[Galayn Lord]

Ugh, it posted too early. Anyway thats if you were going to believe the story about the disk etc, of course maybe that doesn't count as off thread comms.


So Korv, who are you going to vote for? I need to get going and whichever way you go I suspect I will have to follow or we are going to miss a lynch completely.

[Korvalain]

Id like to point out i stated quite clearly why i did not want to post for kasle or osseric?

and ive came back to change my vote to get a lynch if needed

bargahst could also change his vote atm to get a lynch yet hes having a go at me for wasting my vote? When after his point is made about me, people have voted for someone else and his vote now is as useless as mine?

ive already pointed out that id choose to lynch osseric out of the two and as its my choice

again on phone so cannot bold (hoping the mod can tidy up for me )

remove vote

vote osseric

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 13 October 2010 - 07:46 PM

[Barghast]

Well passing information is not the same as off-thread comms, IMO. To me, it's a lot like the ability I got night 1.

And if it somehow IS really off-thread comms and he's faking it with this disk story, it probably makes him Eldar because, if you think about it, Chaos (if they can comm off-threadf) are probably too busy trying to possess to use abilities like finds. And cult have never historically had the power to communicate off-thread. If Necron is solo, Eldar is the only possibility since I believe they are a group of specialists with unique powers. And that makes him a bad lynch.

Of course, conversely, it also means he thinks is faction is closing in on a win and is trying to move toward majority by eliminating people not in his faction, which indicates that he's either trying to save Korv, or just keep the whole thing too messy to dilute to the truth.

[Barghast]

@Osseric, it's discussion. You were tied up until this point.

@GL, Osseric has history on his side, if nothing else.

@Korv, I had a go at you because you voted for someone pointless and I didn't realize you'd be back to help lynch.

Looks like we're 4-3 Osseric-Kalse right now.

[Barghast]

Look, I'll just be honest, of the two, I think I'm leaning toward Kalse. Osseric has a greater chance in my mind of being Eldar. Kalse has a greater chance of being cult, even if just a recruit. If that's the #1 goal, we gotta go for the Cult. I doubt any faction wins based off of this lynch, although it is in all likelihood D-Day from here on out... we'll have to assume Cult are 1 person away, and other assumptions based upon the night results and the Kalse CF.

[Barghast]

Remove Vote
Vote Kalse

[Galayn Lord]

So Barghast from that, I take it you would lynch Kalse then? Korv has just gone to Osseric, so thats 4 Osseric, 3 Kalse I believe. Although if I switch to Kalse, and you go Kalse that would be 5, so we'd need one more.

[Alkend]

Just getting up ... shit, not much time left, looks to be about forty minutes.

I'd rather go for Korv, but I don't think that's going to happen in the waning minutes. Hmmm ...

[Barghast]

It should be 4-4 now... We're stuck waiting for 1 vote no matter what.

[Osseric]

Well, here we go 4-4.

@GL I am not communicating with anyone. I have been sent a message. After the person is dead. I know this doesn;t count as off thread comms. because I am not Xeno, and I am getting the messages. Easy for me to say, impossible for me to prove, all I know is I gave town one Xeno and am trying to give them another... granted, the info could be faked... but it was correct the first time.. so do what you will.

[Korvalain]

Cant quote on this thing but u asked about who i was going to vote for because to get a lynch you would need to join your vote with mine

thats not technicaly true, if barghast jumped off the fence you two would still be able to put the lynch on kalse if you choose too

[Barghast]

Well, Alkend's here now so I think we can hash it out. Amusing his favorite case today was mine.

[Barghast]

Maybe Osseric is getting the info when important characters die? Like squad leaders? Doesn't explain why Osseric is getting it, tho.

[Osseric]

Barghast, on 13 October 2010 - 04:18 PM, said:

Look, I'll just be honest, of the two, I think I'm leaning toward Kalse. Osseric has a greater chance in my mind of being Eldar. Kalse has a greater chance of being cult, even if just a recruit. If that's the #1 goal, we gotta go for the Cult. I doubt any faction wins based off of this lynch, although it is in all likelihood D-Day from here on out... we'll have to assume Cult are 1 person away, and other assumptions based upon the night results and the Kalse CF.

This is also true. If you truly think I am scum.. what race could I be? it would have to be Eldar as I am outing Xeno's... at that point why would you want to lynch me? It makes no sense.

Also, @ Barghast I would be willing to vote for Korv as well, but after seeing the tide switch so dramatically to me, I think the cult has quite a few members.

[Alkend]

Barghast, on 13 October 2010 - 04:24 PM, said:

Well, Alkend's here now so I think we can hash it out. Amusing his favorite case today was mine.

I'm now convinced that you at least started the game Inno.

[Galayn Lord]

Osseric, on 13 October 2010 - 04:24 PM, said:

Well, here we go 4-4.

@GL I am not communicating with anyone. I have been sent a message. After the person is dead. I know this doesn;t count as off thread comms. because I am not Xeno, and I am getting the messages. Easy for me to say, impossible for me to prove, all I know is I gave town one Xeno and am trying to give them another... granted, the info could be faked... but it was correct the first time.. so do what you will.

Sure the problem is of course that you could have given us an Eldar and now given us Eldar number 2! And also the person who gave you the first find is now dead? And you got another one? From beyond the grave again...

[Korvalain]

Sorry cross posted barghast hase came off the fence now

admitidly hes tied up the vote lol
if osserics eldar than kalse is aswell

why would an eldar draw attention to themselves and get rid of a choas player? Wouldnt be worth it

[Osseric]

Barghast, on 13 October 2010 - 04:27 PM, said:

Maybe Osseric is getting the info when important characters die? Like squad leaders? Doesn't explain why Osseric is getting it, tho.

ding ding ding

[Galayn Lord]

Hmm hold on.. I just spotted the flaw in my logic there.. i would of course be voting an Eldar anyway! Doh - tha would make no sense at all. Argh well that changes things a little, I can discount that cos its lose - lose no matter what way I look at it. The other scenarios are much less likely for Osseric to be scum and more exotic, at this point I am happy to swap over to Kalse.

Remove Vote
Vote Kalse

[Barghast]

@Alkend, Thanks, I think?
@GL, if you read any of the giant blocks of posts I've laid out it should be pretty clear that Osseric is very unlikely to be Eldar outing his team. He could be Eldar outing other teams, but there isn't enough evidence to support or refute that theory.