[Gamelon]

I'm out - I will be back before time out

[Hood's Path]

 Path-Shaper, on 06 December 2011 - 10:26 PM, said:

Post times are on thread, yes, but it is still a speculative meta argument unless I completely misunderstand the definition of meta.

My initial inclination is not to mod-kill anybody, just give a warning - but this has nothing to do with a player's actual play, but when they allegedly are or are not on thread.

listen if dibs wants to be mental and shoot at shin then really that is only morgoths business well perhaps its dkt's too but it is most definately not ja's as he is still asleep the same can be said about gh, vengy and obdi but no one had better speed lynch the dude before pb gets up or else drek will flip out

[Omtose]

SO i have my list like this:

Gamelon/Atrahal Undecided. but my 2 best bets for scum atm.

Tennes-- Only because I think it would be weird if him and Mockra did the whole HP case together. I am not sure if he is symp or inno. He comes after me for no interaction with Mockra... thats valid. But I think a lot of other people fit that category. My quote he brought up about Ruse being inno making Mockra look inno... I face palmed when I read it. I look like an idiot.

Spite-- As some have pointed out... he laid in the weeds. He also cam on and explained that, as well as said he would more active this week. His story checks out. but Tennes had a good post early on where Mockra and him butted heads. Didn't get a partner vibe. Also, if he came on, played the RL card, contemplated a modkill on thread, and used that as a tacttic.. cheap.. very cheap. You can have the win if you want to play that way as scum.


Meanas-- Mockra tried to mod kill him, and they butted heads. Very possible a symp, but probably not a killer.


HP/Anno--- Cleared by the finder

Emur-- Finder

Omtose- Angelic and the pictue of innocence.



I suggest Emur ( if for some reason he is still alive come tomorrow) find me Gamelon or Atrahal (whoever we don't lynch). As we are top suspects, it would put minds at ease.

[Omtose]

 Hood, on 07 December 2011 - 01:06 AM, said:

 Path-Shaper, on 06 December 2011 - 10:26 PM, said:

Post times are on thread, yes, but it is still a speculative meta argument unless I completely misunderstand the definition of meta.

My initial inclination is not to mod-kill anybody, just give a warning - but this has nothing to do with a player's actual play, but when they allegedly are or are not on thread.

listen if dibs wants to be mental and shoot at shin then really that is only morgoths business well perhaps its dkt's too but it is most definately not ja's as he is still asleep the same can be said about gh, vengy and obdi but no one had better speed lynch the dude before pb gets up or else drek will flip out

Well played sir.

[Emurlahn]

 Omtose, on 07 December 2011 - 12:58 AM, said:

 Emurlahn, on 06 December 2011 - 02:15 PM, said:

 Tennes, on 06 December 2011 - 09:41 AM, said:

These two quotes from meanas makes me tend to agree with your evaluation of him Ano....

 Meanas, on 01 December 2011 - 04:39 PM, said:

 Path-Shaper, on 01 December 2011 - 12:23 AM, said:

It is Day 2, 3 hours and 1 minute are left.

15 players alive: Anomandaris, Atrahal, Emurlahn, Galain, Gamelon, Hood's Path, Meanas, Mockra, Omtose, Osseric, Rashan, Ruse, Spite, Tennes, Thryllan

8 votes to lynch

5 votes Thyrllan: Spite, Meanas, Rashan, Mockra, Gamelon
4 votes Ruse: Omtose, Thyrllan, Galain, Osseric





Players not voting: Anomandaris, Atrahal, Emurlahn, Hood's Path, Ruse, Tennes,

Yeah, I'm a big fan of momentum. Mockra and Gamelon turbo vote Thyr when Ruse starts to build heat. Eenteresting.

 Meanas, on 01 December 2011 - 04:43 PM, said:

I'm totally down with a Mockra lynch. That was some really dodgy stuff yesterday after Ruse was getting all kinds of heat.

That said, I'm voting for Ruse right now because that's who was saved by the misdirection.

Vote Ruse

not something i would think a killer partner would be saying that early in the game...drawing attention to his partner would be pointless.

Your last quote there actually makes me want to vote Meanas more. My Mockra case was NOT good. This looks more like a killer distancing himself from his partner but not actually leveling any serious accusations. Hasn't Meanas been pretty middle of the road so far?

Not sure why you would want to vote Meanas because of this. There was not much push for a mockra lynch. Hard to believe a Killer partner would throw his buddy under the bus like that.

The throwaway comment on being "okay with it" while there was actually no danger of it going down seems like the behavior of someone who doesn't want to draw attention to Mockra, so they would know who he was.

I'm thinking Meanas is a symp, maybe. I dunno if he's a killer with the way Mockra did that modkill thing

[Omtose]

Well, I am around for the next 1-2 hrs off and on. then I have to vote. I am going to be voting Atrahal or Gamelon. Unless something ground breaking happens.

[Atrahal]

And that is yet another unsubstantiated comment against me (I was clumped with Gamelon and not even given a paragraph by Omtose). I know, lets lynch Omtose and either find me or gamelon. /sarcasm

[Atrahal]

Gamelon, to prevent the same thing being done to you that keeps getting done to me, let me lay out why you are a suspect in my estimation:

Most of your posts are one liners, often questions (good questions, but still mostly questions). You continually defer to being busy at work or with family, but rarely show up on thread (why play the game if you are just lurking for the hell of it?). In fact, I think at least half of your posts have some reference to returning after this and that, be back in 10 minutes, etc. In fact you promised a very thorough read through this weekend, and so far you have given us about as much as Mockra's non-existent list of suspects.

More specifically, looking at your cases for your lynch votes, day 1 you said Kesso seemed like the most convincing case (and that was all) before laying down your vote. Day 2, you objected to Thyr's "lack-of-symp" comment and said Thyr's attempt at making a case wasn't convincing. Really not much more than that and Day 2 you voted for Thyr. And then, I don't see any more votes from you (though it sounds as though, surprise surprise, Ruse was your second choice following Thyr).

Yesterday, you speak up in support of Emur and doubt of Mockra, and today say "Spite is looking mighty yummy" mostly for his obvious absence and recent reappearance (not much more to your accusation than that).

Now you don't say anything particularly stupid or blatant that I could find, but you are playing a smooth quiet game that sometimes tries to rattle the cage but for the most part just goes with the flow.

[Emurlahn]

Now look at my example. I post both stupidly AND blatantly. And often. So wooh! /waves finger/

But really, you seem like you're sliding by. Easy to hide a scum in people like you and Meanas.

[Atrahal]

 Emurlahn, on 07 December 2011 - 01:53 AM, said:

Now look at my example. I post both stupidly AND blatantly. And often. So wooh! /waves finger/

But really, you seem like you're sliding by. Easy to hide a scum in people like you and Meanas.

How have I been sliding by you ass? I would have been ready to build a case on you as soon as I got home if it wasn't for the fact that you revealed and confirmed with a scum lynch. Do I have to post stupidly to be untouchable? Should I reveal my role? What do you want Emur? I build cases, point out suspicions, respond to comments, and vote for scummy targets. Did I miss some idiot requirement to be in your circle?

[Atrahal]

If you notice, most of the time I just ignore you... and that's not easy to do...

[Emurlahn]

I was talking to Gamelon, brother.

Your idiocy level has not nearly reached mine, sorry.

You remain outside the circle.

Your game has been well played regardless of if you're scum or inno. You've been helpful but at the same time kept a somewhat low profile (less so toward the end of the game). So if you're inno this has kept you from being NKed like so many other high posters. If you're scum, it's been a good enough balance to not make you appear overtly scummy.

Don't take out your anger on me!

[Emurlahn]

And re: You ignoring me.

Regardless of some of my more silly posts, I make legitimate points and try to induce discussion as often as possible.

I can get into serious mode, if you want. It's just kinda boring until right before lynch.

[Atrahal]

Sorry Emur. I'm just a little testy after Omtose's non-case on me. I'm tired of not having anything to defend against from so many people...

[Emurlahn]

I kinda wanna die tonight. SH is teasing me... I demand knowledge.

But I suppose it'd be better if I can get one more find off.

[Atrahal]

Yeah, it is boring. I just can't understand how people like you and Spite who make such raucous remarks can somehow move on without suspicious and yet more ernest, serious, glum-buckets like myself and Galain can be cast in such suspicious light...

[Atrahal]

Can't die on us now Mr. Finder. We actually have a shot.

[Emurlahn]

Speaking of boring... dead thread.

Shit better happen while I'm asleep.

[Atrahal]

^

[Omtose]

Atrahal- I have no case against you. It's process of elimination. You and gamelon are the two with the most question marks. Don't get all butt hurt. It's mafia. Now come to the big boys table, start playing and quit bitching.

I'm on my phone and going to bed. Not sure if I can bold on my phone. I'll try, but if it doesn't work I hope PS will accept my vote as I won't have CPU access before timer is up.

vote Gamelon