[Tennes]

Kalse are you around?

[Tellan]

I say we lynch SL, as I believe this may be a play by Kalse to clear him. I find him the more suspicious of the pair anyway.

remove vote

Vote Sheltatha Lore

[Kalse]

I will switch to shelly if you prefer

I waited because ive not been able to get online till now for a conversation

[Sorrit]

Exactly my thoughts. Too bad he already gave his defense for his late timing. He's saying he thought he had to find one more. As per his post. He also said he thought each killer got a NK, earlier. So maybe he's new to both finder and mafia, or he's Grief v 2.0.

[Sorrit]

I say we lynch Kalse. If he's the finder, we win. It's not D- day.

[Tellan]

 Tennes, on 31 July 2012 - 10:29 AM, said:

 Tellan, on 31 July 2012 - 10:27 AM, said:

Up. 6am. Fuckoff. I thought day ended at 1pm today for me. I might fall back asleep, but I will vote.

Is this Kalse's only post today? Very poorly timed reveal, and with this he has essentially set up the next 2 day's lynches because I'm not sure we can get one today.

If he found both scum, why would he wait until today to post it?

I thought Tennes was the symp, but maybe just dumb town (no offense meant, I'm too tired to be offensive). You did break one of the standard rules of mafia today, and I don't see why anyone but a symp would do so. (I'll send it to sh if I remember)

That said, this reveal by Kalse seems odd. He found both scum in 2 nights? And told us at the last minute?

a modkill rule? or a mafia 101 rule?

101

[Sorrit]

Fuck that, lynch Kalse. If he's scum, one scum down. We clear ducks. MAYBE. If finder, we win.

Best Case Scenario.

remove vote
Vote Kalse

[Tellan]

 Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 10:30 AM, said:

Exactly my thoughts. Too bad he already gave his defense for his late timing. He's saying he thought he had to find one more. As per his post. He also said he thought each killer got a NK, earlier. So maybe he's new to both finder and mafia, or he's Grief v 2.0.

Where does he say he thought he had to find one more?

[Tennes]

 Tellan, on 31 July 2012 - 10:32 AM, said:

 Tennes, on 31 July 2012 - 10:29 AM, said:

 Tellan, on 31 July 2012 - 10:27 AM, said:

Up. 6am. Fuckoff. I thought day ended at 1pm today for me. I might fall back asleep, but I will vote.

Is this Kalse's only post today? Very poorly timed reveal, and with this he has essentially set up the next 2 day's lynches because I'm not sure we can get one today.

If he found both scum, why would he wait until today to post it?

I thought Tennes was the symp, but maybe just dumb town (no offense meant, I'm too tired to be offensive). You did break one of the standard rules of mafia today, and I don't see why anyone but a symp would do so. (I'll send it to sh if I remember)

That said, this reveal by Kalse seems odd. He found both scum in 2 nights? And told us at the last minute?

a modkill rule? or a mafia 101 rule?

101

i'm intrigued. I din't know I had. Enlighten me (see what i did there?)

Remove Vote

Vote Sheltatha Lore

[Tennes]

Sorrit are you the symp?

[Sorrit]

 Kalse, on 31 July 2012 - 10:00 AM, said:

we cant afford another mistake


I really hope we have the time and players to get a lynch

I am a finder, and ive found that shelly and kaschan are both scum

you really cant trust those ducks.

we are a little closer to the end that I had hoped and im probably going to get NKed for this but Its best I tell you what I have found

vote kaschan

have to get one of them

This would imply that he doesn't know the game is over. Do symps CF scum to a finder? Never been a finder.

[Tellan]

 Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 10:34 AM, said:

Fuck that, lynch Kalse. If he's scum, one scum down. We clear ducks. MAYBE. If finder, we win.

Best Case Scenario.

remove vote
Vote Kalse

But killers wouldn't do this, right? So he'll come up inno regardless, finder or symp.

If he really is the finder, the killers will eliminate him tonight. I still say SL is the better choice.

[Kalse]

if you lynch me, you give scum an extra night to kill, so you will lose two town

its not d-day but its not far off.

Im expecting to be NK'd today anyway now ive revealed.


remove vote

Vote Sheltatha Lore
we need to pick one of the ducks and lynch them tonight. I dont care which one you choose. lynching the finder to see if he is lying? sounds like one hell of a dodgy idea to me

[Sorrit]

 Tennes, on 31 July 2012 - 10:35 AM, said:

Sorrit are you the symp?

Are you guys retarded or something?

If he CFs finder WE WIN. GAME OVER. WE LYNCH SL AND KASCHAN NEXT TWO DAYS.

If he's fucking with us, we lynched another innocent. Then we have to kill Rashan and Tellan. May have only covered for one. Still don't know the other.

How is lynching Kalse Not Our best plan? We fucking win if he's finder.

Scum POSSIBLE 3, town 6 tomorow. We can easily kill SL and then Kaschan.

If he's lying and we kill an Inno, its scum 3 possibly, and town 6, but we still have to lynch Rashan and tellan.

And if there not BOTH scum, they fucked us.

Figure it out, dips.

Lynch Kalse.

[Tennes]

I don't think we'll get the numbers.

[Tellan]

 Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 10:36 AM, said:

 Kalse, on 31 July 2012 - 10:00 AM, said:

we cant afford another mistake


I really hope we have the time and players to get a lynch

I am a finder, and ive found that shelly and kaschan are both scum

you really cant trust those ducks.

we are a little closer to the end that I had hoped and im probably going to get NKed for this but Its best I tell you what I have found

vote kaschan

have to get one of them

This would imply that he doesn't know the game is over. Do symps CF scum to a finder? Never been a finder.

CF implies coroner find, which would be upon death. But anyway, finders find symps as town, just as they CF.

[Sorrit]

If he CFs finder, we win. If he CFs Inno, he's obvious symp. We kill Rashan and tellan, only one MIGHT be, not two, we find last killer.

No scenario is better for us that lynching Kalse.

[Kalse]

I did my first find on shelly on night one, the main reason Ive been pro lio and atrahal and defended them before was mainly because shelly seamed to be casting suspicions at those two, or they were saying bad things about shelly.

decided to do my second find on kaschan because I thought he was just cruising through, and just keeping far to quiet. But mainly becuase he was also a duck,

crap reason to do it but it came through for us in the end

[Tennes]

 Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 10:41 AM, said:

 Tennes, on 31 July 2012 - 10:35 AM, said:

Sorrit are you the symp?

Are you guys retarded or something?

If he CFs finder WE WIN. GAME OVER. WE LYNCH SL AND KASCHAN NEXT TWO DAYS.

If he's fucking with us, we lynched another innocent. Then we have to kill Rashan and Tellan. May have only covered for one. Still don't know the other.

How is lynching Kalse Not Our best plan? We fucking win if he's finder.

Scum POSSIBLE 3, town 6 tomorow. We can easily kill SL and then Kaschan.

If he's lying and we kill an Inno, its scum 3 possibly, and town 6, but we still have to lynch Rashan and tellan.

And if there not BOTH scum, they fucked us.

Figure it out, dips.

Lynch Kalse.

your a dick OR you don't understand.

A symp would come up innocent. A finder would come up innocent. The only way to test if kalse is innocent is by lynching one of the revealed players. IF they come up scum he is a finder. IF they come up innocent he is a symp.

[Tellan]

 Sorrit, on 31 July 2012 - 10:41 AM, said:

 Tennes, on 31 July 2012 - 10:35 AM, said:

Sorrit are you the symp?

Are you guys retarded or something?

If he CFs finder WE WIN. GAME OVER. WE LYNCH SL AND KASCHAN NEXT TWO DAYS.

If he's fucking with us, we lynched another innocent. Then we have to kill Rashan and Tellan. May have only covered for one. Still don't know the other.

How is lynching Kalse Not Our best plan? We fucking win if he's finder.

Scum POSSIBLE 3, town 6 tomorow. We can easily kill SL and then Kaschan.

If he's lying and we kill an Inno, its scum 3 possibly, and town 6, but we still have to lynch Rashan and tellan.

And if there not BOTH scum, they fucked us.

Figure it out, dips.

Lynch Kalse.

I see where you're coming from, but in this game, the Coroner Find only includes faction, right? I don't remember seeing 'Roled Innocent' in any of the CFs so far. So there's no guarantee Kalse will CF as finder, he might just CF as town. And in that way, we couldn't tell if he was finder or symp.

This is why I'm voting SL.