[Korbas]

Korvalain's post seems the weakest evidence of the 4.

I'll discount mine, if possible.


I'm Scarecrow. Roled town. You can look back through my posts and find instances of me messing up with the RI pm and whatnot quite a few times. My PM is not the same. I'm a BP. No longer, of course, since ole Gusty shot me in the face. His death is unrelated to the removal of my BP, though.

That's the main worry I have with lynching the two that didn't know about this so called handing out of guns. But I'm willing to go for it.

Vote Rashan

Until we hear back from them.

[Telas]

Yeah, I know they could well be roled town. But since the c**t leaders...sorry, cult leaders, don't seem willing to make themselves useful and eliminate a few names, I'm putting out what I've seen.

[Korbas]

I'm glad I'm a role that doesn't matter if I get lynched. Unfortunately, I also have the characteristic of the CL, Bulletproof.

[Ampelas]

Here and reading up. Found Osseric last night, who was of the Joker gang.

[Korbas]

Ampelas, on 07 June 2012 - 02:55 PM, said:

Here and reading up. Found Osseric last night, who was of the Joker gang.

Lol.

[Telas]

In other news - bears shit in the woods!

[Atrahal]

I like Telas's post above enumerating the non-RI posters who were unaware of the weapon acquisition (or tied it to recruitment, which could mean they were recruits themselves). Problem is, if we eliminate recruits, we make it even more difficult to win as town. It's a delaying tactic, no more.

[Ampelas]

Not much to say about Meanas and Korbas screaming on-thread. Korbas seems reasonable, Meanas sounds like he is just spewing as much shit as he can.

[Telas]

By the way, I think we can eliminate Ampelas being the Joker. Eloth did lie about that. I already had major doubts after Meanas came on to berate his supposed master so strongly and deny their counter-argument.

[Ampelas]

Aaaaaand he's dead. Well, I guess that cancels that line of thought. Weird choice of NK if it was Batman, though. I guess BM was thinking back to Meanas' day 1 heat? But that was mostly about Meanas being a shitty towny, so odd for BM to want to test him just from that. I think this gives us a bit of insight into BM's strategy - testing/finding all the CLs before starting to take them out?

[Telas]

Ampelas for Batman? Batman for sure has to have a finder ability, no?

[Ampelas]

Osseric now claiming to have witnessed rooftop meetings or something like that? Is this another possible ability you can get from being recruited like what Meanas was claiming?

[Telas]

Ampelas, on 07 June 2012 - 03:16 PM, said:

Osseric now claiming to have witnessed rooftop meetings or something like that? Is this another possible ability you can get from being recruited like what Meanas was claiming?

PLEASE READ EVERYTHING BEFORE COMMENTING - TAKE NOTES OR SOMETHING!!!!

[Ampelas]

I was thinking the police captain/inspector/chief/guy, but the Hugo Strange idea could work too. Either way it seems weird to me that such a role could be recruited easily (though this wasn't known on thread so I'm not damning anyone).

[Omtose]

Korvalain, on 04 June 2012 - 01:28 PM, said:

Galain, on 04 June 2012 - 01:20 PM, said:

My lord, the brazen sexuality of today's youth. You'd almost think we were all sex-starved, serial rapist criminals or something...

Galain is a admitting to being a criminal!

Korbas, on 07 June 2012 - 02:44 PM, said:

Korvalain's post seems the weakest evidence of the 4.

I'll discount mine, if possible.


I'm Scarecrow. Roled town. You can look back through my posts and find instances of me messing up with the RI pm and whatnot quite a few times. My PM is not the same. I'm a BP. No longer, of course, since ole Gusty shot me in the face. His death is unrelated to the removal of my BP, though.

That's the main worry I have with lynching the two that didn't know about this so called handing out of guns. But I'm willing to go for it.

Vote Rashan

Until we hear back from them.

Yes but Korvalain was also the one that reacted to Galain's post about criminals. He also didn't know about weapons AND he is one of the lowest posters with very little content.

vote Korvalain

[Telas]

I think we need to get started on properly voting. Based on the fact that he's been on the trains both days, and didn't know about the weapons cache choice, and that he was reacting favourably to an Osseric as Batman lynch back on day 1,

Vote Rashan



If a cult leader would like to claim Rashan as their own, then I will remove vote and look elsewhere.

[Atrahal]

Telas, on 07 June 2012 - 03:21 PM, said:

I think we need to get started on properly voting. Based on the fact that he's been on the trains both days, and didn't know about the weapons cache choice, and that he was reacting favourably to an Osseric as Batman lynch back on day 1,

Vote Rashan



If a cult leader would like to claim Rashan as their own, then I will remove vote and look elsewhere.

Concur

Vote Rashan

[Korbas]

Telas, on 07 June 2012 - 03:17 PM, said:

Ampelas, on 07 June 2012 - 03:16 PM, said:

Osseric now claiming to have witnessed rooftop meetings or something like that? Is this another possible ability you can get from being recruited like what Meanas was claiming?

PLEASE READ EVERYTHING BEFORE COMMENTING - TAKE NOTES OR SOMETHING!!!!

Dkt catchups arres o fun though

[Anomandaris]

Korbas, on 07 June 2012 - 02:44 PM, said:

Korvalain's post seems the weakest evidence of the 4.

I'll discount mine, if possible.


I'm Scarecrow. Roled town. You can look back through my posts and find instances of me messing up with the RI pm and whatnot quite a few times. My PM is not the same. I'm a BP. No longer, of course, since ole Gusty shot me in the face. His death is unrelated to the removal of my BP, though.

That's the main worry I have with lynching the two that didn't know about this so called handing out of guns. But I'm willing to go for it.

Vote Rashan

Until we hear back from them.

I understand where korbas is coming from, considering I'm roled town as well. I guess thats the reason that we had no clue about the secret caches. I could tell you my name and ability, but I like to maintain some level of secrecy

Telas, on 07 June 2012 - 03:21 PM, said:

I think we need to get started on properly voting. Based on the fact that he's been on the trains both days, and didn't know about the weapons cache choice, and that he was reacting favourably to an Osseric as Batman lynch back on day 1,

Vote Rashan



If a cult leader would like to claim Rashan as their own, then I will remove vote and look elsewhere.

I can agree with this as well until Rashan refutes it. We now have a relative list of people who are not BM and he is not on it.

Vote Rashan

[Ampelas]

Karosis, on 07 June 2012 - 12:03 AM, said:

As far as I'm concerned, Eloth's lynch BP shows that the game design is fundamentally opposed to us trying to take out the cult. And given that, the only option really is to go full steam ahead in a Batman hunt. The no-lynch gives us the certainty we need about how this game is laid out to progress down the right path. For sure we have to keep an eye on the cult, but as town we can't kill them without vigs, at least not efficiently enough for it to be viable. The efficient solution is to trust Batman to keep them in line. More than any words from Eloth or Meanas, the results of the lynch attempt prove that.

I have no regrets about the results from the day. Rushing head long into a game like this without understanding the mechanics at play would not have served us well. But with what we know now, we can get somewhere, we can figure out a coherent plan. So let's draw a line under the conflict from yesterday, and focus on Bat hunting on the morrow.

Not sure I agree with this. If Eloth having an LP means we shouldn't lynch him, what does that mean about Batman having 4 LPs???