[Olar Ethil]

Oh, FFS, you are clever while seeming like the opposite aren't you?

slight bits? As in the enitirety of my post? Read it again - you missed everything, not just the bit about math reasons. What part of it were you responding to, ffs?

You're Brujah aren't you? NO, don't answer.

if editing posts is illegal in 'new malazan mafia' than kill me now because that is not on.

[D'riss]

Hello all, quick post before I go make some dinner.

First off - role speculation, I'm of the opinion that role speculation in itself doesn't overtly benefit the killers, I feel that focusing on it gives them a handy place to hide for a day or two and since this is supposed to be M&P I feel its pointless.
Unless I misread the signup we didn't get the numbers Blend wanted for his "twist"
I'll go back and double check but I thinkg this game is a straight up killers vs innos.
On the CF front, since this is a theme'd game I'm running on the assumption that the revealed name will be as good as a cf for us as in the film the mean girls were a group of 3 super bitches, so at a pitch if we're running 2 killers 1 symp, theres our 3 right there, with the stupid girl being the symp?

I'll not vote Olar for this because its been a while for him and like I said, I don't think speculation hurts us. But we can't be holding out for a heroe finder to save us, this will be good old fashioned mob justice the whole way

[Karosis]

Ok as noone seems to be around il talk to myself .

Looking back the thread so far. Not a lot stands out (obviously since we've even had a page yet), but i find myself suspicious of Liosan and Fener.Liosan's only posts were saying he was here and then calling olar a killer for discussing roles. This just a bit like shooting at an easy target that people might decide to jump on while staying low so people wont notice you. Fener made mention of the thread being dead , and called on people to arrive and start discussion then disappeared as soon as people did, this just seems a bit weird.

At the moment im more suspicious of Liosan but obviously its pretty hard to judge someone whose only made 2 posts so i will wait to see what else he does.

[Karosis]

Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 08:42 PM, said:

Alright - that makes no sense to me. Ages ago, I managed to lynch a fellow innocent on day one in a serious game (not sure you lot know what that means, tbph) due to a random, fun vote on day one operating on the principle that it didn't matter anyway, might as well be a complete ass. Never again. There has to be a reason. There are compelling math reasons to lynch every day so I'm down with that but I don't start off with stupidity, I'd prefer to have a proper adult reason based on observable behaviour. There's no reason, especially with 36 hour days, that we can't have a real conversation that is related to the situation at hand. I'm off to bed soon, so please don't lynch me before I have a chance to respond

ok read your post without the bold bit it very much comes off as someone whose been burned by accidently lynching an innocent and would rather have no lynch than possibly get it wrong. This seemed weird so i responded.

About the editing thing its so that people cant edit away incriminating stuff.
Also as id already read your post before you edited it i didnt noticed the extra part till a while later when i was rereading the thread.

[Karosis]

So D'riss do you have any ideas or comments on my speculation?

[Karosis]

There are 4 people viewing but noone is talking to me

Im going to go take out these contacts as they're making it hard to concentrate.

[Spite]

I'm here. And I see we have had an argument this early in the first day. interesting.

[Spite]

Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 09:23 PM, said:

Oh, FFS, you are clever while seeming like the opposite aren't you?

slight bits? As in the enitirety of my post? Read it again - you missed everything, not just the bit about math reasons. What part of it were you responding to, ffs?

You're Brujah aren't you? NO, don't answer.

if editing posts is illegal in 'new malazan mafia' than kill me now because that is not on.

Calm down bro , nothing's happened. just some reading incomprehension.
Its not like he has done anything.

[Olar Ethil]

Karosis, on 04 September 2012 - 09:31 PM, said:

Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 08:42 PM, said:

Alright - that makes no sense to me. Ages ago, I managed to lynch a fellow innocent on day one in a serious game (not sure you lot know what that means, tbph) due to a random, fun vote on day one operating on the principle that it didn't matter anyway, might as well be a complete ass. Never again. There has to be a reason. There are compelling math reasons to lynch every day so I'm down with that but I don't start off with stupidity, I'd prefer to have a proper adult reason based on observable behaviour. There's no reason, especially with 36 hour days, that we can't have a real conversation that is related to the situation at hand. I'm off to bed soon, so please don't lynch me before I have a chance to respond

ok read your post without the bold bit it very much comes off as someone whose been burned by accidently lynching an innocent and would rather have no lynch than possibly get it wrong. This seemed weird so i responded.

About the editing thing its so that people cant edit away incriminating stuff.
Also as id already read your post before you edited it i didnt noticed the extra part till a while later when i was rereading the thread.

hmmm, I would have thought that in this arena, more than most others, it is of the utmost importance to understand fully the missive you are responding to, call me a traditionalist! And that's the nicest way I can say that.

and do not fucking suggest that my edit was nefarious, it was an ETA with all the additional content after that. The original text was not altered. Mods, please advise re: edits - if this fool is right, then I need to know.

my vote stands because I cannot imagine how this person could be useful and he just might be a killer trying to hide in plain sight.

[Fener]

Sorry I'm around, but I got caught up in a surprise meeting all afternoon. On my cell now for a bit.

the editing thing was last game only, not a general rule afaik

[Spite]

Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 09:53 PM, said:

Karosis, on 04 September 2012 - 09:31 PM, said:

Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 08:42 PM, said:

Alright - that makes no sense to me. Ages ago, I managed to lynch a fellow innocent on day one in a serious game (not sure you lot know what that means, tbph) due to a random, fun vote on day one operating on the principle that it didn't matter anyway, might as well be a complete ass. Never again. There has to be a reason. There are compelling math reasons to lynch every day so I'm down with that but I don't start off with stupidity, I'd prefer to have a proper adult reason based on observable behaviour. There's no reason, especially with 36 hour days, that we can't have a real conversation that is related to the situation at hand. I'm off to bed soon, so please don't lynch me before I have a chance to respond

ok read your post without the bold bit it very much comes off as someone whose been burned by accidently lynching an innocent and would rather have no lynch than possibly get it wrong. This seemed weird so i responded.

About the editing thing its so that people cant edit away incriminating stuff.
Also as id already read your post before you edited it i didnt noticed the extra part till a while later when i was rereading the thread.

hmmm, I would have thought that in this arena, more than most others, it is of the utmost importance to understand fully the missive you are responding to, call me a traditionalist! And that's the nicest way I can say that.

and do not fucking suggest that my edit was nefarious, it was an ETA with all the additional content after that. The original text was not altered. Mods, please advise re: edits - if this fool is right, then I need to know.

my vote stands because I cannot imagine how this person could be useful and he just might be a killer trying to hide in plain sight.

I noticed the ETA btw. And I completely agree that what he said was foolish but it does not mean OMGUS comment this early in the game. (I would have jumped and made one such comment too, but really. it does not mean you should do it as well.)
That vote for Fener. It made me cry. useless voting in... worst way possible.

[Karosis]

Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 09:53 PM, said:

Karosis, on 04 September 2012 - 09:31 PM, said:

Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 08:42 PM, said:

Alright - that makes no sense to me. Ages ago, I managed to lynch a fellow innocent on day one in a serious game (not sure you lot know what that means, tbph) due to a random, fun vote on day one operating on the principle that it didn't matter anyway, might as well be a complete ass. Never again. There has to be a reason. There are compelling math reasons to lynch every day so I'm down with that but I don't start off with stupidity, I'd prefer to have a proper adult reason based on observable behaviour. There's no reason, especially with 36 hour days, that we can't have a real conversation that is related to the situation at hand. I'm off to bed soon, so please don't lynch me before I have a chance to respond

ok read your post without the bold bit it very much comes off as someone whose been burned by accidently lynching an innocent and would rather have no lynch than possibly get it wrong. This seemed weird so i responded.

About the editing thing its so that people cant edit away incriminating stuff.
Also as id already read your post before you edited it i didnt noticed the extra part till a while later when i was rereading the thread.

hmmm, I would have thought that in this arena, more than most others, it is of the utmost importance to understand fully the missive you are responding to, call me a traditionalist! And that's the nicest way I can say that.

and do not fucking suggest that my edit was nefarious, it was an ETA with all the additional content after that. The original text was not altered. Mods, please advise re: edits - if this fool is right, then I need to know.

my vote stands because I cannot imagine how this person could be useful and he just might be a killer trying to hide in plain sight.

Ok i wasnt suggesting your edit was nefarious i was just pointing out that last time i played i think editting wasnt allowed and it was better to just add another post.

Also i notice you're not commenting on how easy the mistake was to make and are instead trying to continue to attack my character rather than anything ive actually done.

[Karosis]

Spite, on 04 September 2012 - 09:58 PM, said:

Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 09:53 PM, said:

Karosis, on 04 September 2012 - 09:31 PM, said:

Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 08:42 PM, said:

Alright - that makes no sense to me. Ages ago, I managed to lynch a fellow innocent on day one in a serious game (not sure you lot know what that means, tbph) due to a random, fun vote on day one operating on the principle that it didn't matter anyway, might as well be a complete ass. Never again. There has to be a reason. There are compelling math reasons to lynch every day so I'm down with that but I don't start off with stupidity, I'd prefer to have a proper adult reason based on observable behaviour. There's no reason, especially with 36 hour days, that we can't have a real conversation that is related to the situation at hand. I'm off to bed soon, so please don't lynch me before I have a chance to respond

ok read your post without the bold bit it very much comes off as someone whose been burned by accidently lynching an innocent and would rather have no lynch than possibly get it wrong. This seemed weird so i responded.

About the editing thing its so that people cant edit away incriminating stuff.
Also as id already read your post before you edited it i didnt noticed the extra part till a while later when i was rereading the thread.

hmmm, I would have thought that in this arena, more than most others, it is of the utmost importance to understand fully the missive you are responding to, call me a traditionalist! And that's the nicest way I can say that.

and do not fucking suggest that my edit was nefarious, it was an ETA with all the additional content after that. The original text was not altered. Mods, please advise re: edits - if this fool is right, then I need to know.

my vote stands because I cannot imagine how this person could be useful and he just might be a killer trying to hide in plain sight.

I noticed the ETA btw. And I completely agree that what he said was foolish but it does not mean OMGUS comment this early in the game. (I would have jumped and made one such comment too, but really. it does not mean you should do it as well.)
That vote for Fener. It made me cry. useless voting in... worst way possible.

I thought it was th edone thing to vote for Fener if nothing else presented itself? Or have things changed a bit since my day?

[Olar Ethil]

Karosis, on 04 September 2012 - 09:59 PM, said:

Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 09:53 PM, said:

Karosis, on 04 September 2012 - 09:31 PM, said:

Olar Ethil, on 04 September 2012 - 08:42 PM, said:

Alright - that makes no sense to me. Ages ago, I managed to lynch a fellow innocent on day one in a serious game (not sure you lot know what that means, tbph) due to a random, fun vote on day one operating on the principle that it didn't matter anyway, might as well be a complete ass. Never again. There has to be a reason. There are compelling math reasons to lynch every day so I'm down with that but I don't start off with stupidity, I'd prefer to have a proper adult reason based on observable behaviour. There's no reason, especially with 36 hour days, that we can't have a real conversation that is related to the situation at hand. I'm off to bed soon, so please don't lynch me before I have a chance to respond

ok read your post without the bold bit it very much comes off as someone whose been burned by accidently lynching an innocent and would rather have no lynch than possibly get it wrong. This seemed weird so i responded.

About the editing thing its so that people cant edit away incriminating stuff.
Also as id already read your post before you edited it i didnt noticed the extra part till a while later when i was rereading the thread.

hmmm, I would have thought that in this arena, more than most others, it is of the utmost importance to understand fully the missive you are responding to, call me a traditionalist! And that's the nicest way I can say that.

and do not fucking suggest that my edit was nefarious, it was an ETA with all the additional content after that. The original text was not altered. Mods, please advise re: edits - if this fool is right, then I need to know.

my vote stands because I cannot imagine how this person could be useful and he just might be a killer trying to hide in plain sight.

Ok i wasnt suggesting your edit was nefarious i was just pointing out that last time i played i think editting wasnt allowed and it was better to just add another post.

Also i notice you're not commenting on how easy the mistake was to make and are instead trying to continue to attack my character rather than anything ive actually done.

how easy what mistake was to make?

Completely failing to read and understand a sentence written in your native language? I mean really? In mafia? I'm supposed to have patience for this? Please enlighten me on how easy it was for you to make that mistake.

As far as attacking your character 'rather than anything ive actually done', I believe I've managed to do both - to be fair, the attacks on your character were just for style points and to see if I could get a rise out of you but your obvious errors are egregious enough to justify my hostility.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I've listed everything that you've done that I find 'wrong', in detail.

So, again, I dunno. With you, I'm starting to think ' aliens are among us', no offense

English. Do you speak it?

[Liosan]

OK. I'm back.

[Karosis]

There it is again. Can you speak like a civilised person?, its hard to take you seriously with the way you're talking.

Ok im really quite uncomfortably warm with my laptop on my lap, i had contacts in which were starting to itch, ive had a few cans of cider and i was making dinner. Missing half a sentence in your block is an easy mistake to make, especially as it doesnt make what i said any less relevant.

In fact i think you're getting way to worked up about this.

Vote Olar Ethil


Because he's reacting very much like i attacked him on thread when all i did was a slight comment. This seems very oversensitive, like he might have something to hide.

[Liosan]

Karosis, on 04 September 2012 - 09:26 PM, said:

Ok as noone seems to be around il talk to myself .

Looking back the thread so far. Not a lot stands out (obviously since we've even had a page yet), but i find myself suspicious of Liosan and Fener.Liosan's only posts were saying he was here and then calling olar a killer for discussing roles. This just a bit like shooting at an easy target that people might decide to jump on while staying low so people wont notice you. Fener made mention of the thread being dead , and called on people to arrive and start discussion then disappeared as soon as people did, this just seems a bit weird.

At the moment im more suspicious of Liosan but obviously its pretty hard to judge someone whose only made 2 posts so i will wait to see what else he does.

Ssooooo I'm suspicious for posting, then getting busy and having to be away for awhile? Well fuck me.

Now, as far as OE goes, I just thought it was a little odd that he came in speculating without secks or spam first! WTF?! What have we become if we cannot warm up a game with some lewd comments and joke votes first?

[Karosis]

Liosan, on 04 September 2012 - 10:30 PM, said:

Karosis, on 04 September 2012 - 09:26 PM, said:

Ok as noone seems to be around il talk to myself .

Looking back the thread so far. Not a lot stands out (obviously since we've even had a page yet), but i find myself suspicious of Liosan and Fener.Liosan's only posts were saying he was here and then calling olar a killer for discussing roles. This just a bit like shooting at an easy target that people might decide to jump on while staying low so people wont notice you. Fener made mention of the thread being dead , and called on people to arrive and start discussion then disappeared as soon as people did, this just seems a bit weird.

At the moment im more suspicious of Liosan but obviously its pretty hard to judge someone whose only made 2 posts so i will wait to see what else he does.

Ssooooo I'm suspicious for posting, then getting busy and having to be away for awhile? Well fuck me.

Now, as far as OE goes, I just thought it was a little odd that he came in speculating without secks or spam first! WTF?! What have we become if we cannot warm up a game with some lewd comments and joke votes first?

It wasnt that you had to run off its that you're post was literally "im here" then ooh hes a killer. As i said it was only 2 posts so just enough to get me watching you rather than enough to make me sure you're scum.

[Emurlahn]

Good evening, everyone. I just got home from work, and I had to sit in traffic forever. Anyway, it looks like you guys have dived right in, and the game is running along at full speed. This looks like it might turn out to be a very entertaining game.

[Karosis]

Emurlahn, on 04 September 2012 - 10:37 PM, said:

Good evening, everyone. I just got home from work, and I had to sit in traffic forever. Anyway, it looks like you guys have dived right in, and the game is running along at full speed. This looks like it might turn out to be a very entertaining game.

I'm glad you are entertained