[Tellan]

Nah, I just woke up.

Multiple alts would clearly escape the tmdi of this game. Eloth probably just got confused with an alt from a previous game.

[Tennes]

I'll wait to see what town have to say about it all.

[Tellan]

Lol. Good lord.

[Eloth]

I just got confused qouting .

will edit.



Edit: now I'm confused with you . what are you talking about?

This post has been edited by Eloth: 30 July 2012 - 01:52 PM

[Telas]

Catching up. Awfully quiet with the weekend break, though I didn't exactly help on that count.

[Telas]

Here's something interesting:

Rashan, Liosan, and Kaschan all have fewer or as many posts as Emurlahn, who was lynched on day 1. Nice job guys!


D'riss initiated the switch to Lio. He CFed town, and operating on the assumption that scum wouldn't kill their symp, we can trust what he was saying before his death.
Tellan switches as well, noting he will switch back to osseric to get a lynch.
Tennes switches to Lio, after thinking the osseric push was derailing from Tellan.
Kaschan asks what the case is on Lio, Shelly tells him to look back a couple pages, he then votes Osseric without explanation.
Osseric votes Lio--he's inno, but it appeared more that the just wanted to save his own skin.
Kalse switches to Lio--puts Lio at L-2.
Atrahal arrives and moves his previous vote on Tellan to Osseric, no explanation.
---Both are L-2 at this stage.
Tellan moves his vote from Lio to Osseric, effectively securing an Osseric lynch.
D'riss switches to hammer.

I think that since D'riss and Osseric both CFed inno, the apparent conclusion is that the people they focused on (Tellan, Liosan) are scum. I disagree. This is very wifom, but I think that scum is trying to point us in their direction--keeping in mind that the cases against both weren't particularly strong, though Tellan's blow-up didn't exactly help. The more interesting thing are the two big swing votes toward Osseric: Kaschan and Atrahal. Neither of them explained their votes, neither of them participated aside from voting, and both disappeared as soon as the lynch took place--infact, Atrahal claimed he preferred a Tellan lynch over an Osseric lynch, but the way I understand it Tellan / Liosan are implicated together, so he shouldn't have had any qualms taking Lio to L-1. Instead, he and Kaschan brought Lio and Osseric to the same number of votes (L-2) rather than securing the lynch on Lio together. Furthermore, both have kept their distance from one another, and both have generally avoided suspicion.

I'm going to do a reread of these two and see what I can come up with.

[Telas]

Also, there were 4 anons viewing just 5 minutes ago. Now just me. Hi lurkers!

[Tennes]

I'm here. Got the screen open whilst I work

[Eloth]

Anyone here?

[Kaschan]

looks like everybody is having a busy Monday


@Eloth - I'm around for the next few minutes

[Tellan]

Tennes, on 30 July 2012 - 11:05 AM, said:

I'll check night after this..

Sheltatha Lore, on 27 July 2012 - 06:09 PM, said:

I don't have a good handle on Osseric. He did not strike me as too pushy, though.

Tellan looks more inno after the tantrum, but that's WIFOM.

To me Tellan seemed a lot more scummy after that tantrum. He thought we were going to lynch him over what he thought was nonsense so threw a fit. He didn't want to be caught out by something silly because he thinks he's played a clean game, or whatever he thought it did look like scrambling.

Or I'm town who gets annoyed at bullshit cases and people following them.

Quote

Tellan, on 27 July 2012 - 06:21 PM, said:

What's the vote counter? I'm watching Batman Begins, sorry for the long absences.

He's pointing this out why? I think he is saying that scum would stay away from the thread for as long as he did (which i don't know how long that was) no one has mentioned the absence but it is convenient for him to come back at the right time to influence the decision of the lynch.

This was at the end of the day when participation and talking is vital. I was apologizing because I kept getting distracted by the movie. My long absences were 5-20 minute periods, not hours.

Quote

Kaschan, on 27 July 2012 - 06:48 PM, said:

In case something happens re: time out

Vote Osseric

I'm going to look for Shel's post, phone won't stop here

This is awful voting. The lynch on Lio was building and in my opinion would have given us a lot more information than voting for someone who's got a witch as their avatar. This is one reason I think Kaschan is the other killer, the one laying low, he disregards everything that has been said on thread, votes where the masses are and disappears. He'll say the cases or points people have made are shit but not offer any of his own.

I actually agree with you here. 100%

Quote

Atrahal, on 27 July 2012 - 06:59 PM, said:

Vote Osseric

Eloth complaint led to people switching and maybe the swing to Lio was happening too fast

Happening too fast... LOL. We had 45 min left, if memory serves. Things tend to happen fast on that kind of a deadline.

Quote

Sheltatha Lore, on 27 July 2012 - 07:00 PM, said:

can we pls get an update?

remove vote

Shelly equalled things up so it stood like this

Path-Shaper, on 27 July 2012 - 07:01 PM, said:

It is Day 2. 6 minutes remaining
13 Players still alive: Atrahal, D'riss, Eloth, Kalse, Kaschan, Liosan, Osseric, Rashan, Sheltatha Lore, Sorrit, Telas, Tellan, Tennes

7 votes to lynch, 7 votes to go to night.

5 Votes for Osseric ( Eloth, Telas, Liosan, Kaschan, Atrahal )
5 Votes for Liosan ( D'riss, Tellan, Osseric, Tennes, Kalse )

Players not voted: Rashan, Sheltatha Lore, Sorrit

Tellan, on 27 July 2012 - 07:02 PM, said:

4 min,



Remove Vote



Vote Osseric

At the end of the day Tellan made the lynch of Osseric inevitable. He could say he was just trying to get the lynch but Shelly could have voted and there were people around. Tellan's play smacks of scum and if he does turn out to be town then we will still clear the water a lot rather than leaving it murky. In my opinion one of Lio or Tellan is scum. So let's find out.

[b]Vote Tellan

I said I was going to switch back to Osseric with 10 minutes left because we clearly had enough people to lynch him. I wanted a lynch. I gave it 6 extra minutes. I couldn't trust Shelly to vote AND someone else to switch. If we're lynching one of us, it should clearly be Liosan.

Unfortunately, I'm not confident that he'll come out scum. But I know I won't.

[Eloth]

Everyone thinks we should lynch Rashan or Kaschan. Now we need to find out who's play is scummy. methinks its Rashan .

[Telas]

Rashan? Only one person mentioned Rashan iirc. Care to explain that?

[Eloth]

How much has he been playing? We don't know his opinions, we have no content post of him, he is low poster. Scummy? yes please.

[Tennes]

It's not the day for a low poster hunt, if we fucking go for someone like Rashan then what information does that give us? Care to explain Eloth? You have no fucking content posts except your asking who's around or checking in posts. What do you make of Liosan, Kaschan, Tellan? If you want to "look" scummy whilst actually being town then that's great. I don't think of you as scum, I don't but don't play into their hands.

[Telas]

Eloth, on 30 July 2012 - 05:34 PM, said:

How much has he been playing? We don't know his opinions, we have no content post of him, he is low poster. Scummy? yes please.

Meanwhile let's forget about everyone who's been under the microscope: Tellan, Liosan, Kalse, etc. Amirite

[Tellan]

LOL. They have a point,

[Eloth]

Tennes, on 30 July 2012 - 05:50 PM, said:

It's not the day for a low poster hunt, if we fucking go for someone like Rashan then what information does that give us? Care to explain Eloth? You have no fucking content posts except your asking who's around or checking in posts. What do you make of Liosan, Kaschan, Tellan? If you want to "look" scummy whilst actually being town then that's great. I don't think of you as scum, I don't but don't play into their hands.

So you are saying we should lynch Tellan today and Liosan tomorrow so we can clear our suspect pools. good plan dear, go through with it.
while you were not around yesterday dear, we had quite the discussion , while you with only 2 useful posts today just voted and left.
Case on Kaschan is nothing other than low posting case. Tellan is not cleared in my mind but i'm sure the finder did a find on either him or Lio last night , and he is kind o' off my radar ATM.
between two low poster cases i prefer Rashan's, you have any problem with that?

[Kalse]

I'm here buy still hung over from the weekend, and stupidly over worked, just reading through doubt I will get a chance to do post much

[Telas]

lmao Eloth, Tennes makes a case, you do nothing but deflect from people's questions on you, have offhandedly misrepresented the Kaschan case as a mere low poster case, and then suggest that Rashan's low poster case is stronger based on...nothing?