[Lizradusa]

There are something like 50 minutes left.

5 votes on The Dude right now and 2 on shin

[The Dude]

you guys are being silly. I am a RI General. Thats how I knew that Roldom was RI.if you think it will helpthe cause I will vote myself. But I have no role, take a look at tapper and shin when I am gone.

[The Dude]

Yue Jiu. I am a military commander for teh good guys. whilemy lynch will give us a train,we are still going to be losing an inno and we seem to have lost 4 of them already. I really don't like Grief's vote. PB'sismoreunderstandable. I am not sure how my case is OMGUS. I made points based on observation. Because the points were directed at me i noticed and scrutinized them more than most. It might seem omgu, but I feel I backed up my vote with quality points.

[Grief]

Only 20 minutes or so left.

[Mentalist]

how many votes do we need?

[Grief]

Two, I think.

[Hugin & Munin]

It is Day 2. 24 minutes remaining
13 Players still alive: Ace Hunter, ansible, dibs, Grief, HiddenOne, Lizra, Mentalist, MTS, PB, Shinrei, Tapper, The Dude, Trull's son

7 votes to lynch, 7 votes to go to night.

2 Votes for Trull's son ( Shinrei, dibs )
5 Votes for The Dude ( Tapper, Grief, PB, Lizra, HiddenOne )
2 Votes for Shinrei ( The Dude, Mentalist )

Players not voted: Ace Hunter, ansible, MTS, Trull's son

[Mentalist]

who else is around?

[ansible]

I've been reading tCG a lot so I don't have time to go point by point, but:

The case against Shin seems weak to me. MTS makes an interesting connection with the quote about Tapper's posts...and Silencer seemed all but unlynchable after the heat of Day 1 passed. The Dude has become really defensive after people didn't take to his long post filled with "compliments", and he kept bringing it up and asking people to explain.... a little too much attention was given to that post, which didn't really make a case for anyone, anyway. I also agree that the Tapper-as-symp theory is too obvious, and The Dude is voting Shin...

The Dude, on 23 February 2011 - 08:59 PM, said:

To answer your points:

1. Thats absurd and you are reaching. If I am going to do a list of people and I am a killer Im not going to leave out the person I kill. Clearly that person would be on my mind. iirc Roldom had posted next to nothing in the thread up to that point. Someone (Trull i believe) went back to look at Roldom's posts and came up with exactly 1 post of relevence.

This is probably true...but why the detail? Seems like the whole question of whether or not Roldom would be on a killer's list is WIFOM anyway. Weird. Easiest way to sound convincing is to tell the truth, right? And Silencer was on his list. That's not proof of anything, unfortunately, but...

Vote The Dude

[Hugin & Munin]

Timer momentarily paused while I resolve stuff, 1 sec.

This post has been edited by Hugin & Munin: 24 February 2011 - 03:35 AM

[Hugin & Munin]

News of the fall of San Pass was reported in Tian Shi, so the general Pang Yi lead his army out of the city and south. In San Pass, Ma Chao could do little but watch while the Lu main army from Han Zhong blocked the pass to the south and Pang Yi's army to the north. Ma Chao's officers advised they break out before the encirclement was complete, so Chao had his soldiers sabotage the southern gate of the pass and charged the northern army. Pang Yi's forces set spears to hold back Ma Chao's advance, but the Guanxi soldiers feinted to either side. Pang Yi's forces spread to match the Guanxi offense, at which point Ma Chao personally charged the center of the Lu troops and pushed back the center line. Falling in behind their commander, the Guanxi charged the Lu troops, broke through the center and raced for their ships. Pang Yi's troops pursued, leaping onto the enemy ships.

Battles raged on every ship, until each was secured for one force or the other. Then the ships set upon each other with ballistae and rams. Ma Chao's ship fled north but Pang Yi's ship had more rowers and caught the fleeing Chao swiftly. Leaping aboard, Pang Yi found heaps of straw and an enraged Ma Chao holding aloft a torch. The Guanxi general let out a thunderous laugh then threw the torch into the straw and leaped overboard. Pang Yi fled to his ship, but the flames followed and burned it down. Unable to swim, Pang Yi drowned in the swift currents.

Peanutbutta is dead. He was Pang Yi, General Who Suppresses the North of the Lu Dynasty

---


It is Day 2. 23 minutes remaining
12 Players still alive: Ace Hunter, ansible, dibs, Grief, HiddenOne, Lizra, Mentalist, MTS, Shinrei, Tapper, The Dude, Trull's son

7 votes to lynch, 6 votes to go to night.

2 Votes for Trull's son ( Shinrei, dibs )
4 Votes for The Dude ( Tapper, Grief, Lizra, HiddenOne )
2 Votes for Shinrei ( The Dude, Mentalist )

Players not voted: Ace Hunter, ansible, MTS, Trull's son
---

TIMER RESUMED!

This post has been edited by Hugin & Munin: 24 February 2011 - 09:39 PM

[Hugin & Munin]

It is Day 2. 22.5 minutes remaining
12 Players still alive: Ace Hunter, ansible, dibs, Grief, HiddenOne, Lizra, Mentalist, MTS, Shinrei, Tapper, The Dude, Trull's son

7 votes to lynch, 6 votes to go to night.

2 Votes for Trull's son ( Shinrei, dibs )
5 Votes for The Dude ( Tapper, Grief, Lizra, HiddenOne, ansible )
2 Votes for Shinrei ( The Dude, Mentalist )

Players not voted: Ace Hunter, MTS, Trull's son

[Shinrei]

The Dude, on 24 February 2011 - 03:13 AM, said:

you guys are being silly. I am a RI General. Thats how I knew that Roldom was RI.if you think it will helpthe cause I will vote myself. But I have no role, take a look at tapper and shin when I am gone.

The Dude's case on me was pretty OMGUS, and I felt his points of attack were opportunistic and tenuous at best. However, I wasn't expecting the vote to actually swing to him.

Remove Vote
Vote The Dude
There's very little time for someone else to come on and challenge your particular name reveal. More importantly, I want to know what you are claiming to back up that underlined part. How does you being a general make it known to you that Roldom was a general?

[Shinrei]

Holy Twisted CrossPost Batman.

[MTS]

Hmm, well someone clearly doesn't want this lynch to go through. While I think The Dude has some questions attached to his play, I think Tapper's outburst is more worthy of attention. While I think Tapper's maybe a better bet for scum, the lynch is better than nothing.

Vote The Dude

[Mentalist]

Okay

WHAT

THE

FUCK?


just how many damn vigs do we have?

[Shinrei]

H^M, is that supposed to be 25 minutes left, I assume?

[HiddenOne]

The Dude's reveal was too convenient for me - out of nowhere, then his next post throws a name, Why not the first time?

Convinced me to stay where I am in the vote.

[Shinrei]

Mentalist, on 24 February 2011 - 03:44 AM, said:

Okay

WHAT

THE

FUCK?


just how many damn vigs do we have?

Did I miss something? There was one kill yesterday, and two today right? That would only be one vig by my figuring.

[ansible]

Mentalist, on 24 February 2011 - 03:44 AM, said:

Okay

WHAT

THE

FUCK?


just how many damn vigs do we have?

Isn't the more obvious answer that there's two killers?