[Grief]

It's getting to the stage where I feel the finders are almost certainly going to hit MH soon(since the other can avoid who tat targets, leaving not that much overlap). This would be bad for us. However, the other finder probably has a fair amount of info, which would really allow us to narrow it down for our next choice, giving us a really good chance of lynching MH, which would be good.

I can't really think of a downside to a finder reveal at this point. Having a hidden finder doesn't really give us an advantage in this game, and restricts our info.

[Khellendros]

The downside is if there's a symp out there who pretends to be a finder to sow confusion and cast doubt on the true finders, but I am now of the opinion that the benefit will outweigh the risk.

[Gust Hubb]

So, I just want to see where everyone is. Appears to me that Grief, Kells, Tat, and myself want to know who the second finder is and see no risk in such a reveal.

Venge seems to agree, albeit reluctantly since he didn't want Tat's reveal in the first place.

Shin and ansible seems diametrically opposed, and I would like to here from KM.

I'm missing 3 people...

[Gust Hubb]

Oh, Ment, Roldom and HO

I think Roldom was in on the calling for a second find. Not sure about Ment and HO (two others I would like to hear from)

[Vengeance]

Ok since I am tired of this I have decided to reveal my finds. Just remember that you lot brought this upon yourself.


Day 1 Mental - I looked at him because he is always my number 1 suspect

Day 2 Grief - Seemed like he was trying to slid by.

Day 3 Tatter - She revealed I wanted to make sure that she wasn't MH.

Day 4 Roldom - Now I started to choose people at random

Day 5 Khell - Same reason


Now I hate finder reveals more then anything else except for slow stupid games, which this has became. So there you are. Laters

[Gust Hubb]

Excellent. Thanks for coming out of the closet. This is good. Also seems to confirm tat, though, venge, did your finds say whether or not he was a FK?

[Vengeance]

Gust Hubb, on 19 July 2011 - 05:26 PM, said:

Excellent. Thanks for coming out of the closet. This is good. Also seems to confirm tat, though, venge, did your finds say whether or not he was a FK?

No

[Gust Hubb]

Tat, does that gel with what you've experienced? Can we trust you two?

[Vengeance]

Gust Hubb, on 19 July 2011 - 05:30 PM, said:

Tat, does that gel with what you've experienced? Can we trust you two?

I wouldn't trust us. But then in mafia I wouldn't trust my own mother.

[Khellendros]

So the non-MH players are: Mentalist, Gust Hubb, HiddenOne, Grief, Roldom - and Venge will confirm I am also not MH once he does his find on me

Tattersail and Vengeance are the FKs.

Leaving myself (until Venge's find), Shinrei, Kurt Montandon, and ansible as MH.

Out of those my biggest suspect is Kurt probably.

[Khellendros]

If we believe Tat and Venge, obviously, which I'm foolhardily going to do.

[Gust Hubb]

I would currently lean that way as well. I don't know Kurt that well, but unless he plays really differently each game, he is really quiet this game.

Vote Kurt Montandon

for now, unless some of the veterans can let me know that Kurt is a very flexible player with a diverse (loud and quiet) role set.

[Vengeance]

Well I am going to vote for Shin. Because I hate to see players almost get lynched then not get lynched. It has came back to bite me in the ass to many times.


Vote
SHin

[Gust Hubb]

Also, another thought, do we really want to do finds tonight? We have four suspects left (if Tat and Venge agree they are getting the same info and thus are plausibly FK and if no other FK shows up...), and a FK from both Tat and Venge will cause a 50/50 chance of hitting MH. We have the potentials down to a small enough number, so we don't have to waste a FK quite yet.

[Vengeance]

Gust Hubb, on 19 July 2011 - 05:41 PM, said:

Also, another thought, do we really want to do finds tonight? We have four suspects left (if Tat and Venge agree they are getting the same info and thus are plausibly FK and if no other FK shows up...), and a FK from both Tat and Venge will cause a 50/50 chance of hitting MH. We have the potentials down to a small enough number, so we don't have to waste a FK quite yet.

I doubt that Kell would agree with you GH.

[Vengeance]

Actually going over the remaining players I think that Ansible is to suspicious. Mostly due to his absence.



Remove Vote

Vote for Ansible

[Gust Hubb]

Well, he is on the list of suspects. And there are two options: find or lynch. If Kell was MH, this would be an ideal opportunity to give the town the finger and waste a find-kill. Plus, he didn't seem so eager earlier in the game.

[Gust Hubb]

Don't forget that KM has popped onto this thread several times without commenting, which is suspicious considering how close he is to being lynched.

[Kurt Montandon]

Gust Hubb, on 19 July 2011 - 05:37 PM, said:

I would currently lean that way as well. I don't know Kurt that well, but unless he plays really differently each game, he is really quiet this game.

Vote Kurt Montandon

for now, unless some of the veterans can let me know that Kurt is a very flexible player with a diverse (loud and quiet) role set.

No, just a busy one.

I haven't seen much change in this game since I last commented, in any case.

Besides Venge's reveal, though that was kind of predictable.

[Gust Hubb]

Like right now.