect for providing no content. Galain looks suspect for flash voting Karosis and movi9ng onto Spite.
Still getting caught up.
So in conclusion for the above post. Lio looks suspect for being a low poster, increasing his posts and going after low posters. Emur and Meanas look suspect for providing no content. Galain looks suspect for flash voting Karosis and movi9ng onto Spite.
Still getting caught up.
Gonna reply to this post rather than the other one to avoid more confusion.
Of the three you analyzed, i'm very suspicious of emurlahn, but i'm somewhat hesitant to follow up on a day 1 target without closer analyzation. I will do so once i'm off the phone, will be a while. I want to take a look at some of the players i am most suspicious of in relation to the lynch train.
The signaling bit is lame. Joke voting. The equivalent of a fener vote, then a vote against spite just to piss him off after he called my fener vote useless and annoying or something of the sort. When i'm at a computer i catch up all in 1 post, to avoid post padding. So those easily could have been seperate posts.
Be back in a while.
He would go for an Emurlahn lynch but doesn't see anything in Lio or Karosis. He is downplaying his signal, calling it joke voting. Then what is the point, why Karosis rather than anyone else? When have we said Karosis is the new Fener? How many games has he come up scum?
I want to lynch Lio and Karosis as much as I want to lynch, say, Meanas. I find Emurlahn's posts suspicious. All the suspicion layed against the other two is based on me, and I know I'm not scum, so I don't hold any particular hate for them. Now, if I reread and there's actually something valid there, I can reconsider. But at the moment, your accusations have been pretty baseless in my mind.
Galain, on 06 September 2012 - 01:21 PM, said:
Korvalain, on 06 September 2012 - 11:20 AM, said:
Galain, on 05 September 2012 - 01:58 PM, said:
LOL. Caught up to my post,i promise that was before i read that other people caught the same thing i did.
I don't think Emurlahn would be a bad bet, but i'm definitely more interested in the mockra/korvalain connection at the moment.
I don't think Emurlahn would be a bad bet, but i'm definitely more interested in the mockra/korvalain connection at the moment.
Why do you think Galain has to justify his observation here?
Because of the exact thing you just did, meany face. In my posting from my phone, i was the first to vote him. But in reality i was third or fourth, so it looked like i was jumping on the bandwagon. I dont expect you to believe me, really, but its true. I refuse to lie about things related to real life in mafia. Being on my phone makes me have to post as i catch up because i cant copy paste.
See this is the post that makes me feel like he was listening to Liosan and voting for the same reason. I point out that I wasn't symping Mockra and Lio said that maybe someone would find it as symping. Then Galain comes on and uses it as his excuse to vote.
I've explained this. Just as you explained that you weren't symping Mockra. You dont believe me, why do you expect me to believe you?
Galain, on 06 September 2012 - 01:28 PM, said:
Korvalain, on 06 September 2012 - 11:32 AM, said:
Liosan, on 06 September 2012 - 11:26 AM, said:
And back. Just waking up.
Korv, your whole gripe on me about not posting enough 'content' is bullshit. Is it ok with you if I take a few hours here and there during the game to get some work done or god forbid sleep?
I did however like your case on emur. Without the benefit of coffee yet, Emur and Osseric both are standing out for me for their lack of content, and Sorrit for defending low posters. Someone else pointed out Meanas who has managed to totally stay under the radar. Anyway, I need more caffeine, and want to look at the players again.
Korv, your whole gripe on me about not posting enough 'content' is bullshit. Is it ok with you if I take a few hours here and there during the game to get some work done or god forbid sleep?
I did however like your case on emur. Without the benefit of coffee yet, Emur and Osseric both are standing out for me for their lack of content, and Sorrit for defending low posters. Someone else pointed out Meanas who has managed to totally stay under the radar. Anyway, I need more caffeine, and want to look at the players again.
What? Near the start of the game you didn't. That spat between you and karosis early on can be seen as distancing cause there wasn't anything substantial in it. The way Galain is behaving points fingers at both you and Karosis for me. That post about one arguing about me symping Mockra was off, then Galain uses it as his reasoning for a Mockra vote AND then he says he didn't read what others had said, "he promises".
Yes Emur, Osseric, and Meanas have scummy play. They do. I am more convinced of you though. I probably won't get the numbers to lynch you because you are a voice of reason, you are one of the higher posters etc.
Cut it out dude. The post made it look very likely that you were symping mockra. Just because you explain something, doesn't make suspicion vanish. I don't really find you that scummy atm, because mockra came up innocent, but this kind of logic is poor imo.
Right Lio here says I have a gripe about no content when that isn't it at all. Yet Rather than continue discussion with him Galain comes on and defends Lio. As you all know we have no information regarding other players or alts, so how is it that Galain is defending Lio? This is what makes me think he is the symp. I just cannot figure out if he is symping Lio or Karosis or both.
Because I 100% agree with his position on lynchnig Mockra! Hell, I came to the same conclusion myself before even reading his posts. There is no discussion. Your "discussion" is "I explained it, you should take my word as law, you shouldn't have pursued something that legitimately looked like symping."
Galain, on 06 September 2012 - 03:04 PM, said:
Path-Shaper, on 06 September 2012 - 01:38 AM, said:
14 Players still alive: D'riss, Emurlahn, Fener, Galain, Karosis, Korbas, Korvalain, Liosan, Meanas, Mockra, Olar Ethil, Osseric, Sorrit, Spite
8 votes to lynch, 7 votes to go to night.
1 vote for D'riss: Meanas
8 votes for Mockra: Liosan, Fener, Emurlahn, Korvalain, Spite, Olar Ethil, Karosis, D'riss
Players not voted: Galain, Korbas, Mockra, Osseric, Sorrit
Kristen knew everything about the Plastics. Her favourite fact was that they liked Varsity Blues. But one day she made the mistake of wearing her hair in a ponytail.... for the second time in a week! No Plastic would ever do that!
Mockra is lynched. She was Kristen Hadley and Gwyn Ap Nubb.
It is now night.
8 votes to lynch, 7 votes to go to night.
1 vote for D'riss: Meanas
8 votes for Mockra: Liosan, Fener, Emurlahn, Korvalain, Spite, Olar Ethil, Karosis, D'riss
Players not voted: Galain, Korbas, Mockra, Osseric, Sorrit
Kristen knew everything about the Plastics. Her favourite fact was that they liked Varsity Blues. But one day she made the mistake of wearing her hair in a ponytail.... for the second time in a week! No Plastic would ever do that!
Mockra is lynched. She was Kristen Hadley and Gwyn Ap Nubb.
It is now night.
Okay, so the internet is out. I'll do my best here, but gonna struggle doing multiple quotes. So I'll just pick this one. It doesn't do anything to make Emurlahn less suspicious, really. He was third (fourth, I think, since I removed) on the train. But along with him at the beginniner are Liosan, Fener, and myself. Liosan is under attack from Korvalain. I don't agree with Korvalain at all, -but- I need to go back and reread his posts just to make sure I'm not missing anything, or going omgus because he accused me. Fener is dead. I am under attack from Korvalain. So of the train starters, he is attacking the two not dead. But he also omits himself, who comes in at 5th on an 8 person train (again, leaving my vote in there). 5th is the tipping point, where the train passes half way. I see some merit in the accusation that Korvalain got Mockra lynched on purpose.
We really have to choose here, Korvalain and Emurlahn are both suspicious, but on polar opposite sides. And they aren't the only two choices, just the two more suspicious in my mind. Korv's insistence that we lynch Emurlahn earlier is actually my primary reason for not voting him. Hm.
Anyway, hopefully the internet will be fixed after work. Will be reading from phone when I can.
See his use of under attack. What is this? He also conveniently has left Karosis out of each of his posts.
I am concerned with Galain's play. I think we have a killer in at least one of Lio or Karosis and my gut is saying it is the latter.
Remove Vote
Vote Karosis
As to the last comment, I left Karosis out because he wasn't part of my analysis.. I was looking at the first half of the train (eventually including the 5th person, so just after the half). Karosis was near the end. I haven't felt the need to defend Karosis because I don't have the same agreement I do with Liosan. Your selective reading is absolutely mind boggling.
I answered this as best I could. I'm interested to see what the others think about this. I know it's a large post, which guarantees that 90% of players won't read it, but I hope people do. I need opinions on whether Korvy is a misguided towny or a sneaky scum. Or, hell, if he's right, if that's what you guys pull from this.
#393
Olar Ethil
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 1
- Joined: 14-April 09
Posted 07 September 2012 - 12:47 PM
Sorrit, on 07 September 2012 - 01:27 AM, said:
Osseric, on 07 September 2012 - 01:22 AM, said:
Galain, on 06 September 2012 - 11:04 PM, said:
Olar Ethil, on 06 September 2012 - 08:32 PM, said:
Osseric, on 06 September 2012 - 08:18 PM, said:
actually I have been reading the previous 324 posts trying to do just that, but this pesky occupation has other plans
I can't shake the feeling that somehow the spat with OE & Karo was somehow fake-ish, or staged. It just doesn't feel authentic. Someone (Spite?) said it could have been distancing, and that could be true. Perhaps making some distance between partners while creating a history that will keep them from seeming to avoid interaction, standard killer partner strategy.
I can't shake the feeling that somehow the spat with OE & Karo was somehow fake-ish, or staged. It just doesn't feel authentic. Someone (Spite?) said it could have been distancing, and that could be true. Perhaps making some distance between partners while creating a history that will keep them from seeming to avoid interaction, standard killer partner strategy.
Interesting that this is your first mention of this idea that Karosis and I were faking our little scrap and you claim an inability to 'shake the feeling', implying that you've had this feeling for some time now - why not mention it before? Anyway, that's cool. You know what? I agree with you - I'm pretty sure that one of me and Karosis is on the wrong side, perhaps even both of us. Chasing low posters has gotten boring as well. So, I heard that it's now possible to vote for oneself yes? I'll be more than happy to vote for myself if needed but for now, I'm going to
vote Karosis
I can't make sense of this post. Am I the only one?
There is something weird here, maybe the tone
@Olar Ethil - Somebody else mentioned it and it didn't get much attention, it was more significant as I reread it. So I did mention it. You go on to say you and Karosis might be scum? Is this supposed to be a reminder that everyone is suspect? I don't know if you're invoking a strategem beyond my experience, but your next three sentences are at odds with your general play so far. I will agree chasing low posters can be boring. Why even bring up the self-vote, as I think you should not do so unless it was required for victory, and is certainly not in the line of conversation. Please explain
I think the tone here is bleeding sarcasm...
This. (bolds and underline mine)
I haven't had any time today - trying to work out a vote count, brb
#394
Galain
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 6
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 07 September 2012 - 12:54 PM
Osseric, on 07 September 2012 - 12:12 PM, said:
ok, I'm back for this morning
If my math is right, there's 2 hours left but there doesn't seem to have been much activity since I left. Where is everybody? The weekend hasn't started yet as far as I know.
I'm already getting tired of the low poster BS coming my way, so feel free to lynch me off. Keep going for the lowest poster each time, then all the killer(s) has to do is stay in the lead, pile on the easy target and before you know it, D-day will arrive.
Quit wasting time
Because nothing seems any more plausible than my theory about OE & Karosis
Vote Karosis
I will be around until end of day to move my vote if needed
If my math is right, there's 2 hours left but there doesn't seem to have been much activity since I left. Where is everybody? The weekend hasn't started yet as far as I know.
I'm already getting tired of the low poster BS coming my way, so feel free to lynch me off. Keep going for the lowest poster each time, then all the killer(s) has to do is stay in the lead, pile on the easy target and before you know it, D-day will arrive.
Quit wasting time
Because nothing seems any more plausible than my theory about OE & Karosis
Vote Karosis
I will be around until end of day to move my vote if needed
Everyone is stuck in bad day 1 cases, imo. BUT I don't agree with straight lynching a low poster, either.
I'm not sure the time left, and I need to finish writing my paper before class. So I'm going to vote and then check back in to see if I should change.
Remove Vote
Vote Korvalain
He was the 5th on the Mockra train, and really pushed it over the edge. He was reason most of us voted Mockra, yet hopped on early enough to apply momentum. I'm thinking he must have been something bad. I think either a killer trying to save his own ass with the push on top Osseric (and then Mockra), or a symp fake symping Mockra. My internet was out yesterday, so I couldn't form a case full of quotes and whatnot, but hopefully people will se my reasoning here.
Back in a bit, hopefully. Really will finish this paper first though, so if I miss timeout, I'm sorry.
#395
Olar Ethil
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 1
- Joined: 14-April 09
Posted 07 September 2012 - 12:55 PM
Unofficial vote count
It is Day 2. I dunno how much time is left
12 Players still alive: D'riss, Emurlahn, Galain, Karosis, Korbas, Korvalain, Liosan, Meanas, Olar Ethil, Osseric, Sorrit, Spite
7 votes to lynch, 6 votes to go to night.
3 vote Karosis: Olar Ethil, Korvalain, Osseric
2 vote Osseric: Spite, Liosan
1 vote Korvalain: Galain
1 vote Spite: Karosis
Players not voted: D'riss, Emurlahn, Korbas, Meanas, Sorrit
edit: cross-posted with Galain, updated vote count
It is Day 2. I dunno how much time is left
12 Players still alive: D'riss, Emurlahn, Galain, Karosis, Korbas, Korvalain, Liosan, Meanas, Olar Ethil, Osseric, Sorrit, Spite
7 votes to lynch, 6 votes to go to night.
3 vote Karosis: Olar Ethil, Korvalain, Osseric
2 vote Osseric: Spite, Liosan
1 vote Korvalain: Galain
1 vote Spite: Karosis
Players not voted: D'riss, Emurlahn, Korbas, Meanas, Sorrit
edit: cross-posted with Galain, updated vote count
This post has been edited by Olar Ethil: 07 September 2012 - 12:59 PM
#396
Olar Ethil
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 1
- Joined: 14-April 09
Posted 07 September 2012 - 01:07 PM
I'll be checking the thread for roughly the next hour and a half, but I don't have the leisure to concentrate on making a case or arguing at the moment. If we truly have so little time left, it's all about pickign someone to lynch at this point. As I'm already on the largest lynch train, I'll stay on karosis until and unless someone else gets more votes. I'll try to catch up as best I can, but currently, I'm willing to lynch Karosis, Osseric or Korvalain but Spite not so much. This mat change upon reread but it would be comical if we fail to lynch and not in a good way so please people, let's pile on somebody.
#397
Korvalain
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 10
- Joined: 05-October 08
Posted 07 September 2012 - 01:10 PM
I'm one of the killers. Go for me or a symp, go figure. That is how i've been playing. No one seems to agree with me. Get my CF see that I am innocent, take Karosis down. Or not. I don't care. Town are stupid. We need to lynch everyday but it looks like that won't happen.
#399
Olar Ethil
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 1
- Joined: 14-April 09
Posted 07 September 2012 - 01:16 PM
Meanas, on 07 September 2012 - 01:57 AM, said:
Olar Ethil, on 06 September 2012 - 08:32 PM, said:
Osseric, on 06 September 2012 - 08:18 PM, said:
actually I have been reading the previous 324 posts trying to do just that, but this pesky occupation has other plans
I can't shake the feeling that somehow the spat with OE & Karo was somehow fake-ish, or staged. It just doesn't feel authentic. Someone (Spite?) said it could have been distancing, and that could be true. Perhaps making some distance between partners while creating a history that will keep them from seeming to avoid interaction, standard killer partner strategy.
I can't shake the feeling that somehow the spat with OE & Karo was somehow fake-ish, or staged. It just doesn't feel authentic. Someone (Spite?) said it could have been distancing, and that could be true. Perhaps making some distance between partners while creating a history that will keep them from seeming to avoid interaction, standard killer partner strategy.
Interesting that this is your first mention of this idea that Karosis and I were faking our little scrap and you claim an inability to 'shake the feeling', implying that you've had this feeling for some time now - why not mention it before? Anyway, that's cool. You know what? I agree with you - I'm pretty sure that one of me and Karosis is on the wrong side, perhaps even both of us. Chasing low posters has gotten boring as well. So, I heard that it's now possible to vote for oneself yes? I'll be more than happy to vote for myself if needed but for now, I'm going to
vote Karosis
Wait, are you just voting Karo because somebody put you two together?
I'll look back to see if you have any other reasons, but I would appreciate it if you list all of your reasons for voting when you vote.
My suspicions of karosis were well-documented in our scrap at the beginning of the game - I don't mind restating them a bit later, just catching up now.
Also, I was not suggesting that both Karosis and I might be scum, i was suggesting that we both might be on the 'wrong side' as in the side that is going to lose because we innocents can't seem to get our shit together. I bet the killers win a lot more than they should around here ...
#400
Olar Ethil
- Recruit
-
- Group: Game alts
- Posts: 1
- Joined: 14-April 09
Posted 07 September 2012 - 01:17 PM
Spite, on 07 September 2012 - 02:11 AM, said:
Sorrit, on 07 September 2012 - 02:05 AM, said:
Spite, on 07 September 2012 - 01:39 AM, said:
Remove vote
Vote Osseric
He is next in line.
Vote Osseric
He is next in line.
Seriously? This is the laziest of lazy play. Are you actually going to join in the discussion, proovide something useful and look for scum? Or is your crusade against low posters so all-consuming that you will follow it regardless of whether you actually think that person is scum or not?
Don't you ever learn ?
low posting is not good for town. If we are gonna lynch town (which is the most likely since its only day 2) I prefer we kill a useless town. not someone vocal and useful .
I have my suspicions but I don't have anything to back them up so right now motivating low posters is my priority .
1000x this!
